‘Fandom’s Toxic Influence’: Alan Moore’s Take on Fan Culture

In today’s society, a segment of fans believes they dictate the narrative. The harmful environment cultivated by such fandom has permeated online communities, making it exceedingly challenging to appreciate art without bias. Creatives often find themselves needing to conform to these demands or risk inciting the ire of a hostile fanbase.

Alan Moore, famed for his iconic works like Watchmen, has openly discussed how the toxicity stemming from fandom can seep into broader societal issues. Upon initially voicing his concerns, Moore faced significant backlash from these fans. However, he has returned with a new article, featured in The Guardian, which examines contemporary fandom’s problematic impact.

“Fandom is an essential and vibrant component of modern culture that prevents stagnation, atrophy, and death,” Moore articulates in his article. “However, it can also serve as a hideous affliction that corrupts the surrounding society with its bitter obsessions and a misplaced, unwarranted sense of entitlement.”

Moore addresses the kind of fandom that targets creators. This includes individuals who resort to threats over differing opinions. He emphasizes that, amidst this toxicity, there exist healthier factions within fandom that genuinely appreciate media and support fellow enthusiasts. That’s the environment I cherish—discussing beloved characters and cherished narratives with friends.

Those who perpetuate the negative atmosphere within fandom certainly don’t merit our admiration. Hearing creatives like Moore denounce them is empowering, especially since many fans—particularly women—have been warning about this toxicity for years.

Moore’s Insights on the Influence of Toxic Fandom

People frequently suggest “just ignore them” when discussing problematic fans. The reality, however, is that neglect only fuels their proliferation. Their animosity acts like a contagion, invading fandom spaces and gradually becoming the perceived norm. Many of us continually advocate for positivity and express our fondness for media, yet toxic fans retort with more vitriol.

Moore is spot-on. Movements like Gamergate and Comicsgate have granted a platform to the darker inclinations of certain fans. This unchecked hostility has led others to unjustly claim ownership over what they believe should belong exclusively to them.

“At an alarming rate, we find ourselves living in a culture predominantly shaped by fandom,” Moore observes. “Our entertainment can face premature cancellations due to negative fan responses, and we may be subjected to largely misogynistic campaigns like Gamergate or Comicsgate, driven by those who misconstrue the term ‘gate’ as synonymous with ‘conspiracy’—perhaps forgetting that Nixon’s scandal was rooted in a simple cover-up. Yet, this doesn’t fully capture the extent to which fan attitudes have tainted our world, particularly evident in our political landscape.”

I genuinely appreciate creatives like Moore standing up against such fans. It instills a sense of pride within me, although I wish we could exist without the shadow of toxicity at all.

Source