John Wayne’s 3 Oscar Nominations: Discover Who He Lost To

John Wayne, an iconic figure in American cinema, received three nominations for an Academy Award during his illustrious 50-year career, yet he claimed only a single Oscar. Renowned for his roles in approximately 80 Western films, Wayne’s image is predominantly that of a rugged, stoic cowboy. This perception, however, oversimplifies his considerable acting range. While he frequently portrayed similar characters, Wayne also showcased remarkable depth in performances, exemplified in films like the haunting The Searchers and the charming romantic drama The Quiet Man. Nonetheless, it is notable that Wayne often found little appreciation from the Academy Awards.

Despite the critical acclaim received by many of Wayne’s collaborations with director John Ford, none of these films contributed to his Oscar nominations. Interestingly, Wayne also presented several awards to fellow actors at the Academy Awards, one of which was to Gary Cooper for High Noon. This act is particularly ironic, as Wayne famously loathed High Noon for its moral implications. Tragically, the Academy Awards marked the last public appearance of Wayne, who passed away just two months after presenting the Best Director award to Michael Cimino for The Deer Hunter at the 51st Academy Awards.

3 John Wayne’s First Oscar Nomination: Sands of Iwo Jima – Best Actor

Lost to Broderick Crawford in All the King’s Men

The Academy first took notice of Wayne’s talent with his 1949 performance in the World War II drama Sands of Iwo Jima. Although he felt embarrassed for not serving in the military like many of his contemporaries, Wayne sought to demonstrate his patriotic spirit through films such as The Fighting Seabees and Sands of Iwo Jima. In this movie, he plays the hardened Sergeant Stryker, who adopts a tough attitude towards his troops to prepare them for the grim realities of battle.

While Sands of Iwo Jima garnered an Oscar nomination, it lacked the character depth found in Wayne’s later work like The Searchers. Ultimately, he lost the Academy Award to Broderick Crawford for his role in the political drama All the King’s Men, a film that Wayne himself had declined to participate in, deeming it “unpatriotic.”Losing to a film he had criticized surely added to his disappointment.

2 John Wayne’s Second Nomination: The Alamo – Best Motion Picture

Lost out to The Apartment

The Alamo represented a significant personal investment for Wayne, taking over a decade to develop. Much like Kevin Costner with Horizon, Wayne invested more than $1 million of his own money into this historical epic, additionally stepping into the roles of director and producer. Despite receiving mixed reviews, the film performed well at the box office, earning seven Oscar nominations, including Best Motion Picture.

However, it only secured one win for Best Sound, awarded to Gordon E. Sawyer and Fred Hynes. The Best Motion Picture award ultimately went to Billy Wilder’s classic, The Apartment. While The Alamo had merits, it suffered from issues of pacing and focus, making The Apartment a deserving winner. Moreover, aggressive campaigning from co-stars like Chill Wills for individual awards may have diluted the film’s chances, as some viewed such tactics as overly brash. Wayne himself expressed disapproval of this approach.

1 John Wayne’s Third Nomination: True Grit – Best Actor

John Wayne won his sole Oscar for playing Rooster Cogburn

Wayne’s moment of triumph at the Oscars finally arrived in 1970 when he won the Best Actor award for his role in True Grit. Portraying Rooster Cogburn, a rough-around-the-edges U.S. Marshal, Wayne brought both vigor and vulnerability to the role of the character aiding a young girl in her quest for vengeance after her father’s murder. His performance was celebrated for its richness, marking it as one of his most cherished roles, despite Wayne later expressing that True Grit was not among his top Westerns.

Wayne found enough satisfaction in the role to reprise it in 1975’s Rooster Cogburn, which would be one of his final films. Though his win may be viewed as a culmination of his career rather than a testament to this particular performance’s subtlety, Wayne undeniably earned his Oscar for his memorable portrayal of Rooster Cogburn.

References:
Hollywood’s Golden Age,
Vanity Fair,
Playboy/The Wrap

Source & Images