7 Must-Watch Shows to Binge While Anticipating the Only Murders in the Building Season 4 Finale

Mystery enthusiasts are thrilled that season four of Only Murders in the Building is now in progress. Each season, Charles-Haden Savage, Oliver Putnam, and Mabel Mora—brought to life by entertainment legends Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez—have captivated audiences with their humor-infused amateur detective skills as they unravel peculiar murders within the Arconia community.

This season continues the trend by introducing a host of new characters and celebrity guest appearances, including Eugene Levy, Zach Galifianakis, and Eva Longoria. With fresh episodes premiering every Tuesday, fans will eagerly anticipate the grand finale of Only Murders in the Building season four, set to air on October 29, 2024—leading to an extended wait for what’s to come.

During this interlude, fans can explore various television shows that mirror the engaging vibe of Only Murders in the Building.

Disclaimer: This article features insights from multiple sources.

Explore Search Party and Six More Shows Like Only Murders in the Building That Are Suspenseful and Entertaining

1) Bored to Death (2009)

Like Only Murders in the Building, Bored to Death boasts funny lead characters who are flawed but endearing (Image via HBO) — Like **Only Murders in the Building**, **Bored to Death** boasts funny lead characters who are flawed but endearing (Image via HBO)

Similar to Only Murders in the Building, Bored to Death effectively marries a crime-centric narrative with perfectly timed comedy. Created by author Jonathan Ames, this series follows Jason Schwartzman as a fictional version of Jonathan Ames, a New York City writer who masquerades as a private detective, navigating through various oddball cases.

Alongside his best friend Ray Hueston (played by Zach Galifianakis) and his mentor George Christopher (Ted Danson), he stumbles through detective work. Bored to Death not only captures life’s nuances in New York City but also showcases well-developed characters, sharp humor, and fantastic chemistry, making it a binge-worthy experience.

Where to watch: Bored to Death has three seasons consisting of 24 episodes and is available for streaming on Max and Prime Video.

2) Search Party (2016)

The central characters in this show, similar to the ones on Only Murders in the Building, are amateur sleuths (Image via HBO Max) — The central characters in this show, similar to the ones on **Only Murders in the Building**, are amateur sleuths (Image via HBO Max)

In Only Murders in the Building, the trio of Charles, Oliver, and Mabel don their detective hats following a murder in their residence. Similarly, the characters in Search Party stumble into amateur sleuthing when Dory, portrayed by Alia Shawkat, becomes fixated on the disappearance of her college friend, Chantal Witherbottom. With little sleuthing experience, the comedic mishaps that ensue provide plenty of laughs.

The relatable friendship dynamics among the well-crafted lead characters enhance the viewing experience. Although it starts slowly, Search Party ramps up the narrative with countless unexpected twists. This series spans five seasons and includes 50 episodes.

Where to watch: This dark comedy series is available for streaming on Max, Prime Video, and Apple TV+.

3) Queens of Mystery (2019)

Fans of Only Murders in the Building will enjoy this funny cozy mystery series (Image via Acorn TV) — Fans of **Only Murders in the Building** will enjoy this funny cozy mystery series (Image via Acorn TV)

Like the trio of Only Murders in the Building, the characters in Queens of Mystery feel well-equipped to tackle crime due to their addiction to true-crime narratives. In this series, Olivia Vinall portrays a young detective who struggles to keep her three crime-writing aunts from meddling in her investigations.

The aunts believe their knowledge of crafty whodunits can help crack the case. Queens of Mystery thrives on its charming characters and intelligent dialogue, making it a treat for Agatha Christie fans due to its cozy mystery aura.

Where to watch: Queens of Mystery has two seasons consisting of 12 episodes and can be viewed on Prime Video and Plex.

4) The Afterparty (2022)

The distinctive storytelling format sets this show apart from the rest of the titles on this list (Image via Apple TV+)

Fans love Only Murders in the Building not just for the murder mystery itself but also for the rich backstories of the lead characters. The Afterparty elevates this concept further—set during a high school reunion that culminates in a murder. Each episode reveals the events from different characters’ perspectives.

This engaging format allows viewers to delve deep into the characters’ lives. As the story unfolds with each new interview, maintaining suspense until the conclusion becomes a challenge for viewers. The Afterparty consists of two seasons and 18 episodes, with each season tackling a new case while retaining its unique storytelling approach.

Where to watch: The Afterparty can be streamed on Apple TV+.

5) Based on a True Story (2023)

Like Only Murders in the Building, the narrative of this show also revolves around a true crime podcast (Image via Peacock) — Like **Only Murders in the Building**, the narrative of this show also revolves around a true crime podcast (Image via Peacock)

Kaley Cuoco’s Ava Bartlett in Based on a True Story rivals the obsession of Charles, Oliver, and Mabel for true crime podcasts. Ava, who is pregnant, is married to Nathan (Chris Messina), a former tennis player turned coach post-injury. When she suspects a local serial killer is on the loose, instead of alerting the authorities, she begins a podcast to cash in on America’s true crime fascination.

Much like Only Murders in the Building, crime podcasts play a pivotal role in the show’s narrative. While it features comedic elements, it also casts a light on disturbing truths about society’s willingness to exploit others for personal gain. The first season includes eight episodes, with a second season launching on November 21, 2024.

Where to watch: Based on a True Story can be streamed on Peacock.

6) A Murder at the End of the World (2023)

Only Murders in the Building fans looking for a more intense thriller series shouldn’t miss out on this one (Image via FX Networks)

This series, with only seven episodes, presents a darker tone than Only Murders in the Building while retaining the suspense and tension viewers cherish. Emma Corrin stars as Darby Hart, an amateur detective summoned to an isolated Arctic retreat. After one guest is murdered, Darby must exercise her sleuthing skills to prevent further killings.

The narrative cleverly incorporates technology and high-tech detective methods. Corrin’s performance as Darby, who embodies a complex character, drives the suspenseful and well-structured storyline, which features multiple clever red herrings to keep audiences guessing.

Where to watch: A Murder at the End of the World is available on Hulu and Disney+.

7) Poker Face (2023)

Like Only Murders in the Building, Poker Face offers a delightful mix of mystery and witty humor (Image via Peacock) — Like **Only Murders in the Building**, **Poker Face** offers a delightful mix of mystery and witty humor (Image via Peacock)

Viewers are drawn to Only Murders in the Building for its intricate, sinister plots within Arconia. Similarly, Poker Face, featuring Natasha Lyonne as casino worker Charlie Cale, is consistently embroiled in trouble, blessed with the unique ability to detect lies.

After finding herself on the run, Charlie always encounters mysterious deaths of those around her. Notably, the show employs an inverted detective storyline—revealing the crime and perpetrator upfront, with the plot focusing on how she solves the mystery using clues.

Where to watch: The 10-episode Poker Face is available for streaming on Peacock and Apple TV+.

As fans of Only Murders in the Building await the season four finale, they can dive into these captivating murder mystery shows that promise equal entertainment and excitement.

Source