DC’s Poor Setup for the Next Justice League Movie

The DCU is just beginning to carve out its narrative, yet even within its inaugural offering, Creature Commandos, the franchise appears to be taking liberties with its depiction of the Justice League. As James Gunn endeavors to launch a new superhero universe to rival the MCU, the strategic direction for iconic characters like those in the Justice League remains somewhat ambiguous. Gunn has emphasized the importance of refining each script before moving forward with casting and directing—a decision that, while commendable, could severely impact the overall timeline of future projects.

For example, although both Superman’s new film and the next Batman installment were announced simultaneously in January 2023, the release dates diverge drastically. Superman is scheduled for a cinematic debut in July 2025, while Batman is still pending a finalized script. Furthermore, Gunn has indicated that the upcoming Superman film was not crafted with a view to establishing future storylines. While this commitment to standalone narratives is admirable, it raises questions about the cohesive future of a shared universe. Across the current DCU landscape, other developments are compounding the complications surrounding the Justice League.

Peacemaker’s Place in DCU Canon Raises Questions About Justice League

The Complexity of the DCU Canon

As the writer and creator of Peacemaker, Gunn is committed to building on the success of its first season, leading him to develop a second installment. He has previously stated that DCU canon is somewhat fluid; elements introduced are considered canon once referenced. With Peacemaker season 2 continuing the storyline of its predecessor and a brief cameo in episode four of Creature Commandos when Circe unveils her vision, it seems Peacemaker season 1 is now firmly embedded in the canon.

Notably, season 1 concluded with significant appearances by four pivotal members of the Justice League—Aquaman, Wonder Woman, Superman, and the Flash—immediately after Peacemaker and his team triumph over adversity. This suggests that Peacemaker is cognizant of these heroes and their significance. However, the question arises: will this iconic moment be ignored, edited out, or transformed in the evolving narrative? The notion of disregarding such a key event feels particularly awkward.

Creature Commandos Attempts to Redefine the Justice League

Defeated by a Vulnerable Princess from Pokolistan

In episode 4 of Creature Commandos, Circe’s prophetic vision introduces Princess Ilana as a formidable threat aiming for world domination. This unimposing human from a small, technologically backward country, teaming up with the supervillain Gorilla Grodd to take down the entire Justice League, raises eyebrows about the perceived weakness of the Justice League.

The early narrative decision to depict the Justice League’s downfall, even if merely a vision likely to be overwritten, diminishes the stature of these legendary characters. While this portrayal aims to amplify the seriousness of the threat faced by the Creature Commandos, it consequently detracts from the dignity of the Justice League. As the DCU aspires to establish a shared universe, it is imperative that these iconic heroes receive the respect they warrant.

The Justice League Deserves Greater Respect in the DCU

Top-Tier Superheroes Require Thoughtful Treatment

Steppenwolf in Zack Snyder's Justice League

The Justice League comprises some of the most potent characters in superhero lore. They symbolize god-like protectors, inspiring both fans and the general populace alike. The loyalty exhibited by their fanbase fuels passionate reactions to their portrayals across various media. Failure to treat these characters with the respect they deserve could lead to dissatisfaction among audiences.

If the DCU does not begin to anticipate how individual narratives will intertwine and how utilizing its most revered heroes as mere plot devices could undermine their legacy, it may encounter significant challenges ahead. The DCEU’s past missteps revealed difficulties in creating cohesion and character development. However, the DCU has a unique opportunity to succeed. By learning from the blunders of using the Justice League as mere narrative leverage in Creature Commandos, the franchise still has time to redeem itself.

Source & Images