7 Must-See Docuseries for Fans of Netflix’s Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter

“Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter”is a gripping two-part true-crime docuseries that chronicles the relentless quest of Cathy Terkanian as she searches for her biological daughter, Aundria, whom she placed for adoption. Cathy was initially led to believe that adoption would ensure a better life for Aundria, but her world is shattered when, in 2010, she is asked to take a DNA test to confirm whether an unidentified deceased body is that of her daughter.

When the DNA results yield a negative match, Cathy embarks on an exhaustive search and discovers that her daughter has been missing since 1989. As Cathy unravels the mystery surrounding her daughter’s new identity and adoptive parents, she dedicates the next decade to uncovering the truth about her daughter’s disappearance.

“Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter”offers a poignant exploration of a mother’s determination for her children. For fans of true crime documentaries, the following curated list presents additional compelling docuseries reflecting similar themes of deception and heartache from loved ones.

The Keepers, The Staircase, and seven other must-watch docuseries if you enjoyed Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter

1) American Murder: Laci Peterson – Netflix

Still from American Murder: Laci Peterson (Image via Netflix)

This powerful three-part docuseries, “American Murder: Laci Peterson,”delves into the mysterious disappearance of Laci Peterson, who was eight months pregnant at the time, igniting public outrage that culminated in her murder. The narrative begins on Christmas Eve 2002, when Scott Peterson, Laci’s husband, reports her missing under suspicious circumstances.

The docuseries incorporates the testimony of Scott’s alleged girlfriend, extensive media coverage, and an intense trial, making it a captivating and emotional watch akin to “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter.”

2) Elizabeth Smart: Autobiography – Amazon Prime Video

Still from Elizabeth Smart: Autobiography

“Elizabeth Smart: Autobiography”is a hard-hitting three-part docuseries where Elizabeth recounts the horrific ordeal she faced in 2002 when she was kidnapped by a self-proclaimed religious leader and his wife. Enduring years of abuse in isolation, Elizabeth has emerged as a dedicated child safety advocate.

This telling docuseries mirrors “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter”as it features Elizabeth’s family, law enforcement, and eyewitness accounts, while she shares her path to healing to inspire others.

3) The Keepers – Netflix

Still from The Keepers (Image via Netflix)

“The Keepers”is an investigative docuseries that probes the unsolved murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik, an English and drama teacher at an all-girls school in Baltimore. After going missing in 1969, her body was discovered a year later.

The series follows two former students as they delve into Sister Catherine’s cold case, interviewing other former students who suspect a Priest at the school of abusing students. Like “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter,”this somber exploration leaves a lasting impression.

4) Keep Sweet: Pray and Obey – Netflix

Still from Keep Sweet: Pray and Obey (Image via Netflix)

This four-part docuseries, “Keep Sweet: Pray and Obey,”follows the infamous cult leader Warren Jeffs, who controlled the Fundamental Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS). The series examines how he manipulated young girls into polygamous marriages and includes interviews with his ex-wives.

Directed by Rachel Dretzin and Grace McNally, the series presents survivors’ stories that illustrate the dangers of blind faith, mirroring themes from “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter.”

5) Sins of Our Mother – Netflix

Still from Sins of Our Mother (Image via Netflix)

This limited docuseries chronicles the drastic transformation of a once-loving mother who becomes enveloped in religious fanaticism. It tells the story of Lori Vallow, who believes in distinguishing between ‘dark’ and ‘light’ spirits, advocating for the elimination of those deemed spiritless.

The series includes insights from Lori’s friends and family, revealing her radical ideological shift. As two of her children go missing, media speculation intensifies around Lori and her husband’s involvement, creating a chilling narrative akin to “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter.”

6) The Staircase – Netflix

Still from The Staircase (Image via Netflix)

“The Staircase”is a notable true-crime docuseries that follows novelist Michael Peterson, accused of murdering his wife, Kathleen, at their home. The series dives deep into the investigation and trial, exploring whether Kathleen’s death was a murder or tragic accident, with Michael offering his perspective.

Covering aspects like Michael’s past, the autopsy findings, and Kathleen’s family dynamics, the comprehensive research makes it a quintessential courtroom drama and a must-see for fans of “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter.”

7) Worst Roommate Ever – Netflix

Still from Worst Roommate Ever (Image via Netflix)

This two-season docuseries, “Worst Roommate Ever,”chronicles true stories of individuals who find themselves living with violent roommates. Each episode showcases a different story, exploring the backgrounds of these roommates and the horrors faced by those living with them.

Featuring personal interviews and expert commentary, the series tackles theme of suspense, encompassing tales ranging from disappearances to fatal betrayals, making it a thrilling watch like “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter.”

Viewers who enjoyed “Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter”can explore this list and select a captivating docuseries to dive into next.

Source