Julian Rush Connected to Fight Club Twist Through the Penguin Theory

Key Insights About HBO’s The Penguin

The series delves into Oswald Cobb’s transformation from a lackey to a formidable villain in Gotham.
A fan theory proposes that Julian Rush may be a figment of imagination, reminiscent of Fight Club’s significant twist.
The status of Julian’s reality remains ambiguous as fans eagerly anticipate the resolution of a cliffhanger featuring Oz, Sofia, and Vic.

HBO’s The Penguin stands out as one of the most compelling shows currently airing, drawing in a vast audience eager to unravel its intricate plotlines with each hour-long episode. The series takes a deep dive into the complexities of DC’s multifaceted characters, particularly focusing on Julian Rush, whose existence has become a topic of heated discussion among fans. Some theorists speculate that Julian may not be a real character but rather a manifestation similar to the iconic plot twist seen in Fight Club.

This spin-off, rooted in Matt Reeves’ cinematic universe of The Batman, chronicles the ascent of Oswald Cobb within Gotham’s shadowy criminal circles. Starting as a subordinate to Carmine Falcone, Oz’s saga elaborates on his evolution into the notorious villain recognized across the DC universe. With the aid of Rhenzy Feliz’s Victor Aguilar, Oz skillfully maneuvers through Falcone’s operations, particularly those involving Sofia Falcone, portrayed by Cristin Milioti, who is now on a vengeance quest following the murder of her brother. Amidst this tangled web, Julian Rush, the enigmatic Arkham therapist, poses many intriguing questions about his true nature and role in the narrative.

Intriguing Theories Surrounding Julian Rush

A captivating theory surfaced on Reddit suggesting that Julian Rush might be nothing more than a hallucination stemming from Sofia Falcone’s presumed dissociative disorder. This proposition draws a parallel to the shocking twist in Fight Club, where the characters Tyler Durden (played by Brad Pitt) and an unnamed protagonist are revealed to be different facets of the same person. The theory posits that Sofia may have killed the actual Julian in Arkham and has since been conversing with an imagined version of him during their therapy sessions. Critics of the theory point out that a bodyguard facilitates Julian’s entry in a pivotal episode, leading some to speculate about the authenticity of that encounter.

We need to talk about Julian by u/deLocked333 in ThePenguin

While the hallucination theory presents a fascinating angle, supporters argue against it, noting that Julian has played a significant role in rescuing Sofia, calling into question the feasibility of his character being purely imaginary. This particular series does have a knack for layering its narrative with subtle hints and unexpected developments, keeping audiences guessing. Despite the improbability of Julian’s nonexistence, the theory opens a dialogue about his identity, potentially linking him to the infamous psychiatrist and Batman adversary, Hugo Strange.

Looking ahead, fans are on the edge of their seats, anticipating whether Sofia will eliminate two pivotal characters in the upcoming seventh episode of The Penguin. With Sofia closing in on Oz’s whereabouts in a dilapidated Crown Point location, tension escalates as she confronts Oz’s mother and Vic, who are blissfully unaware of the looming threat. The episode concludes on a suspenseful cliffhanger, leaving viewers eager to see if Sofia will strike before Oz returns.

Source: Reddit

Source & Images