James Gunn Endorses New DCU Batman Casting Choice That Proves This Actor Would Be the Ideal Dark Knight

Under the dynamic leadership of James Gunn and Peter Safran, the DC Universe (DCU) is embarking on an ambitious overhaul. This new phase, titled Chapter One: Gods and Monsters, promises interconnected films and television series that aim to redefine beloved characters and story arcs. Among the most eagerly anticipated developments is the casting of the new Batman—a pivotal choice for the franchise.

In Gunn’s vision for the DCU, the emphasis is placed on character depth and engaging storytelling. Given Batman’s integral role as a darker, more complex superhero within the DCU, selecting the right actor is crucial for the franchise’s future. It’s expected that Batman will make his entrance in the upcoming film The Brave and the Bold.

James Gunn Backs Jonathan Bailey as a Potential Batman

Jonathan Bailey as Anthony Bridgerton in Bridgerton Season 2, Episode 5, 'An Unthinkable Fate'

Speculation around Jonathan Bailey as a strong candidate for the next Batman began circulating wildly, largely due to a viral social media post on Reddit. User Robemilak championed Bailey for the role, expressing surprise that he hadn’t been considered previously. The post resonated with many fans, stirring excitement and discussion across the community. The buzz intensified when James Gunn liked the post, hinting at his potential interest in Bailey.

Although Gunn refrained from confirming Bailey as Batman, his social media interactions suggested a willingness to entertain the idea. He has previously articulated his casting philosophy, prioritizing an actor’s fit for the role over their star status, leading to further speculation about Bailey’s candidacy.

Jonathan Bailey, famous for his role as Anthony Bridgerton in Netflix’s Bridgerton, is not only an accomplished actor but also a rising star with a commendable background, including an Olivier Award. His involvement in the Batman discussions illustrates Gunn’s intention to seek actors who embody both charm and emotional gravitas.

Why Jonathan Bailey Could Be an Ideal Batman for the DC Universe

Bailey’s distinctive traits position him as a prime candidate for the role of Batman. He has proven his capability to portray multi-dimensional characters, as evidenced by his compelling performance as the intense Anthony Bridgerton. This complexity aligns perfectly with Batman’s character—a vigilante grappling with personal trauma while upholding a strong moral code.

Bailey’s physicality enhances his potential portrayal as a convincing Batman. His lean yet muscular build and ability to exude grace suggest he could bring a more acrobatic interpretation of the character, reminiscent of earlier comic book representations. With appropriate training, he could transform into an imposing physical embodiment of both the detective and warrior archetypes that define Batman.

Moreover, Bailey possesses a captivating intensity that could effectively capture the essence of Batman. His piercing eyes and nuanced performance ability would enable him to explore the complexities of Bruce Wayne and the Dark Knight. His history in period dramas may also lend credibility to portraying the aristocratic aspects of Bruce’s character while infusing the brooding darkness that defines Batman.

Comparing Jonathan Bailey to Other Popular Fan Casting Choices for Batman

Jensen Ackles as Dean Winchester in Supernatural Season 5

Bailey is not alone in the spotlight—other notable actors like Jensen Ackles, Richard Madden, and Nicholas Hoult have also been vocally supported by fans for the role of Batman. Each brings their own strengths and unique characteristics to the conversation, leading to intriguing contrasts with Bailey.

For example, Jensen Ackles has lent his voice to Batman in several animated productions, generating acclaim for his performances. His established familiarity with the character and significant experience in genre television enhance his candidacy. Yet, selecting Ackles could be perceived as a conventional choice, whereas Bailey offers a refreshing, unconventional direction that might align with Gunn’s vision.

Richard Madden, who starred alongside Bailey in Bridgerton, is another fan-favorite candidate. With a notable reputation from his roles in Game of Thrones and Marvel’s Eternals, Madden enjoys greater mainstream recognition. However, his polished demeanor might resonate more with a Superman archetype than Batman’s intricate darkness, making Bailey’s edgier profile a stronger fit for the role.

Nicholas Hoult, known for his work in Mad Max: Fury Road and The Great, sparks conversation as a contender. While Hoult’s experience with darker roles seems suitable, his softer appearance might challenge his ability to capture Batman’s commanding essence. Bailey’s sharper features could naturally convey a sense of intensity and intrigue typically associated with the Dark Knight.

Ultimately, while Bailey’s relative inexperience in major blockbuster roles might raise questions about his marketability, it could also present an opportunity for fresh narratives and bold choices. Gunn’s focus on character-driven storytelling indicates that how well an actor embodies their character may outweigh their prior fame.

Other Potential Roles for Jonathan Bailey in the DC Universe

Jonathan Bailey as Fiyero in Wicked's Dancing Through Life sequence

Should Jonathan Bailey not emerge as the caped crusader, a myriad of other roles within the DCU might suit him well. His versatility could lend itself effectively to both heroic and villainous characters, with one compelling option being Dick Grayson/Nightwing.

In the role of Nightwing, a character deeply tied to Batman as his former sidekick and now a leader of the Titans, Bailey could showcase his charm, athleticism, and emotional depth. His dramatic background might allow him to explore the complexities of Grayson’s relationship with Bruce Wayne while excelling at Nightwing’s acrobatic fighting style.

Another intriguing possibility is Green Arrow. The character of Oliver Queen merges cocky humor with a gritty vigilante persona, aligning perfectly with Bailey’s ability to navigate layered character portrayals. This role would offer a unique blend of levity and seriousness, making Green Arrow a standout figure in Gunn’s envisioned DC Universe.

On the darker side, Bailey’s talents could shine as Hush, the bitter rival of Batman with a history shared with Bruce Wayne. This role would allow him to embody a psychologically complex antagonist, filled with ambition and vendetta. Regardless of the character he ultimately embodies, Jonathan Bailey’s potential within the DCU is extensive, showcasing his capability to infuse depth and charisma into this reimagined universe orchestrated by James Gunn.

Source: Robemilak

Source & Images