Dexter: New Blood Episode 1 Review – Michael C. Hall Revives a Chaotic Prequel Premiere

WARNING: This article contains spoilers for the premiere episode of Dexter: Original Sin.

Introductory Overview of Dexter: Original Sin

The much-anticipated debut of Dexter: Original Sin, titled “And in the Beginning…”, revisits familiar narrative elements from the original series. However, it has yet to find a seamless integration between the beloved old characters and the new faces introduced. The episode opens with a dramatic scene that continues the storyline from Dexter: New Blood, featuring a critically injured Dexter being rushed to the hospital in Angela Bishop’s police cruiser. As he fights for his life, the haunting voiceover by Michael C. Hall, accompanied by the series’ iconic theme, sets a nostalgic yet hopeful tone.

Challenges of Reviving the Dexter Franchise

Launching a prequel series after the polarizing conclusions of the original series and New Blood poses significant challenges. Unfortunately, the premiere fails to capitalize on the potential for a compelling narrative. The character of Dexter, portrayed here by Patrick Gibson, is depicted as an eager Miami Metro forensics intern who is ready to take the darker plunge into his first kill following his recent college graduation.

Revisiting Dexter’s Backstory: A Missed Opportunity

Fans of the original Dexter series are already well-acquainted with his origin story, making the first episode’s extensive recapping feel repetitive. Instead of offering fresh perspectives, Original Sin opts for a safe retelling that lacks significant depth.

Classic Elements with Little New Insight

The episode introduces a cast of characters that will seem familiar to long-time fans. Vince Masuka retains his teasing charm, while a younger Debra Morgan displays her familiar defiance, even dragging Dexter to his college party—hinting at their complex sibling dynamic later in the series. Meanwhile, the show introduces heavy-hitting new characters, including performances by Patrick Dempsey and Sarah Michelle Gellar. Christian Slater takes on the role of a more empathetic Harry Morgan, offering a different take on Dexter’s father figure compared to James Remar’s portrayal.

Character Development and Pacing Concerns

The primary plot point—Dexter’s initiation into killing—is rushed, packed into a few hasty scenes featuring a rather simplistic character. The first 15 minutes of the episode struggle to maintain interest, hindered by an overly nostalgic soundtrack drowning out the narrative’s intensity.

Reflections on Dexter’s Childhood

While some past elements of Dexter’s childhood are shared, such as his fascination with Wrestlemania and his troubled upbringing, these insights lack groundbreaking revelations. The most significant revelation pertains to Harry, who had another son who tragically drowned while he was distracted by a football game, adding a shaded backstory to Dexter’s character.

Potential of Patrick Gibson’s Dexter

The Dynamic Duo: Patrick Gibson and Michael C. Hall

A highlight of the series is Patrick Gibson’s ability to take on the mantle of Dexter. Coupled with Michael C. Hall’s distinct voiceover, Original Sin showcases a promising interplay between the classic and newest iterations of Dexter Morgan. Clearing away plot points early, especially involving Nurse Mary, might pave the way for deeper explorations in future episodes as Dexter develops professional relationships, particularly with CSI Chief Tanya Martin.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Dexter: Original Sin

For Original Sin to capture the essence of what made the original series iconic, it must delve deeper into Dexter’s characteristics. Episode 2, titled “Kid in a Candy Store,”appears to hint at exploring darker themes, which could revitalize the narrative. A substantive villain must be introduced to elevate the stakes, transforming this prequel from a mere shadow of its predecessor into a standalone success.

In conclusion, while some moments resonate with the audience, further development is critical. A two-episode premiere could have offered more clarity and engagement. As the series unfolds, the chemistry between Gibson and Hall could serve as the lifeblood needed to redeem this prequel’s shaky start.

New episodes of Dexter: Original Sin are available every Friday on Paramount+ with Showtime.

Source & Images