Main Insights
- HBO’s The Penguin marks a significant achievement in prestige drama, setting a new benchmark for superhero narratives within the DC universe.
- Daredevil: Born Again aims to transform the MCU’s tone with its gritty, crime-centric storytelling, echoing themes found in The Penguin.
- This upcoming series could give the MCU its own version of a crime drama akin to The Sopranos, presenting a more grounded narrative.
Since its debut, HBO’s The Penguin has undeniably influenced the television landscape, earning accolades as one of the finest superhero shows on air. The show’s success may provide critical insights for Marvel Studios, especially regarding their future Disney+ series, Daredevil: Born Again.
The Penguin represents the inaugural spin-off set within Matt Reeves’ The Batman universe. Unlike the new DC cinematic universe being developed by James Gunn and Peter Safran, it operates independently from the earlier DCEU, which included titles like Man of Steel and Wonder Woman. While The Penguin operates outside the main DCU canon, Daredevil: Born Again is inherently part of the MCU’s narrative continuity, featuring returning characters from Netflix’s Daredevil series. Although these two shows belong to distinct universes, Daredevil: Born Again has the potential to resonate within the MCU in a manner similar to The Penguin’s impact on DC.
The Penguin: A Prestige Format for DC
Traditionally, DC’s television offerings have featured the Arrowverse series, which includes popular titles such as Arrow, The Flash, and Supergirl. While these series have garnered substantial fan love, they occupy a different space compared to The Penguin, which is tailored for a more sophisticated audience. As an HBO production, The Penguin can explore heavier themes and violence while benefiting from a larger budget for its action sequences, thereby achieving a prestigious status parallel to that of The Batman.
The elevated status of The Penguin doesn’t imply that all upcoming DC shows need to replicate its formula. However, it certainly introduces a refreshing departure from the usual offerings in the DC television landscape.
Daredevil: Born Again Needs to Emulate The Penguin’s Success
Potential Tone Shift for the MCU with Daredevil: Born Again
Similar to the Arrowverse, the MCU has cultivated a recognizable tone in its previous Disney+ offerings. Although Marvel’s shows span various genres, they typically adhere to the established superhero tone associated with the MCU. With Daredevil: Born Again, there lies an opportunity to diverge from this path and potentially develop a prestigious entry in the superhero drama genre.
The Marvel series on Netflix crafted a dark and intense narrative for Daredevil, endowed with a TV-MA rating that allowed it to delve deeply into the character’s violent world. This direction was well-received by audiences, maintaining an impressive 92% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Following a production hiatus in 2023, Marvel Studios initiated a creative reworking of Daredevil: Born Again, reportedly aiming to align its tone more closely with that of the Netflix series. Recent confirmations indicate that the series will retain its TV-MA rating on Disney+, a rarity it’s only previously showcased with Echo.
While Echo embraced a darker aesthetic than many MCU series, it fell short of achieving the prestige level demonstrated by The Penguin. However, Marvel’s decision to revamp Daredevil: Born Again suggests a desire to shift the tonal landscape of its Disney+ properties, potentially crafting a show that matches the caliber set by The Penguin.
Common Ground Between Daredevil: Born Again and The Penguin
In addition to tonal similarities, Daredevil: Born Again and The Penguin also share thematic connections. The Penguin delves into the criminal underbelly of Gotham City, presenting a narrative focused on the darker elements typically seen only from the perspective of the hero. Conversely, Daredevil: Born Again will likely adopt a street-level storyline, granting viewers a more realistic portrayal of New York City’s organized crime network.
This aspect represents another area where Daredevil: Born Again could learn from The Penguin’s approach. Highlighting Gotham through the lens of The Penguin, stepping away from Batman’s heroic narrative, invites exploration into the complexities of crime. This approach facilitates a novel type of superhero series, one that resonates more with classic mob dramas like The Sopranos or The Godfather. Such a shift has been positively received by viewers and could similarly benefit Daredevil: Born Again. Though inherently linked to superhero elements, Daredevil’s narrative is traditionally more grounded and bleak, navigating the unseen criminal factions manipulating New York City, in contrast to the fantastical threats typically faced by the Avengers.
Daredevil: Born Again: The MCU’s Own Sopranos?
All signs point to Daredevil: Born Again continuing as a crime-centric drama in the same vein as the Netflix adaptation, with Charlie Cox returning as Matt Murdock facing his nemesis, crime lord Wilson Fisk. Much like The Penguin, Daredevil: Born Again could develop Fisk’s character into a multi-dimensional antagonist, providing a rich backstory that makes him a formidable counterpart to Daredevil. This narrative approach would allow the series to build upon its criminal elements, potentially aligning its style with classic mobster dramas.
Details emerging about Daredevil: Born Again suggest a significant tonal evolution for MCU’s Disney+ projects. However, whether it can match the esteemed quality of The Penguin remains to be seen. Achieving this would represent a significant milestone for Marvel Studios, potentially paving the way for a fresh direction in MCU television programming.
Daredevil: Born Again is slated for release on Disney+ on March 4, 2025.
Image Credits: Gamerant.com
Related Articles:
Understanding Why Batman’s Strategy for the Justice League is Flawed
21:06
Are Superhero Origin Stories in Hollywood Now a Thing of the Past?
21:04
Final Trailer for Secret Level Hints at Warhammer 40K and Doomed PS5 Shooter
20:19
Leave a Reply