Evidence Suggests DC Comics May Have a Hidden Fourth Joker

The Joker stands out as one of the most intricate villains in literature, embodying a constantly shifting persona. Over the years, DC Comics has delved deeply into this elusive nature, with recent narratives affirmatively suggesting that the Joker possesses at least three distinct personalities. Yet, I am convinced that there exists a fourth persona, hinted at through various clues within the source material.

Numerous interpretations have emerged, showcasing the Joker’s multifaceted personality. Notably, in the acclaimed Three Jokers storyline by Geoff Johns and Jason Fabok, the theory is explored that the Joker may actually be comprised of three different individuals.

Comic book page: three of the Joker's personalities express their emotions.

Conversely, Chip Zdarsky takes a unique approach in his Batman series, proposing that the Joker’s diverse personalities stem from his training with Dr. Daniel Captio, the same psychiatrist who aided Batman in developing his alternate Zur-En-Arrh identity. Unlike Batman, who developed a single backup personality, the Joker capitalized on the concept, resulting in three prominent personas explored in the The Joker Year One arc, crafted by Zdarsky and Giuseppe Camuncoli.

The Original Joker Was Not Always a Supervillain

Art from Batman: The Killing Joke by Alan Moore and Brian Bolland

Comic book art: Joker laughing maniacally, iconic image from Alan Moore's series.

The most commonly recognized Joker personas include the impish jokester, the ruthless killer, and the meticulous strategist. This triad of personalities explains the vast range of his behavior—from harmless clowning to monstrous brutality. While many fans accept these three as the full extent of the Joker’s character, I argue that several hints suggest a deeper, hidden persona.

The transformation into the Joker was ignited by a singular traumatic event. Before his descent into madness, he was a man—often referred to as Jack—who led a normal life complete with familial connections, as described in both Batman: The Killing Joke and Batman: Three Jokers. Although DC maintains a veil over this background, it remains the most widely accepted narrative amongst enthusiasts, allowing us to consider it as part of the character’s lore.

The Joker’s Hidden Personality

The Existence of a Fourth Joker

Comic book panels: Joker expressing fear of Batman

Trained by Captio, the Joker symbolically extinguished his former self to embrace his new identity. However, erasing one’s original persona is no simple task, even for him. While the nefarious aspects of the Joker dominate his behavior, he has exhibited moments of vulnerability, particularly in the absence of Batman, allowing shadows of his “former self”to surface.

In Batman: Going Sane by J.M. DeMatteis, the Joker believes he has successfully vanquished Batman and voluntarily steps back from crime, opting for a semblance of normalcy—a life that mirrors his existence before the chaos consumed him. This behavior raises questions about the sincerity of his villainous personas, suggesting that perhaps an inherent desire for redemption lingers beneath.

Additionally, the Joker’s sporadic attempts to act heroically compound this theory. His life-threatening antics often sit alongside appalling acts, yet glimpses of altruism appear throughout his history. It seems plausible that the suppressed persona—the ordinary man from his past—could be influencing these actions.

The Joker as a Hero in an Alternate Universe

Jack Napier in Batman: White Knight

Comic book art: The White Knight version of Joker and Harley Quinn appearing as normal citizens.

In the alternate universe depicted in Batman: White Knight by Sean Murphy, the character Jack Napier showcases a compelling contrast to his darker self, as he assumes the role of a virtuous individual. This portrayal splits the Joker’s essence into two personas: the benevolent Napier who takes heroic actions to save Gotham and the malevolent Joker who embodies chaos and violence. This narrative choice supports the notion that the Joker might inherently contain a good personality.

Additional evidence arises from JLA by Grant Morrison, where the Martian Manhunter probes the Joker’s psyche, uncovering a persistent memory of a loving couple hidden deep within his consciousness. While the Joker is characterized as indifferent to human life, this memory implies a contrasting personality may reside within him, possibly tied to his earlier identity.

The Joker Is More Than a Monster

Where is the Fourth Personality?

Throughout his narrative, the Joker has frequently exhibited moments of clarity, laying down his criminal ways without external forces triggering these changes. For instance, in the action arc “I, Bizarro,” he reveals a nature that leans toward helpfulness without the shadow of madness looming over him. Similarly, Batman: Going Sane illustrates how the Joker can revert to normalcy without needing a cure, indicating that a semblance of goodness remains entwined with his psyche.

For readers interested in exploring more of the Joker’s multifaceted identity, the recent comic The Joker: The Man Who Stopped Laughing by Matthew Rosenberg, Carmine Di Giandomenico, and Francesco Francavilla is worth checking out, available both digitally and in collected editions.

Critics of Batman often argue that eliminating the Joker would end the chaos. However, if I am correct in asserting the existence of a fourth persona, we might identify a victim overlooked in this intricate story: the man the Joker once was. If Batman could awaken this hidden self, redemption could be possible. While this theory may seem far-fetched, the clues point toward a deeper, more complex narrative within the Joker’s psyche, suggesting that hidden beneath the chaotic villain exists a personality deserving of salvation.

Batman: The Joker Year One is currently available from DC Comics!

Source & Images