10 Movies of 2024 That Missed Expectations for Box Office Success

As 2024 closed its curtains, film enthusiasts evaluated a year that brought both a wealth of cinematic innovation and disappointment. From acclaimed titles like Anora and The Brutalist to commercial blockbusters such as Inside Out 2 and Deadpool & Wolverine, the year’s offerings illuminated the diverse landscape of filmmaking. These films captivated audiences, reaffirming the magic of the cinema experience. However, as with any year, not all releases met the lofty expectations set by fans and critics alike, leading to discussions on which films fell short of their potential.

Several notable films left viewers and analysts scratching their heads as they failed to resonate as anticipated. Some examples failed due to subpar execution, others by not aligning with audience interests, ultimately resulting in a lackluster impact on popular culture.

10 for Argy

Directed By Matthew Vaughn

The start of 2024 buzzed with excitement for Argylle, largely thanks to its association with the beloved Kingsman franchise. Featuring a wealth of talent including Bryce Dallas Howard, Sam Rockwell, and Henry Cavill, many anticipated a thrilling ride. Despite these expectations, the film quickly stumbled, suffering from convoluted storytelling and inadequate humor. Critically panned and a box office disappointment, Argylle failed to generate the enthusiasm hoped for as it struggled to recoup its significant budget.

9 IF

Directed By John Krasinski

The whimsical premise of IF had many cheering for its success. John Krasinski’s exploration of a young girl intertwining with the imaginary friends of former children offered a unique perspective, especially with a cast featuring Ryan Reynolds and Steve Carell. Unfortunately, the film garnered mixed reviews and a lack of box office success. While Krasinski’s attempt at a family movie was commendable, audiences left feeling that the execution fell flat. It struggled to compare favorably to other family offerings that year.

8 Drive-Away Dolls

Directed By Ethan Coen

Fans anticipated great things from Drive-Away Dolls, the first solo project by Ethan Coen. Featuring a notable cast, including Pedro Pascal, excitement rapidly turned to disappointment as the film’s humor was perceived as excessive and unsatisfying. The once-promising project failed to meet the standards set by previous Coen brother collaborations, leaving audiences wanting more.

7 Joker: Madness for Two

Directed By Todd Philips

The sequel to the critically acclaimed Joker, titled Folie à Deux, drew immense hype due to the return of Joaquin Phoenix. With Lady Gaga joining the cast, expectations soared. However, the decision to incorporate musical elements divided audiences. While creative, this departure from the original’s tone left many fans unsatisfied, resulting in a sequel that fell short of its predecessor’s legacy.

6 Trap

Directed By M. Night Shyamalan

M. Night Shyamalan’s Trap generated its own buzz, featuring Josh Hartnett in a thriller about a serial killer on the run. Despite an engaging premise, the film polarized audiences, with critiques pinpointing its unrealistic dialogue and implausible ending as major drawbacks. While not a total failure, Trap struggled to match the acclaim of Shyamalan’s earlier work.

5 Y2K

Directed By Kyle Mooney

Y2K aimed to captivate as a distinct horror-comedy set on the cusp of the millennium. With a talented young cast and an intriguing plotline, expectations were high. Unfortunately, it failed to appeal to audiences, earning less than five million dollars at the box office. Critics noted that the film’s genre-blending left many confused, resulting in a lack of strong viewer engagement.

4 Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga

Directed By George Miller

Fans of the Mad Max series eagerly awaited Furiosa, the latest addition to the franchise. While critically recognized for its action and strong performances, the movie did not replicate the box office success of Fury Road, making over $170 million but deemed insufficient against its high budget. Longer gaps between releases may have contributed to its lukewarm commercial reception.

3 wolves

Directed By Jon Watts

Excitement followed the release of Wolfs, an action-comedy reuniting George Clooney and Brad Pitt. However, a limited one-week theatrical run before streaming on Apple TV+ drastically reduced its momentum. With mixed reviews highlighting the leads’ performances, the movie struggled to find its footing amidst viewer expectations.

2 Civil War

Directed By Alex Garland

Civil War positioned itself as one of 2024’s most anticipated films from the creative minds at A24. Despite a solid box office showing, many viewers found themselves disappointed with its narrative focus. Rather than the anticipated exploration of a nation torn apart, it centered more on a group of reporters amidst the background chaos. Despite generally positive reviews, it didn’t fulfill the expectations set by its title.

1 MaXXXine

Directed By Ti West

In 2024, MaXXXine aimed to conclude Ti West’s X trilogy amidst high expectations. Set in 1985 Los Angeles, it was anticipated to deliver thrilling narratives similar to Pearl. Sadly, it failed to captivate audiences, missing the mark set by its predecessors in a crowded horror film landscape.

Source & Images