Fake Nintendo Lawyer DMCA Takedowns Targeting Gaming YouTubers

Overview of Recent DMCA Abuse Targeting YouTube Channels

YouTube gaming channels featuring Nintendo content, such as Domtendo, have been subjected to fraudulent DMCA takedowns.
Nintendo has confirmed the authenticity issues regarding bogus takedown emails and is currently investigating these incidents.

In recent developments, YouTube channels focusing on Nintendo games have come under cyber scrutiny due to fraudulent DMCA takedown notices. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) framework facilitates copyright holders to report unauthorized content; however, this system is increasingly being exploited to target unsuspecting creators. This is particularly pressing for channels featuring Nintendo’s popular titles, given the company’s historically stringent approach to protecting its intellectual property online.

When it comes to issuing takedown requests, Nintendo has maintained a strict stance, sometimes resulting in significant repercussions for content creators. For example, the developer of Garry’s Mod faced a staggering removal of two decades’ worth of Nintendo-related content due to such notices. Unfortunately, the current wave of false DMCA claims appears to involve impersonators pretending to represent Nintendo, further complicating the landscape for legitimate content creators.

Persistent Fake DMCA Takedowns Affecting YouTube Community

In late September, YouTuber Dominik “Domtendo” Neumayer received a suspicious DMCA takedown notice that seemed to originate from Nintendo. A significant red flag arose when he noticed the email was sent from an address affiliated with ProtonMail, rather than an official Nintendo domain. While YouTubers hold the option to contest such takedown requests, doing so comes with risks to their channel integrity. There are instances where channels, like Did You Know Gaming, have successfully navigated disputes against Nintendo.

Upon further investigation, Domtendo discovered that the sender, identified as Tatsumi Masaaki, was not a recognized Nintendo representative. As reported by The Verge, while a person by that name does exist at Nintendo’s Kyoto headquarters, they do not work for Nintendo America, as the fraudulent email attempted to suggest. Given Nintendo’s well-documented history of aggressive legal actions, particularly against fan-made projects—such as the removal of a fan-created Pokémon FPS—it’s understandable why creators might initially perceive these bogus DMCA claims as legitimate.

Following the receipt of the dubious email, Domtendo sought verification from Nintendo. He received confirmation on October 10 that the email was indeed a fraud. Nintendo clarified, “Please note that tatsumi-masaaki@protonmail.com is not a legitimate Nintendo email address, and the details within that communication do not align with Nintendo of America Inc.’s enforcement practices. We are investigating this matter further.”Unfortunately, even after this revelation, Domtendo encountered further spoofed DMCA notices aimed at his content, underscoring the systemic problem of leveraging DMCA takedowns fraudulently within the YouTube landscape.

As this troubling trend continues, YouTube remains largely silent on the matter, allowing these fraudulent copyright strikes to jeopardize the security of countless creators. The misuse of the DMCA system poses a significant challenge for the YouTube gaming community.

Source & Images