Can Chainsaw Man Outshine Naruto as Shonen Jump’s Most Heroic Character?

The Journey of Shōnen Manga: A Break from Tradition

Shōnen manga has traditionally adhered to a specific narrative blueprint. Typically, the storyline revolves around a well-meaning, heroic young protagonist who embarks on a quest to fulfill a significant dream or ambition, forging friendships along the way. Iconic characters like Naruto, Goku, and Luffy exemplify this archetype, representing steadfast moral values and a natural inclination towards good deeds. Over the years, Shōnen Jump has capitalized on this formula, generating a succession of relatable role models with each new release. However, the landscape shifted dramatically with the introduction of Chainsaw Man‘s Denji.

Denji arrives on the scene as a crude, irreverent, and often self-serving character reminiscent of a protagonist from a ’90s stoner comedy. His debut shook the manga community to its core, inspiring a trend of complex protagonists who navigate morally ambiguous territories, following in Denji’s rebellious footsteps. The era of idealistic heroes, such as Naruto—characterized by unyielding ethical codes—has been challenged by this chainsaw-wielding teen.

Despite his rough edges and questionable morals, it’s essential to recognize Denji as a hero in his own right. Although his aspirations are muddled and his ethical compass seems loosely calibrated, he embodies the qualities necessary for a Devil Hunter. Much like conventional heroes, Denji endures significant hardship and suffering—experiencing loss, betrayal, and agony—yet, he remains committed to safeguarding others. In this sense, Denji represents a modern twist on the quintessential shōnen protagonist and may even stand as Shōnen Jump’s newest iconic hero.

Denji’s Narrative: A Life of Tragedy

Experiencing Denji’s Pain

One prevalent motif within shōnen narratives is the notion of the tragic backstory. Characters such as Naruto, marked by the hardships of their upbringing, and Tanjiro from Demon Slayer, who maintains a profound kindness despite adversity, illustrate this theme well. Nevertheless, Denji stands apart, not only because of his complicated past but due to the ongoing adversity he faces in life.

In Chainsaw Man, the world is depicted as unforgiving and ruthless. Unlike other genre heroes who grapple with their pasts primarily off-screen, Denji’s pain is experienced in real-time by the audience. The loss of his father and the betrayal by those who should have cared for him serve to paint his tragic portrait. His initial bond with Pochita and ultimate destruction at the hands of the Yakuza add layers to his heartbreaking narrative.

A young Denji with Pochita in a field in Chainsaw Man's first ending theme music video

However, the story doesn’t end with the initial chapters. The deaths of pivotal characters like Power, Aki, and Nayuta only deepen Denji’s anguish. The betrayals by allies Reze and Makima leave indelible scars. Throughout it all, Denji continually rises from his suffering, re-engaging with battles that test his limits. While typical shōnen protagonists experience growth and hope following early sufferings, Denji’s existence is an unending cycle of trauma, and yet he manages to remain himself.

In a pivotal moment when a girl needed help, Denji was prepared to forsake Public Safety for her sake, knowing it might cost him his life. When Santa Claus unleashed human dolls upon him, he hesitated, concerned for their safety. Even in the torment of having to combat Aki, whom he views as a brother figure, Denji’s choice to protect the innocent speaks volumes. He may contradict traditional shōnen heroism, but through every harrowing experience, Denji truly embodies the spirit of a hero.

Denji: A Constant in a Chaotic World

Denji’s Consistency Amidst Change

While many shōnen heroes exhibit static traits, growing only in strength or occasionally in outlook, Denji diverges notably from this convention. Characters such as Naruto and Goku maintain core values without significant evolution. In contrast, Denji’s multifaceted development is mirrored in his shifting desires and outlook on life, indicating that his character progression is as vital to the narrative as the monstrous adversaries he confronts.

Tatsuki Fujimoto reinvents the traditional characteristics of shōnen protagonists with Denji, reconciling both traditional and transformative elements. Throughout his pursuit of frivolous dreams—like touching a girl’s breasts or experiencing love—Denji’s growth is unmistakable. Despite the emotional turmoil he faces, his distinctively humorous and carefree demeanor sets him apart from the more jaded and serious Devil Hunters around him.

Denji’s Resurgence in Chainsaw Man’s Latest Chapters

A Phoenix Rising: Denji in Chainsaw Man Part Two

Denji and Pochita in front of a panel featuring Aging Devil from Chainsaw Man Chapter #187 — Custom Image by Zach Zamora

While Denji consistently finds his footing after each calamity, Chainsaw Man Part Two has presented numerous challenges for him. Before he could truly process the grief of losing his chosen family, he found himself responsible for a sister figure who would ultimately meet a tragic fate. In a different narrative, this trajectory might have led Denji down a dark path towards villainy, but the current chapters depict him rediscovering his strength and purpose.

Now collaborating with Pochita, Denji embraces the realization that true family can manifest in various forms. As he confronts the Aging Devil with a renewed sense of agency, he resolves to rescue Asa from danger. Chainsaw Man boldly steps outside typical shōnen parameters, demonstrating that true heroism often arises not only from victories but from navigating losses with dignity.

Denji ready to save himself and Asa from Aging's World in Chainsaw Man

Few protagonists in Shōnen Jump exist in worlds as dire as Denji’s reality in Chainsaw Man, but remarkably, he maintains his heroic stance despite relentless adversity. It might seem unconventional that a character like Denji, with such an anti-hero persona, could exemplify heroism akin to shōnen legends, yet his narrative suggests otherwise. The intense clash with the Aging Devil sets the stage for thrilling developments, and fans can expect Denji to once again assume the mantle of hero in the forthcoming chapters.

Source & Images