Main Insights
- Prominent isekai adaptations like Re: Zero and Reincarnated As A Slime are scarce amid a plethora of monotone series.
- The isekai genre is saturated with similar lead characters facing new challenges, yet some exceptional titles stand out.
- Innovative series such as The Greatest Estate Developer and Record of Highserk War provide novel interpretations of isekai stereotypes.
The isekai anime genre has become overwhelmingly abundant, to the point of absurdity. Each season seems to introduce a new slate of isekai series (or even multiple), and they often portray the same tired archetypes—characters who abruptly find themselves in fantastical realms. This redundancy can leave avid fans questioning the originality of each new adaptation.
Nevertheless, occasional gems like Re: Zero, Reincarnated As A Slime, and the recent The Great Cleric arise, but such instances are infrequent. Thankfully, numerous remarkable isekai manga offer potential adaptation material. Here are standout recommendations for future anime adaptations.
Updated October 15th, 2024 by Jacob Buchalter: While the number of isekai series continues to climb (and the trend shows no signs of slowing), there remains a lack of top-notch isekai stories that haven’t yet transitioned to anime. Notably, popular series like Reincarnated as a Slime and Jobless Reincarnation have enjoyed extensive production value in their adaptations. Yet, not every noteworthy isekai narrative has been given a screen adaptation. Hence, let’s closely examine the remaining isekai tales that deserve their moment in the spotlight.
22 Genius Martial Arts Trainer
What If Your Physical Therapist Got Isekai’d?
|
Title |
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Genius Martial Arts Trainer |
Krukru |
Midnight Studio |
We kick off this list with an intriguing manhwa called Genius Martial Arts Trainer. This story adheres to traditional wuxia isekai elements, where the protagonist falls asleep or loses consciousness one day, only to awaken in a narrative from a web novel or game they once enjoyed. The lead character, a fitness enthusiast, develops an obsession with training after recovering from an injury sustained during military service.
Post rehabilitation, he dedicates his life to fitness. One fateful day, after a disappointing online stream (a nod to the pandemic’s challenges on his gym business), he awakens to find himself embodying one of the revered Shaolin monks from his childhood web novels. One might expect he would regale them with modern workout concepts and ascend rapidly in power, and while this happens, the emphasis on physical health, stretching, and overall body care makes for a refreshing storyline. The protagonist often plays the role of a personal trainer, guiding the old-school Shaolin monks on various fitness regimens, proving to be surprisingly engaging.
20 World’s Strongest Rearguard: Labyrinth Country and Dungeon Seekers
An Isekai Tale Centered on Support Roles
|
Title |
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|---|
|
World’s Strongest Rearguard: Labyrinth Country and Dungeon Seekers |
Touwa Akatsuki |
Rikizou |
This next series, World’s Strongest Rearguard, showcases a familiar isekai premise but delivers through unique storytelling. Following the protagonist’s tragic accident, he is reborn into a magical and dungeon-filled world. In this universe, many individuals have also been reincarnated as ‘Seekers’—adventurers who explore dungeons and earn Retribution Points through the guild.
To harness the capabilities required for dungeon delving, Seekers need to apply for jobs at the guild. However, main character Atobe Arihito misunderstands the job application system and mistakenly writes ‘rearguard,’ expecting another role to be assigned to him. To his surprise, he is assigned a unique rearguard position that hasn’t been utilized before. Now, he faces the challenge of making a life in this new realm while navigating the intricacies of his distinct support role. While not groundbreaking, its premise and beautiful artwork make it a worthy candidate for the anime treatment.
19 I Killed An Academy Player & The Extra’s Academy Survival Guide
Exploring Two Isakai with Side Character Protagonists
|
Title |
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|---|
|
I Killed an Academy Player |
Hi Sally |
Gerin Geurin |
|
The Extra’s Academy Survival Guide |
Sinks |
Gerin Geurin |
Now, let’s discuss two closely related series: I Killed an Academy Player and The Extra’s Academy Survival Guide. Both are illustrated by Girin Geurin and revolve around protagonists who find themselves reincarnated as side characters in a gaming scenario. Despite differences in outlook and character development strategies, both stories share the journey of their protagonists from mere extras to central figures in their respective narratives.
With vibrant artwork, impeccable humor, rich world-building, and engaging action—along with elements of romance in both stories—each series has enormous potential for anime adaptations. Yet, rather than adapting both at once, it would be wise to choose one for a better viewing experience.
18 Release That Witch
A Contemporary Individual Mastering Magic
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Er Mu |
Dr. Woodman |
Next on our list is Release That Witch, which adopts a unique stance on the typical reincarnation theme. Here, the protagonist is reborn as a noble in a classic fantasy realm. Rather than utilizing cheat abilities to develop his territory, he opts to engage with the ‘forbidden’ powers of witches. Yet, he does not exploit their abilities for combat; instead, he utilizes their talents to accomplish various modern-day tasks not possible in the medieval context.
In essence, Release That Witch chronicles the efforts of a reincarnated noble as he innovatively leverages his prior knowledge to elevate his domain using magical resources. With over 500 chapters currently available, this series undoubtedly has enough material for a well-executed anime adaptation.
17 The Greatest Estate Developer
Top-Tier Manhwa Comedy
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Back-Kyung Moon |
Hyun Soo Kim |
In a refreshing twist, The Greatest Estate Developer is an exceptional read, not because of its plot or battle sequences, but because of its central character, Lloyd Frontera—essentially, Kim Suho, the individual inhabiting Lloyd’s body. This series is another example of a character being resurrected within a familiar fictional world.
While it boasts an array of intriguing characters and engaging narrative elements, it’s the humor that sets this manhwa apart. Kim Suho is absurdly quirky with undeniably twisted ideas (often for good), while Lloyd—before being overtaken by Kim Suho—was a character destined for demise at the hands of the primary protagonist. Kim Suho, however, cleverly navigates his situation, gathers allies, and engages in intriguing engineering and construction ventures to amass wealth.
16 Record Of Highserk War
An Isekai Narrative Weaving in the Harsh Realities of War
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Three tones |
Yanomi Saito |
If you’re in search of a darker isekai experience that avoids extremes, look no further than Record of Highserk War. This story offers a more realistic outlook on how an isekai could unfold, as protagonist Raizou Takakura is reborn into a peasant family and later compelled to join the military—transforming into a cold survivor to stay alive.
Despite its grim tone, the series is imbued with heart as Raizou cultivates friendships. He’s not merely killing out of malice. With exceptional artwork, captivating world-building, and a relatable cast, Record of Highserk War stands out as a compelling recommendation.
15 How To Use A Returner
What If the Protagonist was the Manipulative Antagonist?
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Heuksujeo |
Midnight Studio |
How To Use A Returner is a manhwa series that, while yet to receive recent updates, holds enough compelling content for several seasons of adaptation. The story adheres to classic isekai conventions, introducing a group of individuals summoned to a new world to fight for survival. The central charm lies in the character of Lee Giyoung—the self-proclaimed hero of the narrative—a clever yet ruthless individual.
Giyoung is cunning, avaricious, and self-seeking, leveraging his sharp intelligence to forge connections with powerful allies. The character he keeps closest is Kim Hyunsung, a true ‘returner’ who has returned from the future to amend his past errors. This series offers a dynamic narrative filled with deceit and ambition but maintains a core foundation focused on Giyoung’s manipulative journey to ascend to a position of comfort.
14 Tyrant Of The Tower Defense Game
One of the Finest ‘Trapped in a Game’ Series
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Ryueun Salt |
ought |
In recent times, the ‘gamer transported into their beloved game’ subgenre of isekai has gained popularity. Although many of these series often recycle the same tropes, Tyrant of the Tower Defense Game manages to bring fresh ideas while mastering the elements that make this sub-genre appealing.
