Gwen Stacy Faces Consequences in Marvel’s Spider-Verse Dilemma

Warning: Spoilers for Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider (2024) #9 ahead! Since the inception of Marvel’s Spider-Verse, one character has emerged as a standout: Gwen Stacy, famously known as Spider-Gwen. However, the overwhelming popularity of this multiverse saga might be posing challenges for Gwen’s character, as evidenced in her latest series.

In Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider (2024) #9, Gwen is compromised by a poisoning from the antagonist Mr. Fear, leaving her mostly inactive throughout the issue. Instead, action is primarily driven by a new character, Black Tarantula—a potential love interest entangled in his own villainous subplot.

Gwen is trapped and shackled in a cage. The villain Black Tarantula looms over her.

Throughout much of this series, Spider-Gwen is relegated to the role of a damsel in distress, a disappointing reduction of her character in her own narrative.

Marvel Faces a Dilemma with Gwen Stacy

Spider-Gwen with original Gwen Stacy's death scene behind her.

For those familiar with Gwen’s origins, she hails from an alternate universe where she evolves into Spider-Woman instead of facing her tragic fate alongside Peter Parker. This iteration, introduced in Edge of Spider-Verse (2014) #2, has skyrocketed in popularity, especially after her appearance in the successful Spider-Verse animated films. Marvel has since integrated her into mainstream continuity with Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider, transitioning from her unique universe.

Readers connected with Gwen in Earth-65, where she showcased her artistic flair, acrobatic skills, and an emotionally charged life that involved being a drummer in the band The Mary Janes amid personal tragedy. Gwen’s character is defined by her determination and personal growth, often learning from her mistakes as she navigates her dual life.

Gwen Stacy’s Role on Earth-616 Lacks Depth

However, the essence of the Gwen the fans adore feels absent in Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider. Across nine issues, Gwen is often portrayed as guilty, anxious, or in need of rescue, reducing her heroic stature significantly. Notably, seven out of eleven covers feature her in victim scenarios, highlighting this concerning trend of diminished agency in what should be her story.

Gwen finds herself trapped in a precarious situation: she is popular enough to earn a place in mainstream continuity, yet her identity feels muddled among the many Spider-characters. Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #1 further complicates this by emphasizing Gwen’s role as a tragic figure in Spider-Man’s narrative. This setup suggests a lost opportunity for a captivating fish-out-of-water storyline, raising concerns that Marvel’s strategy is to confine her to clichéd romance and rescue arcs outside her original milieu.

How Will Marvel Manage Its Spider-Heroes?

The landscape of Earth-616 is saturated with Spider-persons, including well-known figures like Peter Parker and Miles Morales, along with seasoned characters like Jessica Drew, Madame Web, and Silk, alongside burgeoning heroes such as Spider-Boy. The saturation makes it challenging for Gwen to carve out a distinctive identity, especially when her series often undermines her strengths. Although there are narrative connections to the TVA, placing her back into a multiversal context only detracts from establishing her presence on Earth-616.

While Gwen Stacy remains an intriguing and well-loved character, her integration into Marvel’s Spider-centric universe highlights the inconsistencies within the Spider-Verse. It’s clear that Gwen possesses immense potential, validated through numerous adventures across comics and films. However, the decision to position her in mainstream continuity raises questions about her future, as it strips her of the tailored environment that nurtured her unique talents. Marvel must reevaluate its approach to the Spider-Verse to ensure that Gwen Stacy can thrive rather than be overshadowed.

Source&Images