Hu Tao vs Nahida: Which Character to Choose in Genshin Impact 5.1 Second Half

The second phase of Genshin Impact version 5.1 is on the horizon, bringing with it the return of two highly sought-after characters with rerun banners. Starting on October 29, 2024, players will have the opportunity to wish for the 5-Star Pyro character, Hu Tao, alongside the 5-Star Dendro Archon, Nahida. Given that many players may have a limited stash of Primogems, deciding between these two can be quite challenging.

Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of both Nahida and Hu Tao can assist you in making an informed choice about which character to pursue. Continue reading to discover which of these two heroes offers better utility and gameplay ease, and ultimately who should be your pick.

Should you choose Hu Tao or Nahida in Genshin Impact 5.1?

Both Nahida and Hu Tao fulfill specific roles within Genshin Impact 5.1, making them valuable additions to various team compositions. However, it’s essential to weigh their unique advantages and disadvantages before making a decision.

Hu Tao: Advantages and Disadvantages

Hu Tao is a strong DPS character (Image via HoYoverse)

Hu Tao is a powerful 5-Star Pyro character who wields a Polearm and can unleash tremendous damage. She typically serves as a Pyro vape DPS in many setups, with her Elemental Burst capable of inflicting significant harm. Here’s a breakdown of her pros and cons:

Advantages:

Exceptional scaling with Elemental Burst
Ability to self-heal
Effective against both single targets and groups
Scales with HP, making her accessible for newer gamers

Disadvantages:

Stamina management can be tricky at C0
Optimal damage requires maintaining low HP
Relying on Charged Attack canceling is crucial for maximal damage output

In summary, Hu Tao is a formidable DPS character capable of dealing with high-health foes rapidly, especially when paired with Hydro characters like Xingqiu or Yelan. If you are prepared to master her Charged Attack mechanics (or if you obtain her C1 constellation that eases stamina consumption for Charged Attacks), she could be a worthwhile investment.

Nahida: Advantages and Disadvantages

Nahida is a top-tier support unit (Image via HoYoverse)

As a 5-Star Dendro character and the Dendro Archon, Nahida wields a Catalyst and excels as a support character. She is integral to numerous Dendro reaction team compositions. Let’s look at her pros and cons:

Advantages:

Outstanding Dendro application
Highly adaptable, fitting into a variety of team setups
Can link multiple foes, enabling simultaneous damage
Passive skill is beneficial for collecting materials in the overworld
Can achieve 100% uptime on her Elemental Burst with effective play

Disadvantages:

Less effective for overworld exploration due to a smaller character model
Requires high Elemental Mastery for optimal performance, which may take time to build up

Overall, Nahida is an outstanding Dendro support option. Not only can she deal a respectable amount of Dendro damage, but she also enhances her teammates’ capabilities with her Elemental Burst. At C0, she remains a strong character and is friendly for free-to-play players in terms of team builds and weapon choices.

If you’re in need of a reliable Dendro support, consider selecting Nahida.

Conclusion: The superior character choice in Genshin Impact 5.1 is Nahida

Nahida is the better pull in 5.1 (Image via HoYoverse)

While both Hu Tao and Nahida have their respective strengths and weaknesses, Nahida ultimately stands out as the more valuable character in terms of utility and pull potential. Hu Tao may excel in delivering explosive initial damage, a feat that Nahida cannot match. However, Nahida boasts superior Dendro application, the ability to connect multiple enemies, and overall benefits for the entire party.

With Dendro currently being a dominant element in Genshin Impact, Nahida is among the top Dendro characters available. If your Primogem stock is limited and you’re torn between the two, prioritize pulling for Nahida, as Hu Tao will likely appear in later banners.

Source