Christmas specials often evoke images of joy and festivity on television, but some memorable episodes embrace the more somber aspects of the holiday season. While classics like A Charlie Brown Christmas are cherished by families worldwide, others prefer a Christmas special that confronts the stark realities that the holiday can bring. It’s essential for TV shows to maintain their unique voices and creativity, even when delving into the complexities often overshadowed by joy and togetherness.
Though traditional holiday specials certainly have their place, the appeal of a Christmas episode that challenges the typical festive narrative is undeniable. Among the surprisingly dark Christmas specials, many stand out as iconic examples of storytelling that resonates deeply, demonstrating that darkness can coexist with holiday themes.
10 “The Doctor, The Widow And The Wardrobe”
Season 2, Episode 8: Doctor Who (1963 – Present)
The beloved British sci-fi series Doctor Who has delivered numerous holiday specials over its extensive history. Following its revival in 2005, special episodes became a cherished tradition, allowing families to gather and partake in the seasonal viewing experience. While many specials leaned towards the light and whimsical, “The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe” ventured into heavier themes.
This episode, set in 1938, introduces Madge Arwell, who aids the Eleventh Doctor in reuniting with his TARDIS. As the backdrop of World War II looms, the tales of loss and sacrifice emerge, encapsulating the bittersweet nature of the holidays. With moments of humor intertwined with poignant reflections on grief, this special adeptly illustrates the harsh realities that some families face during Christmas.
9 “Abed’s Uncontrollable Christmas”
Season 2, Episode 11: Community (2009 – 2014)
The sitcom Community took creative risks in exploring different genres, and its Christmas special, “Abed’s Uncontrollable Christmas,” was no exception. Utilizing a stop-motion animation style reminiscent of beloved classics like the 1964 Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, the episode arrives at a psychological crisis for Abed after learning that his mother won’t be visiting for the holiday.
This inventive narrative intertwines themes of mental health with holiday cheer, showcasing how loneliness can permeate the festive season. While the original Christmas specials often focus on merriment and family, this episode from Community maintains its signature humor while addressing deeper emotional issues through the story of a found family coming together to support one another.
8 “Xmas Story”
Season 2, Episode 4: Futurama (1999 – Present)
In the animated series Futurama, the 30th-century setting provided a unique backdrop for satire, including critiques of modern Christmas traditions. The episode “Xmas Story” reveals Fry’s nostalgia while juxtaposing futuristic celebrations that have strayed from their Christian roots. It introduces a sinister twist with the robotic Santa Claus, who, instead of spreading joy, determines to eliminate those deemed naughty.
The episode combines elements of festive cheer with darker themes of violence, crafting a memorable experience marked by excess and chaos—qualities that mark Fry’s first Christmas in the future as anything but peaceful.
7 “Sabrina’s Christmas Wish”
2014 Christmas Special: BoJack Horseman (2014 – 2020)
In stark contrast to conventional holiday cheer, the critically acclaimed series BoJack Horseman utilized its 2014 Christmas special as a commentary on the absurdity of typical Christmas narratives. The episode features a layered story within a story, as BoJack and Todd watch an old holiday episode from BoJack’s past sitcom, Horsin’ Around. This strategy allows for a reflection on the clichés of Christmas specials while humorously critiquing their often superficial nature.
When BoJack condemns Christmas specials as “cynical cash grabs,” he simultaneously reveals the underlying truths about holiday sentimentality. This self-aware episode contrasts the fictitious merriment of TV with the stark realities of abandonment, ultimately delivering a balance of humor and sincere emotional depth.
6 “A Very Sunny Christmas”
Season 6, Episodes 13 & 14: It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia (2005 – Present)
Set against the chaotic backdrop of Paddy’s Pub, It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia explored the darker side of the holidays in its festive special, “A Very Sunny Christmas.” The group’s dysfunctional relationships served as the foundation for a series of disconcerting revelations, including childhood traumas revisited and the harsh truths of Christmas as experienced by each character.
In a particularly jarring sequence, Charlie discovers the unsettling truth about how his mother financed Christmas celebrations, revealing the dark undercurrents that often accompany family traditions. The episode effectively shines a light on the less glamorous aspects of the holiday season, juxtaposing chaos with personal growth and healing.
5 “White Christmas”
2014 Christmas Special: Black Mirror (2011 – Present)
In stark contrast to most holiday specials, Black Mirror delivers a commentary on the darker aspects of technology through its chilling narratives. The 2014 special “White Christmas” intertwines several haunting stories told by Matt and Joe in a remote cabin on Christmas Day, showcasing a mixture of horror and psychological tension.
With its complex themes, “White Christmas”reveals the fallout from society’s reliance on technology. Its shocking conclusion leaves viewers grappling with the implications of forgiveness and punishment, encapsulating the unsettling experience characteristic of the series.
4 “Marge Be Not Proud”
Season 7, Episode 11: The Simpsons (1989 – Present)
The Simpsons has produced many memorable Christmas episodes, with “Marge Be Not Proud” standing out for its emotional depth. This episode navigates the disappointment of Marge when she discovers Bart’s shoplifting attempts during a time that typically should celebrate joy and familial love.
Interweaving humor with serious themes of trust and redemption, as Bart searches for ways to make amends, ultimately highlights the conflicting emotions that arise during the holiday season. This poignant storytelling culminates in a touching reconciliation between mother and son as they navigate the complexities of family and forgiveness.
3 “The Night Of The Meek”
Season 2, Episode 11: The Twilight Zone (1959 – 1964)
The Twilight Zone frequently employed a darker lens on the holidays, and “The Night of the Meek” shines as a classic example. Following Henry Corwin, a despondent, alcoholic department store Santa, this episode addresses themes of redemption through the discovery of a magical Santa’s sack filled with toys.
The narrative unfolds with an unexpected depth, starting on a bleak note and culminating in a heartwarming realization about the spirit of Christmas. This transformative message encapsulates the show’s balance of fantasy and morality, offering a refreshing contrast to many traditionally dark holiday stories.
2 “It’s the Most Wonderful Time Of The Year”
Season 2, Episode 8: Six Feet Under (2001 – 2005)
Six Feet Under is no stranger to exploring dark themes, and its Christmas episode “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year” exemplifies this. The narrative begins with tragedy—a mall Santa’s sudden death, establishing a somber tone as the Fisher family must navigate grief during the holiday.
This emotional turmoil is exacerbated by the anniversary of a family loss, making the episode a raw portrayal of holiday mourning juxtaposed with the expectations of celebration. Through intense character exploration, “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year” provides a profound insight into the complexity of family dynamics during Christmas.
1 “Fishes”
Season 2, Episode 6: The Bear (2022 – Present)
The Bear adeptly captures the chaotic essence of family gatherings during the holidays in its episode “Fishes.” Set five years prior to the restaurant’s opening, this episode highlights the conflicts and emotional tension existing within the Berzatto family, featuring notable guest stars like Jamie Lee Curtis.
As family dynamics unfold, the portrayal of Christmas dinner evokes memories of past traumas and discomfort, culminating in a profoundly realistic examination of family life. “Fishes” stands out not only for its chaotic narrative but also for its acute portrayal of familial bonds under strain, emphasizing the reality that holidays can sometimes magnify rather than ease underlying issues.
Related Articles:
Explaining the Title of Godzilla Minus One: Why This Godzilla Film Is Named That
12:06
Wallace & Gromit’s New Film Sheds Light on Tough Truths About the Franchise After 36 Years
4:32
Tim Allen Reveals Exciting Toy Story 5 Storyline Tease: “It’s A Really Cool Thing”
4:17
Leave a Reply