The premise follows a retro game streamer who, after finally conquering a notoriously difficult game, finds himself thrust into the game world by the ‘developer’ to tackle it all over again. However, instead of playing as a character, he inhabits Prince Ash—arguably one of the weaker characters in the game, loathed by others. Readers witness how the streamer utilizes his game knowledge to navigate insurmountable challenges.
13 Surviving The Game As A Barbarian
On Par with Tyrant of the Tower Defense Game in Quality
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Yungang Jeong |
Nep |
Much like Tyrant of the Tower Defense Game captures the strategies and challenges of a hypothetical brutal RTS game, Surviving the Game as a Barbarian employs similar gameplay mechanics but from a Western RPG or dungeon crawler perspective.
This series excels in its introduction of inventive concepts to an otherwise saturated isekai genre. For instance, conventional game mechanics operate differently here, the protagonist must conceal his true identity to survive, and he employs inventive strategies typical barbarians wouldn’t even consider. Even though the light novel has many chapters available, the manhwa’s adaptation is still in progress, making it an early yet promising recommendation worthy of adaptation.
12 Pick Me Up: Infinite Gacha
An Immersive Experience in a Challenging Phone Game
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Hermode |
Wasakbasak |
To conclude our list of gamer-into-game themes, Pick Me Up: Infinite Gacha presents a compelling narrative suited for anime, especially considering the popularity of Gacha-style mobile games today.
While no manhwa has converted into anime outside of Tower of God and God of High School, the unique narrative, the character dynamics, and well-structured mobile game mechanics make Pick Me Up: Infinite Gacha a captivating read that keeps readers engaged.
11 Record Of Wörteria War
Combining Fire Emblem with the Isekai Formula
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Ryota Hori |
Upper Yagi |
Next is Record of Wortenia War, a tale that stands out for its violent themes. Unlike many isekai series, where a character is typically ‘summoned’ to another realm to vanquish a demon king or fulfill some grand purpose, the main character, Mikoshiba Ryouma—a highly skilled martial artist—is summoned under different circumstances.
Happening to him in the midst of a meal, Ryouma promptly utilizes his martial prowess against the summoners, changing the usual narrative of isekai heroes. As he goes on to forge his destiny with visual flair, this engaging twist on the classic isekai formula keeps readers turning the pages, hoping for more from his exciting journey.
10 The Golden Word Master: The Four Heroes & The Innocent Bystander With The Unique Cheat
A Protagonist Blessed with a Truly Unique Power
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Sui Tomoto |
Yusuke Ozaki |
Recently, the isekai landscape has begun to feature protagonists with more unconventional skills distinguishing them from traditional heroes. In Konjiki no Word Master, we meet Okamura Hiro, who wields a fascinating ability known as ‘Word Magic.’ This allows him to inscribe meanings onto objects, drastically impacting their form and function, which serves as the vehicle for a unique storytelling experience.
For example, when he writes ‘split’ on a massive boulder, it cleaves in two. Additionally, the enchanting inquiry into his literary ability unravels the diverse applications of words in this fantastical world, leading readers through complex political narratives and world-building, enriching the series further.
9 Walking In Another World
A Lighthearted Concept with Strong Execution
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Arukuhito |
Kei Ogawa |
Unlike many entries on this list that delve into depth, Isekai Walking takes a simplistic approach that remains consistently enjoyable. The plot adheres to the classic isekai blueprint, featuring:
- The protagonist is summoned to a magical universe.
- Each ‘hero’ possesses exaggerated stats and skills from the outset.
- The central character lacks these overwhelming attributes and is either quickly dismissed or expelled.
- Soon after, they come to grips with their true potential, revealing their underlying strength that transcends initial observations.
In this narrative, the lead, Sora, embodies the ‘Walking’ ability, gaining experience points with every step. As he accumulates levels, his strengths increase exponentially, further simplified by his newfound ability to walk without fatigue. Consequently, as days go by in this pleasant town, Sora evolves from an average human into a competent adventurer.
