10 Tough Truths About Rewatching White Collar 15 Years Post-Premiere

White Collar, which aired from 2009 to 2014, significantly redefined the crime procedural genre, securing its place as one of the most iconic television shows of the era. The series featured Matt Bomer and Tim DeKay in the roles of Neal Caffrey and Peter Burke, respectively. Together, they formed an unlikely yet captivating alliance within the FBI’s white-collar crime division. This show took the familiar trope of the gentleman spy and flipped it on its head, presenting Neal Caffrey as the quintessential gentleman criminal—a man who, despite his aversion to firearms, possesses exceptional skills in theft and forgery, all while having an appreciation for fine art.

Neal’s world is turned upside down when Agent Burke apprehends him, leading to an intriguing deal between the two. The anticipated revival of White Collar aims to harness the dynamic chemistry between Bomer and DeKay, a key element that has historically bolstered the show’s narrative intrigue. Despite some elements of the original series having fallen out of fashion, the show remains accessible and enjoyable today. Fans hope that the renewed version will retain the successful aspects while addressing previous shortcomings for a fresh take on this beloved series.

10
Neal’s Treatment of Women

Neal’s Relationships: Depth and Difficulty

As one of the foremost procedural dramas, White Collar employs an episodic structure with a few overarching themes interwoven throughout its seasons. This approach presents challenges in developing stable romantic relationships for the protagonists, as the focus often shifts to the case-of-the-week. While Peter Burke remains steadfastly loyal to his wife, Elizabeth (played by Tiffani Thiessen), Neal is more unpredictable, embodying the charming yet flawed character of a womanizer.

Throughout the series, Neal navigates substantial long-term relationships with characters like Kate (Alexandra Daddario) and Sara (Hilarie Burton), but his struggles to maintain these partnerships are evident. His womanizing ways complicate matters, and his tendency to fall back into a life of crime adversely affects the women he becomes involved with. A pivotal moment occurs when he leaves with valuable stolen goods, abandoning Sara, which resonates painfully with the audience.