American Idol’s Major Misstep: Carrie Underwood Should Have Been in a Different Role Rather Than Judge

The recent decision by American Idol producers to replace Katy Perry with Carrie Underwood as a judge has sparked a debate over what might have been a better fit for the country music star. While Perry, who spent seven seasons alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, departed to refocus on her musical career, many fans feel that Underwood might have been better suited as the show’s host rather than a judge.

As anticipation builds for the 23rd season of American Idol, the excitement stems not only from the impressive talent that contestants are expected to showcase but also from the significant changes within the judging panel since the show’s revival in 2018. One constant aspect, however, remains: Ryan Seacrest as the host. His long tenure, which has spanned over two decades, raises questions about whether it’s time for a change, especially given that Carrie would shine as the show’s host instead of solely serving on the judging panel.

Carrie Underwood’s Kind Persona May Not Suit Judging

Carrie’s Struggle with Providing Constructive Criticism

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aY1OhaLjtfo

Carrie Underwood Admits It’s Tough Saying NO as ‘American Idol’ Judge (Exclusive) (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aY1OhaLjtfo)

Since her rise to fame on American Idol in 2005, Underwood has garnered a reputation for her warm and generous spirit, making the role of a judge particularly challenging for her. It’s hard to imagine her delivering tough feedback to aspiring artists, especially given her awareness of the challenges faced by those competing on the show. Ultimately, Carrie’s inherent kindness poses a hurdle as a judge.

Carrie has openly acknowledged her difficulty in delivering “no”to contestants during an interview with Extra. She remarked on the pressure when contestants urge for additional opportunities: “Whenever somebody is saying, ‘I can sing another one. I have this song, I have this song,’ I just can’t say no.” This quality makes it even more complicated when she is tasked with providing a negative review.

If Carrie were to assume the role of host, she would circumvent the discomfort of critique altogether. Ryan Seacrest has historically acted as a supportive presence for contestants, offering encouragement before their auditions and during live shows. This nurturing role aligns perfectly with Carrie’s strengths, as demonstrated during her mentorship of contestants on season 20.

A Fresh Perspective Is Needed for the Hosting Role

Carrie’s Acclaimed Hosting Experience

While American Idol has enjoyed an impressive 22 seasons, it has noticeably lost momentum in recent years. Contestants from the ABC era have not quite reached the iconic status of earlier winners like Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood, raising concerns over the show’s future viability.

To reinvigorate this time-honored franchise, it’s imperative to consider new changes, starting with a fresh host. With Ryan Seacrest expanding his television commitments by taking on the role of Wheel of Fortune host, now could be the perfect moment for him to pass the torch.

Carrie has consistently proven herself as an adept and captivating host. Her experiences co-hosting the CMA Awards and leading her own special, Carrie Underwood: An All-Star Holiday Special, showcase her ability to engage and entertain audiences. Her charming and cheerful personality undoubtedly make her an ideal candidate for hosting American Idol.

Although Carrie’s role as a judge is sure to be a beneficial one, it seems clear that she would have flourished even more in a hosting capacity. After two decades of Seacrest’s leadership, a co-hosting arrangement with Carrie could enhance the dynamic of the show in the future. For now, the excitement surrounding Carrie’s judging debut in season 23 promises to bring thrilling moments to fans.

The new season of American Idol is set to premiere on Sunday, March 9, 2025, on ABC.

Source: ExtraTV/YouTube

Source & Images