Doctor Who’s Tribute to Martha’s First Appearance Highlights the Series’ Most Underappreciated Companion

The 2024 Christmas Special of Doctor Who includes a poignant nod to a former companion, spotlighting the limited opportunities she had during her tenure on the show. Since its revival in 2005, Doctor Who has featured six different actors in the iconic role of the Doctor, who journeys through time and space with an array of companions.

While many companions have forged deep, familial bonds with the Doctor, a select few have enjoyed unique connections. Rose Tyler stands out for her romantic relationship with the Doctor, while Donna Noble became his closest friend. Companions like Amy Pond and Rory Williams even became part of the Doctor’s extended family. However, it is essential to recognize that not all companions received such heartfelt farewells or recognition.

Christmas Special Revives the Iconic Hospital from “Smith & Jones”

Revisiting Martha Jones’ Origin

In the Christmas episode titled “Joy to the World,”the Doctor, portrayed by Ncuti Gatwa, teams up with a new character named Joy. Joy’s storyline poignantly reflects her struggles during the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly the heart-wrenching experience of losing her mother while unable to visit her in the hospital due to lockdown restrictions. This narrative is compelling and deeply touching, yet amidst the emotional richness, it subtly references the Royal Hope hospital – a location rooted in the show’s past.

The Royal Hope hospital first appeared in “Smith & Jones,”the opening episode of Season 3, where the Doctor welcomed Martha Jones, played by Freema Agyeman, into the TARDIS. This deliberate reference not only connects the current narrative to the series’ legacy but also highlights an often-overlooked issue: Martha Jones was not fully realized as a character during her time on the show.

Martha Jones: The Most Underutilized Companion in Modern Doctor Who

Missed Opportunities for Development

Martha Jones entered the TARDIS shortly after the Doctor’s separation from Rose Tyler, who had been pulled into a different universe. This emotional context meant that the Doctor was still grappling with his feelings for Rose. Upon meeting Martha, however, she was drawn to him, captivated by his intellect and bravery against formidable foes like the Judoon. Unfortunately, despite her own intelligence and independence as a medical doctor, Martha’s character often fell into the trope of being a lovesick companion longing for the Doctor’s affection.

This dynamic created an imbalance in their relationship, leading to moments where Martha had to navigate adventures alone, further developing her resilience. While her journey transformed her into a capable and strong character—going on to serve as an important agent for UNIT—the lack of a meaningful relationship with the Doctor left her character feeling underexplored. The recent reference to her in the Christmas Special serves as a poignant reminder of her untapped potential during her time on Doctor Who.

Source & Images