Dexter: Resurrection – Why Dexter Should Be Portrayed as the True Villain

Key Insights on Dexter’s Transformation in Resurrection

In Dexter: Resurrection, Dexter Morgan may assume the role of the true antagonist, moving away from his traditional anti-hero persona.
The audience may initially resist Dexter’s evolution into a villain over the course of the series.
The shift to portraying Dexter as a villain in the original series’ second season laid a solid foundation for narrative intrigue.

Production for Dexter: Resurrection is set to begin in January 2025, with a scheduled release on Paramount+ in the following summer. Michael C. Hall is reprising his role as Dexter Morgan, grappling with the aftermath of being shot by his son, Harrison. Historically, Dexter has maintained an anti-hero status, yet the implications of his actions in the concluding episodes of New Blood suggest a potential pivot to outright villainy. This shift could offer a compelling narrative direction.

However, challenges may arise as the show intends to extend Dexter’s character arc across multiple seasons. Audience acceptance of this darker portrayal may wane over time. Nonetheless, depicting Dexter as an antagonist could resonate, particularly with the return of notable characters like Angel Batista and Vince Masuka.

Dexter’s Villainous Turn in Season Two

When Dexter debuted its second season in 2007, expectations were high following a successful first season. Fans were eager to uncover the identity of the season’s primary antagonist. To their astonishment, they learned that the true villain was, in a sense, Dexter Morgan himself. The show introduced a gruesome plot twist involving the discovery of dismembered bodies at sea, leading law enforcement to label the enigmatic killer as ‘The Bay Harbor Butcher’.

As it turned out, Dexter was the butcher, navigating the season under a web of deception to evade capture. This duality made him a captivating protagonist while simultaneously serving as the villain, a dynamic that became one of the defining storylines of the series.

The Shift to Villainy in New Blood

Dexter: Resurrection
Starring	Michael C. Hall (confirmed), Jack Alcott, David Zayas, Julia Jones, C. S Lee and Desmond Harrington (all rumored)
Created by	Clyde Phillips
Executive Producers	Clyde Phillips and Michael C. Hall

The second season was a masterstroke in storytelling, redefining Dexter Morgan’s character and framing him as a villain in his own narrative. This trend towards anti-heroes has become increasingly popular in modern television. The return of Dexter in Resurrection could further explore this trope, potentially casting him as the series’ apex villain.

In New Blood, Dexter’s moral compass faltered when he unjustifiably killed Coach Logan after the latter was revealed as the true Bay Harbor Butcher. While plot details for Resurrection remain under wraps, it is likely that the narrative will depict Dexter evading the law, possibly introducing a new antagonist who lacks his unique ethical guidelines. Complications are sure to arise as Miami Metro Homicide intensifies its focus on capturing one of history’s most infamous serial killers.

While portraying Dexter as an indiscriminate killer in Resurrection would misalign with his established character arc, it is conceivable that, much like Logan’s demise in New Blood, Dexter might find himself forced into a scenario where he must choose between his own freedom and adherence to his moral code. This could edge him closer to villainy, reflecting the gradual narrative transition initiated by the creators of New Blood. Abandoning this trajectory in Resurrection would feel inconsistent, particularly with expectations for multiple seasons ahead.

Source & Images