Colin Macrae: The Real Villain in Below Deck Sailing Yacht? Exploring His Love Triangle and Season 5 Absence to Avoid Backlash

Colin Macrae’s unexpected exit from Below Deck Sailing Yacht after its fourth season left many fans feeling let down. Since departing from the show, Colin has dedicated himself to new ventures, including working on his own catamaran and sharing his adventures through YouTube. Although he seems to be thriving on his own, many speculate that his decision to leave might be linked to the tumultuous events of season 4.

Colin Macrae: A Fan Favorite’s Journey

Since joining the Parsifal III as Chief Engineer in season 2, Colin quickly became a beloved figure. His solid relationships with Captain Glenn Shephard, Chief Stew Daisy Kelliher, and First Officer Gary King, along with his calm demeanor under pressure, positioned him as an indispensable member of the crew. However, everything changed during season 4 when Colin’s romantic involvement with Daisy shifted dynamics on the show dramatically. Following the collapse of their relationship, his departure raised questions about his motives, possibly indicating a desire to evade backlash from fans.

Colin Knew Dating Daisy Would Incite Drama

Navigating Romantic Relationships in High-Pressure Environments

Colin possessed enough insight by season 4 to understand the risks of dating Daisy. Their romance threatened to create chaos not only for themselves but for the entire crew. Colin likely recognized the underlying tensions between Gary and Daisy, and though he wasn’t aware of their full romantic history, it was apparent that Gary’s jealousy could pose a significant issue. As their relationship unfolded, Colin found himself entangled in a romantic rivalry with Gary, complicating their working relationship.

The reunion episode of Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 4 illustrated the fallout of Colin and Daisy’s relationship. Colin exhibited defensiveness and didn’t hesitate to criticize Daisy about her prior romantic encounters with both him and Gary. He even dismissed Gary’s feelings as “ego-driven,” casting himself in a hostile light during this confrontation. Despite the drama, Colin failed to acknowledge his own role in the turmoil.

Colin’s Post-Season Breakup with Daisy

Leaving Daisy Heartbroken

While both Colin and Daisy seemed optimistic about their relationship at the close of season 4, it later emerged that Colin ended things after filming concluded. The relationship had descended into toxicity, and even the separation from the Parsifal III did not salvage it. Colin’s choice to wait for the cameras to go dark before breaking up appeared calculated. Daisy had earlier voiced her doubts about sustaining their relationship once the season wrapped, but Colin reassured her it would be manageable, only to ultimately end it.

It is likely that Colin’s strategy was meant to minimize his public image as the villain by avoiding a public breakup. He might have anticipated that allowing some time post-filming would help Daisy heal away from the audience’s scrutiny. However, the aftermath resulted in a disastrous reunion, further solidifying his status as the villain in the eyes of fans.

Colin’s Decision to Exit the Show

Dodging Accountability

The relationship drama from season 4 created such significant turmoil that Colin’s return to Below Deck Sailing Yacht was rendered nearly impossible. Any attempt to work alongside Daisy would likely have been fraught with tension, making his presence on the show implausible. Colin’s withdrawal from the series allowed him to sidestep the consequences of his actions and prevented Daisy from addressing him directly about the heartbreak.

In the end, Colin left Below Deck Sailing Yacht not only to avoid facing the fallout but also to elude accountability. His decision to enter a problematic relationship with Daisy and subsequently abandon her to deal with the repercussions speaks to his role as a true villain in this narrative—leaving Daisy to cope with the aftermath of their turmoil alone.

Below Deck Sailing Yacht airs Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on Bravo.

Source & Images