Explained: The Real Killer in Knives Out and the Ending Details

In Rian Johnson’s intricate murder mystery, Knives Out, audiences are treated to unexpected surprises, particularly in the film’s conclusion that unveils the genuine tragedy surrounding the demise of renowned author Harlan Thrombey, portrayed by Christopher Plummer. Daniel Craig takes center stage as Benoit Blanc, a private investigator enlisted to unravel the circumstances of what initially appears to be Harlan’s suicide following a familybirthday celebration. Throughout the narrative, Blanc uncovers that every member of the Thrombey clan harbors motives for Harlan’s death, ranging from concealing illicit affairs to jeopardizing his substantial estate.

While each character bears the weight of their respective sins, the true perpetrator of Harlan’s murder is revealed to be his grandson, Hugh Ransom Drysdale, played by Chris Evans. The unraveling of the plot occurs through flashbacks and unexpected twists, especially during the film’s climactic moments. Johnson successfully replicates this complex narrative style in its sequel, Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery, yet it is the nail-biting twists in the original that continue to captivate conversation. Given the rapid pacing of the finale, viewers often find themselves grappling with confusion.

What Actually Happens in the Knives Out Ending

Ransom Is Caught, and Marta Is Innocent

The intense third act sees Marta confronting Fran, who holds critical evidence: a copy of Harlan’s blood test, indicating Ransom’s culpability. With Fran in a dire state, Marta is drawn into a confession, revealing her accidental role in Harlan’s morphine administration. Following Marta’s near confession to the Thrombey family, Blanc sifts through the details and realizes her innocence.

In a masterclass of deduction typical of the Benoit Blanc character, he reconstructs the events leading to Harlan’s death, including Ransom’s clandestine entry into the house, his maneuvering through the trellis, and the medication mishap. As the plot unfolds, Ransom, believing he is cornered due to Fran’s potential testimony, ultimately confesses.

However, a significant twist reveals that Fran has passed away, and Marta strategically recorded Ransom’s confession on her phone. Following a failed assault on Marta, authorities apprehend Ransom, while she inherits Harlan’s vast estate, including the family mansion.

Harlan’s Death in Knives Out Explained

Harlan Kills Himself to Protect Marta

Audiences are thrown a curveball early in Knives Out as the film promptly reveals Harlan’s demise. During his evening medication routine with nurse Marta (Ana de Armas), an accidental mix-up leads to Harlan receiving a fatal dose of morphine due to mistaken vials. Realizing the only antidote is missing, and fearing the repercussions that could affect Marta and her family, Harlan devises a plan for her safety that unfolds tragically.

In a desperate bid to mislead the circumstance of his death, Harlan chooses to inflict a fatal injury upon himself, attempting to disguise it as suicide rather than an accident. Ultimately, it’s disclosed that his death, though self-inflicted, is a consequence of Ransom’s sinister scheming—he orchestrated the scenario to frame Marta as the unwitting murderer, a ploy designed to reclaim a fortune he believed was stolen from him.

How Harlan Thrombey Died (& Who Killed Him)

Why Ransom Was Still Guilty

While Harlan Thrombey literally inflicted the fatal wound, the real tragedy lies in the fact that Ransom’s manipulation led to his death. Despite Harlan not receiving an actual morphine overdose, Ransom’s intricate scheme to frame Marta involved swapping medication labels and staging events that would compel Harlan to take drastic actions.

Marta, burdened by guilt yet inadvertently acting on instinct, successfully administered the correct dosage when it mattered most. Harlan’s choice to take his own life was ultimately rooted in a convoluted plot devised by Ransom, who had been estranged from Harlan’s fortune due to the latter’s decision to leave everything to Marta.

Ransom’s Plan & Fran’s Murder

Ransom’s Original Plan to Kill Harlan Was Changed

Fran behind crime scene tape in Knives Out

Ransom’s plot was straightforward: after storming out due to Harlan’s revised will, he returned under the cover of darkness to swap the medicine labels, ensuring a lethal outcome for Harlan. Unexpected events intervened, however, such as being observed by Harlan’s mother and subsequent nighttime intrusions during the funeral undertakings.

With meticulous planning, Ransom covertly engaged Benoit Blanc to investigate Harlan’s death, convinced that the investigation would implicate Marta. However, a series of unforeseen circumstances caused his scheme to unravel, not least of which was Fran’s realization of Ransom’s tampering and her efforts to hold him accountable through evidence of her own.

Why Ransom’s Plan Failed

Marta’s Genuine Goodness Foiled Ransom

As Ransom’s machinations progressed, events spiraled out of his control. Fran managed to survive long enough to implicate Ransom before succumbing, and amidst this tumult, Marta’s instincts to save her friend contributed to unveiling the truth.