Remarkably, everyone in this world is exceptionally kind, steering the narrative away from the typical overpowered protagonist dynamic. Instead, Isekai Walking thrives on the relatable journey of a kindhearted individual exploring a delightful new world.
8 Welcome To Japan Ms. Elf
A Story That Delivers Pure Adorableness
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Suzuki Makishima |
I take Aon |
Welcome To Japan, Ms. Elf diverges from traditional isekai narratives; it’s neither a power fantasy nor a fanservice-oriented work. Instead, it presents a sweet blend of romance and comedy. Moreover, this series elegantly balances being both isekai and reverse isekai, as the protagonist oscillates between the fantasy realm and contemporary Japan.
Several key elements distinguish this series: Firstly, Kazuhiro Kitase traverses to the fantasy world during sleep, awakening in Japan after his dream journey or upon death in the fantasy realm. Secondly, the charming romance with Maribelle, an elven Spirit Sorceress, continually enchants readers. Lastly, the narrative largely centers on Maribelle’s reactions to Japanese cuisine and modern technology, providing comedic contrast to the usual trope of a protagonist experiencing fantasy wonders.
6 Survival Story Of A Sword King In A Fantasy World
A Comedic Journey of a Character Who Became Exceedingly Muscular
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Kyung-Bae Yim |
Soonkyu Kwon |
Survival Story of a Sword King in Another World offers an exhilarating blend of dark beginnings and comedic elements. It follows Ryu Han-Bin, a freshly discharged military member, who suddenly finds himself in life-and-death clashes in an unending loop upon entering a new realm.
Initially set against a grim backdrop, the narrative evolves into a humorous series filled with quirky characters, detailing Ryu’s escapades in a world where he must endure continuous battles to master his strength. His initially traumatic journey becomes refreshing, leading to comedic interactions and lighthearted moments as he embarks on adventures post-trauma.
5 Yakuza Reincarnation
What If Your Underworld Don Grandfather Ended Up a Fantasy Princess?
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Takeshi Natsuhara |
Hiroki Miyashita |
Yakuza Reincarnation is a fresh isekai manga that encapsulates its title perfectly. It chronicles the tale of a seasoned Yakuza member betrayed and killed by a supposed comrade, only to be reincarnated in a new world. Rather than regaining a young male body, his soul inhabits the fragile form of a fleeing princess faced with dangers.
Instead of spiraling into a narrative filled with fanservice, the juxtaposition between the grizzled Yakuza soul and the delicate body of a young girl offers an amusing and humorous contrast, used effectively for comedic purposes.
4 Dungeon Reset
A Fun Manhwa Featuring a Dungeon Tester
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Daul |
Ant Studio |
Dungeon Reset tells the story of individuals summoned to a perilous ‘dungeon’ world forced to combat life-threatening challenges imposed by a secretive puppet master. The protagonist, Dawun, is presumed dead after falling into a trap, left behind as the dungeon system resets.
Against the odds, Dawun survives and carves out a unique existence, stepping beyond the conventional rules of the realm. As he navigates through skill development in unorthodox ways and takes on various modules, each interaction forms a comedic backdrop to his adventures, resembling a humorous twist on traditional survival games.
3 A Veterinarian In Another World
Ideal for Lovers of Detailed World Development
|
Illustrator |
|
|---|---|
|
Chocolate Aozora |
Hu–Ko |
A Veterinarian in Another World flips typical isekai themes on their head. Rather than embodying a formidable fantasy creature or hero, protagonist Kazami Shingo reincarnates as a standard human while retaining knowledge from his prior life as a veterinarian. This allows the narrative to explore the more mundane aspects of fantasy creatures with genuine curiosity.
By delving into topics like the everyday existence of dragons or the nesting behaviors of harpies, the series brilliantly blends fantasy biology with engaging storytelling, elevating its world-building and demonstrating the author’s commitment to detail.
Leave a Reply