Challenges for The Rings of Power Season 3: Can It Surpass the Best Sauron Storyline Even With the One Ring?

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power continues to stir discussions since its premiere, particularly regarding the upcoming second season’s Sauron storyline, which many predict will be hard to surpass. The season one finale revealed Halbrand, portrayed by Charlie Vickers, as the true embodiment of Sauron—a twist that challenges viewers to reconsider the character’s journey. As the plot progresses into season two, Halbrand’s transformation into Annatar is a significant pivot, enriching the narrative landscape. Concurrently, attention shifts to the Stranger (Daniel Weyman), whose identity is finally unveiled at the conclusion of season two, positioning him as a counterforce to Sauron’s machinations. However, there are concerns that season three may fall short of the high bar set by season two.

The Challenge of Surpassing Sauron & Celebrimbor’s Season 2 Journey

A High Point for the Franchise: Season 2’s Sauron Narrative

Navigating forward, Sauron’s narrative may struggle to equal the riveting Celebrimbor deception that defined season two. Celebrimbor’s tragic death serves as a climax, closing out one of the series’ most captivating arcs. This dramatic moment, rooted in Tolkien’s Unfinished Tales, hints at the possibility of Celebrimbor receiving a poignant farewell in season three. Additionally, Sauron’s cunning should lead him to manipulate Pharazôn (Trystan Gravelle) into executing his goals. However, the absence of Charles Edwards’ compelling performance will undoubtedly be felt, potentially diminishing the narrative impact of Sauron’s further developments in Númenor.

Will the Creation of the One Ring Recapture the Season 2 Tension?

Anticipated High Points in Sauron’s Arc

The One Ring seen on Sauron's finger in Lord of the Rings.

As Sauron approaches the creation of the One Ring, expectations soar; yet, it remains to be seen if this pivotal moment can replicate the dramatic stakes witnessed in the previous season. The chemistry between Charles Edwards and Charlie Vickers was particularly noteworthy as Sauron led Celebrimbor to believe he was an emissary of the Valar—a plot device that underscored Sauron’s role as the archetypal deceiver. If the pace changes or if the focus shifts away from this critical thematic element, it could detract significantly from the overall narrative. While the distribution of the nine Rings of Men and the evolution of the Ringwraiths promises to be thrilling, it may lack the depth fostered by the Celebrimbor storyline.

To forge the One Ring, Sauron will undoubtedly draw from the knowledge he gained before killing Celebrimbor. This dynamic between the two characters may add layers to the storyline, even in light of Celebrimbor’s demise. The hope remains that Sauron’s deceptive charm resurfaces powerfully during the Númenor arc. Nevertheless, it may prove challenging to evoke the same level of empathy for Pharazôn as audiences felt for Celebrimbor, a crucial factor that contributed to making The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2 iconic and memorable.

Source&Images