Doctor Who’s Fifteenth Doctor Challenge: What to Expect After the 2024 Christmas Episode in Season 15

The Fifteenth Doctor continues to navigate his way through the unique complexities of Doctor Who. The recent Christmas special serves as a crucial turning point, shedding light on the challenges still hampering his journey. Following any regeneration, both the audience and the Doctor experience a period of adjustment, seeking to understand this new incarnation. While some Doctors effortlessly embrace their roles as gallant heroes, others encounter difficulties in truly embodying the persona that has captured viewers’ hearts for over six decades.

Ncuti Gatwa’s portrayal of the Doctor has undeniably improved over the course of season 14, and his performance in the 2024 Christmas special showcases his growing confidence. Nevertheless, certain aspects appear to be missing. A distinctive aspect of the Doctor’s character is that a handful of core traits are preserved across various regenerations. For the Fifteenth Doctor, however, there seems to be an ongoing struggle to emerge as the iconic Time Lord that fans have loved for years, leading to questions about his heroic capabilities.

“Joy To The World”: Depicting a Struggling Doctor

The Doctor Observes While Others Take Action

In “Joy to the World,”the Doctor arrives at the Time Hotel, quickly sensing that something is amiss. Despite his urgency in seeking solutions, he ultimately fails to resolve key issues on his own. Due to his hasty actions, the hotel manager he seeks assistance from meets a tragic end, and a young woman in 2024 becomes inadvertently encumbered with a suitcase linked to a deeper crisis.

Further complicating matters, he relies on a future version of himself to access the code for disarming the briefcase, a detail that remains unexplained, resulting in his confinement for a year within the hotel. The emotionally charged scenes that follow are poignant, yet it is Joy, rather than the Doctor, who makes the ultimate sacrifice to avert disaster alongside unwanted assistance from the deceased hotel manager.

Balancing Flaws with Heroism in the Doctor’s Character

The Doctor Deserves the Spotlight

The Doctor is defined by imperfection and vulnerability, yet stands as a beacon of heroism. This character has continually saved the universe, confronting incredible foes with little more than his intellect and the trusty sonic screwdriver. However, in season 14, the Doctor’s heroism has faltered. From stumbling on a mine to running away faced with threats, his effectiveness as a hero in episodes such as “Joy to the World”has diminished.

While he typically walks away from challenges with meaningful lessons learned, the narrative often sidelines him. He frequently empowers supporting characters to conduct brave feats, whether it be Ruby confronting Sutekh or a soldier rising to the occasion in “Boom.”Consequently, the Doctor feels more like an onlooker in these tales, and though allowing secondary characters to shine is valuable, it should not come at the cost of diminishing the Doctor’s presence.

Doctor Who Season 15 Must Reinstate the Doctor’s Heroism

Rallying for a Defining Hero Moment

The Doctor and Joy in the Christmas special

When David Tennant debuted as the Tenth Doctor, he interrupted the Sycorax’s threatening takeover of Earth with remarkable authority. Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor instilled fear in the Atraxi simply by proclaiming his identity, while Peter Capaldi’s Twelfth Doctor unraveled a complex mystery with skill. Each successor marked growth as a hero, yet Gatwa’s Doctor appears to be waiting for that pivotal moment to shine.

There is hope that Russell T Davies will ensure season 15 places the Doctor in positions of genuine danger, allowing him to emerge victorious and reclaim his status as the show’s hero rather than remaining a passive figure. With each new episode, we witness flickering glimpses of Ncuti’s potential, and it’s crucial for the series to fully embrace his strengths, affirming his rightful place in the franchise. There remains plenty of time for the Fifteenth Doctor to leave a lasting impact.

Source & Images