‘Impact of Immigration on American Children’s Education’: JD Vance Critiques Immigrant Students

Recently, Vance has placed blame on immigrant children for the decline in American educational standards.

During a rally in Peoria, Arizona, a journalist questioned Vance about his plans if Trump withdraws the temporary protected status for migrants residing in Ohio. Vance took the opportunity to criticize Harris for allegedly “granting amnesty” to those in the country without documentation. He proceeded to state that within Arizona’s educational institutions, there are “thousands” of children who “don’t even speak English.”

Vance queried, “How does this impact the education of American students when teachers are not focusing on them but rather on students lacking legal status?” He made it clear that he harbors “nothing against” these children while simultaneously claiming that current immigration policies are detrimental to American education.

Messaging that targets the children

Vance appears to be inconsistent in his assertions. Supporters of his rhetoric might link the deterioration of American education to migrant children. It seems he suggests that migrants are the issue, rather than the significant funding deficiencies in Arizona’s K-12 education system. The underfunding of public schools is a pressing issue faced by Arizona residents. By attributing the problem to immigrant children, attention is shifted away from critical discussions about the budget cuts affecting Arizona’s schools. In essence, casting immigrants as the culprit is a superficial and harmful tactic.

Moreover, non-English speaking migrant children are educated in separate classrooms. Therefore, there is no issue of divided attention among teachers, contrary to Vance’s claims.

This negative portrayal of immigrants aligns with a recurring strategy employed by both Trump and Vance during their campaigns. Former President Trump has accused the Biden administration of permitting criminals to enter the United States. Similar to Vance, Trump frequently points to immigrants as the source of the nation’s issues. Vance has also spread false narratives concerning Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio. These inaccuracies have been intentional and, regrettably, detrimental to the residents of Springfield.

Source