Instead of allowing Fran to meet a tragic fate, Marta took immediate action, calling for medical assistance. By this moral act, she fostered insights for Blanc, further clear regarding Fran’s evidence. When Marta ultimately confronted the Thrombey clan, Blanc stood ready to unveil the authenticity behind Ransom’s deceptive tactics.

In a remarkable turn, when Marta reassured Ransom that Fran’s survival ensured his downfall, he inadvertently unveiled his own guilt. In a stunning twist, she had recorded his confession, sealing his culpability, which showcases the fulfilling pay-off of her moral integrity throughout the narrative.

Why Ransom Was the Best Choice for the Killer

The Film Chose a Wise Way to Tease & Then Reveal the Truth

Knives Out: Ransom lunges at Marta with a knife

In crafting its compelling murder mystery, Knives Out nails the balance of providing a shocking yet plausible revelation concerning the identity of the killer—Ransom. His portrayal as the unlikable heir becomes central to audience engagement, as viewers initially overlook his potential as the murderer, positioning him as a red herring.

The narrative effectively plays with audience expectations, allowing for an element of surprise upon revealing Ransom’s deceit. This intricately woven story culminates into a satisfying twist that transcends standard genre conventions, showcasing Marta’s genuine persona as the stabilizing force amid the Thrombey family’s entitlement.

The Real Meaning of Knives Out’s Ending

Despite the somber themes surrounding Harlan’s passage, the conclusion of Knives Out radiates an uplifting message. Marta’s triumph in evading wrongful accusation stems from her deep-rooted morals and underlying benevolence. Her intent to protect Harlan was borne not from self-interest but rather from her compassion.

Marta’s innate revulsion to dishonesty—literally manifested in her physical reaction—contrasts strikingly with the avarice embodied by the Thrombey family. The profound implications of inherited privilege versus personal merit become apparent when Harlan’s decision to bestow his legacy on Marta is revealed, having recognized her authentic kindness without ulterior motives.

Harlan’s decision to exclude his own kin, who felt entitled to his wealth, highlights a broader societal critique of inherited affluence and entitlement. The dynamics of Knives Out challenge notions of privilege, revealing that Marta’s essential goodness and diligent character ultimately prevail over the Thrombeys’ manipulative personas.

How The Knives Out Ending Was Received

Knives Out Finds a New Way to Trick the Audience

Knives Out has solidified its reputation as one of the quintessential murder mysteries, largely due to its effective conclusion. A compelling mystery hinges on the balance between clarity and unpredictability, forging an atmosphere where audiences remain engaged and challenged in their deductions.

Contemporary viewers often enjoy piecing together mystery solutions, using an extensive array of genre examples to guide their guesses. Knives Out, however, introduces an ingenious layer of deception by appearing to identify the true murderer early in its narrative. A viewer, reflecting on their experience, remarked about the film’s innovative approach:

The ‘reveal’ of Marta as the killer so early in the movie was intriguing and a cool direction for the genre. Managed to actually misdirect me for a while, as I began to think the rest of the whole movie would be about her subtly sabotaging the investigation to avoid suspicion.

This strategic misdirection allows the audience to focus elsewhere, enabling Ransom’s eventual revelation as the villain to strike harder. Consequently, viewers find themselves re-engaging with the film, discovering new evidence with every revisit.

Watching Benoit Blanc methodically piece together the puzzle provides immense entertainment while serving to elevate his status among cinematic detectives. Ultimately, the concluding triumph of Marta—a character who exemplifies moral resilience even in the face of wrongdoing—cements the film’s lasting impact.

How The Glass Onion Mystery Compares to the Knives Out Murder

The Benoit Blanc Mysteries Continue

Both Knives Out and its sequel, Glass Onion, delve into the layers of deception surrounding their respective murder mysteries, yet they adopt distinctly different tones. In Glass Onion, the humor features a more exaggerated flair, allowing for a perception of simplicity amidst its complexities, contrasting with the tightly woven narrative of the original.

While both films interplay present narrative with flashbacks, the emotional undertone differs. Marta’s struggles with guilt juxtaposed with her fear of repercussions stand stark against Helen’s outward chaos and betrayal. The evolution in narrative complexity appears more streamlined in Glass Onion as well, moving away from the backtracking approach of Knives Out, facilitating smoother revelations.

Ultimately, both films capitalize on intricate storytelling and character complexity to craft captivating narratives that verify Rian Johnson’s prowess as a storyteller in the mystery genre.

Source & Images