Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp Reveals Significant Problems With New Horizons’ Frustrating Villagers

Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp Reveals Significant Problems With New Horizons’ Frustrating Villagers

The evolution of Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp into a paid offline mobile experience—now known as Pocket Camp Complete—has transformed it into a robust addition to the beloved franchise. Since its inception in 2017, the developers have consistently introduced a plethora of updates, imbuing the game with delightful new outfits and distinct furniture sets. Amidst all these enhancements, the real stars are undoubtedly the villagers, who embody the charm and enjoyment that the series is renowned for. Their rich personalities and interactions make Pocket Camp a compelling benchmark for the future direction of the Animal Crossing series.

The villagers in Pocket Camp exhibit a depth and authenticity that surpasses their peers in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. This can be attributed to the fact that the villagers in Pocket Camp have more diverse and realistic personalities. Unlike in New Horizons, where player interaction is primarily limited to repetitive small talk and gift exchanges, Pocket Camp offers a more dynamic engagement with its villagers.

Less Tedious Villager Interactions in Pocket Camp

A Richer Variety and Deeper Personalities

Villager Sherb from Animal Crossing
Gameplay from Pocket Camp
Villagers celebrating in Pocket Camp
Player chatting with CJ in New Horizons
Character with Goldie

One significant criticism of the villagers in Animal Crossing: New Horizons is their monotonous interactions. Engaging with any Villager often results in similar dialogues, creating a feeling of repetition, particularly among villagers of the same personality type. In contrast, Pocket Camp enriches the player experience with a broader range of conversational options and playful activities. Players can participate in discussions, offer styling suggestions, dress villagers, fulfill requests, and even retrieve lost items. While certain aspects, like questing, appear in New Horizons, their execution can feel tedious and less engaging compared to Pocket Camp.

The dynamic scope of interactions in Pocket Camp allows for a more lively engagement with villagers. Players are encouraged to nurture friendships through daily conversations and help with campsite activities. Notably, New Horizons presents all its villagers as uniformly friendly from the start, which diminishes the significance of friendship development—a hallmark of earlier titles—leaving players yearning for a deeper connection.

More Activities Available with Villagers in Pocket Camp

Enhanced Depth and Variety of Interactions

Villager using a lawnmower
Villager Lolly
KK Slider performance in Pocket Camp
Pocket Camp gameplay
Fishing in New Horizons
Villager Tia
Player posing in New Horizons

Pocket Camp goes beyond basic interactions, introducing a captivating feature called Memories. Players must meet specific friendship levels and fulfill certain requirements to trigger these delightful cutscenes featuring villager interactions. For example, the scenario known as “The Library Super Sleuth”showcases Raymond assisting Beau and Sylvana in finding a coveted book. These charming snippets add considerable personality to the villagers, motivating players to invest more effort into developing friendships.

Moreover, the breadth of available interactive items in Pocket Camp allows villagers to engage in various activities around the world, in stark contrast to the limited gameplay in New Horizons. In the latter, villagers mostly perform simple actions like sitting or pretending to water flowers. In Pocket Camp, villagers can interact with an extensive range of items, from turning off lights to using kitchen appliances. They can sleep in beds (often experiencing amusing nightmares) and interact with playful elements inspired by other Nintendo franchises, such as question blocks from Super Mario. This level of engagement enhances the sense of community within the campsite, making it feel alive and vibrant.

Future Lessons for Animal Crossing from Pocket Camp

A Call for Villager Upgrades

Villager Roald
Pocket Camp characters
Player in New Horizons
Character with Filbert
Deep-sea diving in New Horizons
Player by pool in New Horizons

For many players, engaging with villagers is a cornerstone of the Animal Crossing experience. Unfortunately, Animal Crossing: New Horizons fell short, as its villagers often seem like bland caricatures organized into a few personality types. Interactions with a single villager yield largely the same responses, leading to a predictable experience. Even daily rituals such as DIY recipe exchanges can fall prey to redundancy, as they often recycle a small selection of uninspired phrases.

The forthcoming title in the Animal Crossing franchise must prioritize enhancing villager personalities while enriching the relationship-building mechanics that manifest in their dialogue. To create an immersive environment, the game world should be more interactive, allowing villagers to engage meaningfully with the spaces they inhabit. Most importantly, it is crucial to restore the sense of earned friendships, moving away from the notion that all villagers are instant allies, as seen in New Horizons.

Source & Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *