Indicators That Carrie Underwood Will Endure as an American Idol Judge (Should Former Contestants Become Judges?)

Carrie Underwood is set to make her debut as a judge on American Idol Season 23, commencing on March 9, 2025. This exciting move suggests that Underwood could become a long-term fixture on the judging panel. She steps into the role previously held by Katy Perry, joining the iconic Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, who has departed after seven successful seasons to refocus on his music career. Perry, Richie, and Bryan formed the original judging lineup when ABC revitalized the show in 2018, following its cancellation by FOX in 2016.

As one of the most acclaimed winners in the history of American Idol, Carrie Underwood made her mark in Season 4 of 2005. Since her victory, she has achieved remarkable success, selling 85 million records globally and producing 28 number one hits. With nine studio albums to her name, Underwood’s accolades include eight Grammy Awards, 17 American Music Awards, 12 Billboard Awards, 16 ACM Awards, nine CMA Awards, 25 CMT Music Awards, and ten People’s Choice Awards. Additionally, she has undertaken seven headlining tours and has a Las Vegas Residency named “Reflection,”which will extend into 2025. Now, with her new role as an American Idol judge, she adds another significant achievement to her illustrious career.

Carrie Underwood: The Ideal Choice for American Idol Judge

An Alum with Unique Insight into Contestant Perspectives

Carrie Underwood’s transition from a contestant to a judge, nearly two decades after her win, provides her with a distinct and invaluable perspective. She intimately understands the challenges faced by contestants, which will be beneficial as she offers constructive feedback. Having been a contestant during the tenure of the notoriously tough judge Simon Cowell, Carrie not only won his respect but also became one of the most commercially successful alumni, with Cowell predicting her future success in the music industry.

Her firsthand experience as a former contestant turned music icon positions Carrie to be an exceptional judge. She possesses the insight necessary to assist contestants in selecting the right songs and developing their artistic personas. Given her extensive background and success, there’s every reason to believe Carrie will embrace her role as a judge for the long term.

Carrie Underwood’s Deep Affection for American Idol

Carrie Continuously Honors the Show that Launched Her Career

Since winning American Idol nearly twenty years ago, Carrie Underwood has consistently acknowledged the show as a catalyst for her successful music career. Her love for the program shines through in her multiple performances and mentorship roles, including her notable guidance of the Top 5 contestants during Season 20, which allowed her to connect on a profound level. As she shared her journey and what the show represented for her, Carrie demonstrated the heartfelt connections that American Idol fosters.

During her encounter with eventual winner Noah Thompson, Carrie expressed a shared experience with him, reflecting on their roots in “tiny towns.”In a touching moment, she candidly shared her emotional connection to American Idol, stating that it was designed for aspiring artists like her and Noah, revealing the transformative power of the platform. She emphasized that her decision to audition fundamentally changed the course of her life, marveling at the life-changing opportunities afforded to contestants.

For Carrie, American Idol transcends being merely a job or a promotional opportunity; it is woven into the very fabric of her history and identity. Her profound love and respect for American Idol suggest that she will likely remain committed to her judging role for as long as possible, honoring the foundation that helped her rise to stardom.

As Carrie Underwood steps into her new role, it marks a delightful transformation from contestant to judge. Her selection to fill Katy Perry’s seat is not just fitting but invigorating, celebrating the continuity of the show’s legacy. Many fans are optimistic that Season 23 of American Idol, with Carrie as a judge, will be the most exciting yet.

American Idol Season 23 is set to premiere on Sunday, March 9, 2025, on ABC.

Sources: American Idol/Instagram, American Idol/Instagram

Source & Images