How Harry Potter’s TV Remake Can Resolve Issues the Original Series and Cursed Child Faced

HBO’s forthcoming adaptation of the Harry Potter series holds significant potential to address a longstanding issue present in the stage adaptation, Harry Potter and The Cursed Child. This narrative extension occurs 19 years post-Deathly Hallows and attempts to challenge the pervasive stereotype that all Slytherins are malevolent. While the original literary saga struggled to sufficiently counter this trope, HBO’s new series could embark on a more balanced portrayal of Slytherin characters, offering a deeper exploration of morality within the house.

The HBO remake aims to stay truer to the source material than previous films, yet it would be beneficial to diverge from certain elements of the original works to establish from the outset that Slytherins are not inherently evil. Doing so would enrich character arcs, especially that of Severus Snape later in the series. His eventual redemption is impactful, but it would resonate more if early portrayals of Slytherins included some redeeming qualities, setting a more nuanced stage for these characters.

Addressing Slytherin Stereotypes in The Cursed Child

Albus Severus Potter’s Sorting

Scorpius and Albus in Harry Potter and The Cursed Child

Set nearly two decades after Deathly Hallows, The Cursed Child begins by confronting the various stereotypes linked to Slytherins. Albus Severus Potter, Harry’s younger son, is sorted into Slytherin, defying the expectations of his lineage and initiating the play’s central conflict as he grapples with his identity at Hogwarts.

This choice echoes Harry’s own sorting ceremony; had he not protested, he would have found himself among Slytherins. Such an instance reinforces the inherent bias against Slytherins that persists throughout the series. Although several characters from this house align with its more negative traits, The Cursed Child seeks to counter this narrative through the bond between Albus and his friend Scorpius.

Limitations in Redeeming Slytherin

The Friendship of Albus and Scorpius

Old Harry Potter vs. The Cursed Child Characters — Custom Image by SR Editor

The friendship between Albus and Scorpius is undeniably charming, yet its introduction late in the series largely serves little purpose for earlier narratives. While their bond illustrates that not all Slytherins conform to negative stereotypes, it does little to mitigate Harry’s continuing prejudice against the house—a prejudice that spans nearly two decades. Reflecting on these issues in The Cursed Child might have held more weight had the original series confronted Slytherin complexities earlier on.

Although The Cursed Child bravely attempts to redeem Slytherins, its timing appears ineffective for changing long-held perceptions. By the time the stage production appears, the reader’s biases are already entrenched, potentially diminishing the impact of its themes. Further character development of Slytherins in the original works, similar to Rowling’s nuanced portrayal of Snape, could have laid a solid foundation for this redemption arc to flourish.

HBO’s Harry Potter Remake: An Opportunity for Change

Reimagining Slytherin’s Representation

HBO’s adaptation holds the promise of redefining Slytherin’s narrative from the very beginning. Contrary to the traditional portrayal of Slytherin characters as solely cunning and ruthless, the new series should emphasize that ambition and resourcefulness can manifest as positive traits. Aspects such as dedication to academic achievement can be uplifting and should be spotlighted within the adaptation.

Furthermore, instead of depicting Slytherin students, like Draco Malfoy, solely as products of corrupt backgrounds, it is crucial to illustrate that such a characterization does not apply to the entire house. It raises questions about the plausibility of a quarter of the Hogwarts population being inclined towards dark deeds. Addressing this stereotype head-on would present a refreshing perspective in the Harry Potter television series, emphasizing that a minority of Slytherins do not reflect the entirety of their house.

Source & Images