How Lord Of The Rings Outperformed Dune in Cinematic Techniques by 20 Years

Denis Villeneuve’s adaptations of Dune captivate audiences with their exceptional storytelling and cinematic artistry. However, it’s noteworthy that the Lord of the Rings franchise established an essential narrative element first. Both of these significant franchises excel in seamlessly blending blockbuster entertainment with artistic merit, bringing beloved works of fantasy and science fiction literature to life. The film adaptations by Peter Jackson and Denis Villeneuve stand as definitive representations of their respective iconic narratives.

J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings was published from 1954 to 1955, while Frank Herbert’s influential novel Dune followed in 1965, illustrating a continuum of monumental storytelling in the genre. Despite the epic nature of both narratives and their groundbreaking world-building, they present considerably different thematic elements. Interestingly, Tolkien reportedly disapproved of Herbert’s work, even though it garnered significant acclaim. Yet, there’s a crucial aspect of Tolkien’s story that resonates within Dune, which often goes unnoticed.

Shared Depictions of Male Relationships in LOTR and Dune

Celebrating Healthy Masculinity Among Protagonists

The Fellowship from Lord of the Rings shares remarkable similarities with the men of House Atreides in Dune. Both Tolkien and Herbert intentionally crafted male relationships characterized by healthy masculinity and respect. The film adaptations faithfully reflect this dynamic. Whether through light-hearted banter between characters like Legolas and Gimli or the connection between Duncan Idaho and Paul, their interactions are always underscored by a deep sense of respect and camaraderie.

In these narratives, masculinity is portrayed in a nuanced light. Notably, the characters display physical affection and vulnerability towards one another, illustrating a broader definition of strength. Consider Frodo and Sam as prime examples, alongside Aragorn’s moment of reassurance in The Fellowship of the Ring, where he reminds his companions to “stay true to each other.”Leto Atreides embodies a similar sentiment, fostering bonds with Paul and his household.

The Significance of Exemplary Masculinity in Storytelling

The Need for Positive Male Role Models in Film

Aragorn listening to bad news with soldiers in the background from The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.

Highlighting this kind of masculinity is crucial, particularly in action-oriented cinematic experiences that appeal predominantly to male viewers. Numerous films often depict male leads displaying detrimental behaviors toward women or struggling to connect with other men.

Watching The Lord of the Rings or Dune offers audiences thrilling adventures and nuanced storytelling. While Dune portrays Paul’s complex moral descent, contrasting the more optimistic themes of Tolkien, both narratives undeniably illustrate the strength found in positive male relationships, vulnerability, and the profound impact these characteristics have on individuals. Although Tolkien’s work may emphasize this theme more prominently, it remains a fundamental aspect of Herbert’s portrayal of House Atreides, rendering their journeys compelling.

Dune as the Modern Equivalent of The Lord of the Rings

Dune Inherits LOTR’s Cultural Legacy

Paul Atreides and Duke sharing a moment in Dune (2021)

In the context of contemporary film franchises, Dune now occupies the cultural space once held by The Lord of the Rings in the early 2000s. Beyond the exploration of masculinity, both franchises construct elaborate universes that feel authentic and rich in detail. Their directors not only capture grand scales but also infuse these worlds with lived experiences, engaging viewers in remarkable narratives.

Denis Villeneuve has risen significantly in esteem with the success of Dune: Part Two in 2024, establishing himself among the top contemporary directors. Meanwhile, Peter Jackson, though less prolific post-LOTR, remains a celebrated figure. Both directors transformed the notion of adapting “unfilmable”novels into stunning visual experiences, earning a place in the hearts of audiences worldwide. While their narratives differ thematically, they both reflect the cinematic language of their time, showcasing the evolving nature of storytelling in film.

Source & Images