Animal Crossing New Horizons: Fans Weigh the Pros and Cons of Restarting the Game

In the realm of Animal Crossing: New Horizons, players often grapple with the dilemma of whether to restart their game after fully exhausting its content. This situation is not uncommon; many enthusiasts find themselves completing the museum collections, perfecting their island layouts, and settling into their ideal communities, leaving them without new goals to pursue. Moreover, the game imposes a limitation: players can only create one island per device, necessitating a complete reset of all progress for those eager to start anew.

A Reddit user, namelesswndr, recently turned to the community for advice on this very issue. After investing four and a half years into the game, they have checked off nearly every available task, including achieving all Nook Miles. Their post echoes the sentiments of many players who face the prospect of losing their investments in exchange for a fresh start.

Did you restart and regret it? by u/namelesswndr in acnh

This player has engaged in various endeavors—redesigning their island, experimenting with different themes, and villager hunting—to extend their enjoyment of the game. Yet, the recurring thought of restarting lingers, highlighting the emotional weight of potentially wiping away years of dedicated gameplay.

Restarting in Animal Crossing: New Horizons: A Double-Edged Sword

Relish a Fresh Start, but Sacrifice Your Accomplishments

While Animal Crossing: New Horizons doesn’t adhere to conventional gaming completion, it’s common for players to hit a wall after dedicating extensive hours to the game. The charm lies in personalizing one’s island, filling the museum, and acquiring favorite villagers; however, the absence of new objectives can create a void. Restarting the game promises a reinvigoration of that initial excitement but comes at an emotional cost—erasing countless hours of labor can be a deterrent.

Community reactions to namelesswndr’s query show a spectrum of opinions. Some users, like WonkyGeorge, found restarting a transformative choice, while others, such as HeyDickTracyCalled, expressed reservations. This player encountered difficulties finding certain DIY recipes after multiple resets, suggesting that for those hesitant to restart, exploring features like the Happy Home Paradise expansion may offer a satisfying alternative. Many players recommend saving their island to a dream address, enabling them to revisit a cherished state even after embarking on a new adventure.

Our Perspective: Whether to Restart or Not, Animal Crossing Remains Enjoyable

The Adventure Continues

The allure of Animal Crossing: New Horizons lies in its endless possibilities for creativity and engagement. Even when the main activities are completed, players still have the freedom to reinvent their islands and participate in ongoing online trends that inspire unique designs. Additionally, daily routines such as fishing, bug hunting, vegetable cultivation, and diving present ongoing opportunities to keep players actively engaged.

Furthermore, delightful surprises never truly fade from the player experience. Recent discussions revealed that many amusing in-game items can function as wardrobe spaces, enhancing the whimsical nature of the game. With its soothing ambiance and endless surprises, Animal Crossing: New Horizons promises enjoyment, regardless of whether players choose to restart their journey or remain as methodical completionists.

Source: Reddit (namelesswndr, WonkyGeorge, HeyDickTracyCalled)

Source & Images