Comparing David Corenswet’s Superman Trailer to Henry Cavill’s Man of Steel Trailer

Recently, the highly anticipated first trailer for David Corenswet’s Superman has debuted, unveiling a narrative that promises to be both dynamic and vibrant, showcasing a notably different aesthetic from the DCEU’s Man of Steel. This marks the beginning of the DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters, setting the stage for a fresh cinematic take on one of comic book history’s most iconic characters. Corenswet’s interpretation of Superman stands in stark contrast to Henry Cavill’s portrayal, with the trailer quickly indicating a clear departure in tone, visual style, and thematic focus.

When Zack Snyder’s Man of Steel trailer was released in 2013, it presented a serious and introspective Superman, diverging sharply from earlier representations. Cavill’s Superman focused heavily on the burdens and existential dilemmas faced by a near-omnipotent entity navigating a flawed world. Fast forward to 2025, James Gunn brings us a different narrative vision with Corenswet, hinting at a retro and fun vibe, diverging from Snyder’s heavy, serious interpretation.

The Human Side of David Corenswet’s Superman

Henry Cavill’s Exploration of Godlike Identity

The opening scenes of Corenswet’s trailer poignantly depict a more relatable Superman. It begins with a striking image of a battered Superman, seemingly defeated and rescued by his dog Krypto, conveying vulnerability and emphasizing his human aspects. This contrasts sharply with the Man of Steel trailer, which presents a more reflective tone, diving deep into Clark Kent’s childhood and his complicated search for identity.

Watch the trailer here

In contrast to Corenswet’s early reveal, Cavill’s Superman image in his trailer emerges later, showcasing him hovering majestically in space — a visual representation of his divine status. However, the Corenswet trailer favors a grounded portrayal, centering on the character’s humanity rather than his mythic heroism, consistent with James Gunn’s narrative style that often prioritizes relatable stories.

Superman (2025) Brings Lightheartedness to the Franchise

Man of Steel’s Serious Tonal Approach

The trailers create contrasting visions of Superman’s universe. Superman (2025) embraces a retro, colorful aesthetic that radiates optimism and fun, illustrating Superman’s dual identity in a celebratory manner. This is a stark contrast to Man of Steel, which delves deep into the significant struggles of a nearly omnipotent individual, grappling with fear and misunderstanding in society.

Watch the trailer here

Snyder’s movie serves as a nuanced origin story, chronicling Clark’s transformation from a small-town boy to a global hero facing an existential crisis. While Man of Steel expertly portrays Superman’s struggles, Corenswet’s film appears to celebrate an iconic hero rather than taking a serious tone. This retro approach, enhanced by nostalgic fashion and a lively guitar-driven score, aims to reach a broader audience, making it more accessible to younger fans.

Music and Themes in Both Trailers Highlight Key Differences

The Adaptation of John Williams’ Score in Superman (2025)

Both trailers utilize music as a storytelling mechanism, albeit in markedly different ways. Man of Steel opens with Hans Zimmer’s deep and reflective score, aimed at illustrating the heaviness of Krypton’s destruction and Clark’s solitude. This layered composition gradually transitions into a bold heroic theme, bolstering the grandeur surrounding Cavill’s portrayal. On the other hand, the Superman trailer skillfully incorporates John Williams’ classic score, but with a modern twist.

Initially, the Superman trailer features no music, with only winds howling over a weary Superman. This somber setting is soon enhanced with ominous notes highlighting his plight, leading up to a triumphant riff of Williams’ score on electric guitar. This nostalgic yet fresh version crescendos into the iconic Superman theme, emphasizing the film’s optimistic essence. While Zimmer’s composition amplifies the serious narrative of Snyder’s film, Gunn’s selections cultivate warmth and familiarity, signaling a different emotional impetus.

The Visual Contrast Between the Two Superman Interpretations

The Vibrancy of Superman (2025) versus Man of Steel

Superman Taken into Custody in Man of Steel

Visually, the difference between these two films and their trailers is striking. The Superman trailer bursts with bright colors, showcasing a suit reminiscent of classic comic book styles, complete with a colorful cast of DC characters. The vibrant color palette imbues the trailer with energy, reflecting James Gunn’s distinct style seen in his previous works, like Guardians of the Galaxy. This refreshing visual approach is likely to attract audiences yearning for a joyful depiction of the iconic superhero.

Conversely, Man of Steel opts for a more subdued aesthetic with desaturated tones and a darker Superman suit, amplifying its somber mood while emphasizing realism. This visual design aligns with the serious undertones of Snyder’s film. Although this choice is coherent with the introspective nature of the narrative, it may come across as less engaging compared to the colorful vibrancy of Superman. Gunn’s focus on bold colors may signal a return to the essence of Superman as a hopeful and fun symbol.

James Gunn’s Superman Trailer Teases More Narrative Intrigue

Man of Steel’s Direct Approach to the Origin Story

Military Aiming at Superman in Man of Steel

Finally, a significant contrast between the trailers is the amount of information they reveal about each film’s narrative. The Superman trailer hints at several intriguing elements, such as introductions to various DC characters, hints of an alien invasion, and Superman juggling his dual identities. However, it deliberately refrains from providing a detailed storyline. This approach cultivates excitement, suggesting the movie will be a captivating event in Superman’s cinematic legacy.

In contrast, Man of Steel showcases a clearer outline of its narrative, straightforwardly indicating that it is an origin story that follows Clark’s evolution from a troubled youth to Earth’s ultimate defender. While this straightforwardness sets clear audience expectations, it also lacks the mystery and allure present in Gunn’s teaser. By hinting at significant plot points without laying everything out, Gunn’s strategy reflects contemporary trailer trends that prioritize intrigue over exposition. These distinctions effectively highlight the contrasting tones between the two films and signify the new direction that James Gunn is steering with Superman.

Source & Images