Marvel’s Captain America vs Hitler Made History, Yet DC’s Return of the Villainous Man Deserves Recognition

Note: This article contains references to self-harm and suicide.

Marvel Comics immortalized Captain America as a cultural icon when he famously dealt a blow to Adolf Hitler, firmly placing both figures in the realm of superhero lore and World War II history. The debut of Captain America in Captain America Comics #1, created by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, became legendary for depicting the superhero giving the tyrant a punch right in the face, symbolizing the fight against oppression and evil.

Yet, Captain America’s legacy of confronting evil didn’t end there. Decades later, DC Comics chose to reintroduce Hitler himself in a surprising twist. In Adventures of the Outsiders #33, penned by Mike W. Barr and illustrated by Alan Davis, Hitler resurfaces as a clone, engineered by villain Baron Bedlam who seeks to resurrect the ideologies of a Fourth Reich.

Comic panel depicting Bedlam making a clone of Adolf Hitler

As the plot unfolds, DC Comics promoted the next issue with a promise that it would go beyond the typical narrative associated with the Fourth Reich. In a refreshing narrative twist, the storyline revolves around themes of redemption and the possibility of transformation for even the most villainous figures, a core principle entwined with superhero storytelling.

How Did DC Comics Reintroduce Adolf Hitler After Captain America’s Iconic Punch?

The Cloning of Adolf Hitler by an Adversary of the Outsiders

The narrative through Adventures of the Outsiders unfolds as a gripping saga where the titular heroes, including Black Lightning, confront Baron Bedlam, a Nazi collaborator with plans for world domination. Bedlam’s plot involved not only the recreation of Hitler but also an intention to exploit the clone’s fingerprints to unlock an ancient secret chamber housing a powerful Proton Cloud Generator.

However, the reanimated Hitler proves to be more than a mere puppet of evil; he is a blank slate, devoid of any recollection of his horrifying past. To hasten the clone’s recollection, Bedlam places him under the supervision of a Jewish maid, believing this will serve as a pivotal moment for the clone upon regaining his memories. In a shocking turn of events in Adventures of the Outsiders #35, the maid saves him from choking, igniting a spark of humanity within the clone.

Through the process of watching Holocaust footage and noticing the Star of David around the maid’s neck, Hitler’s memories resurface. Stricken with horror and guilt, the clone ultimately takes his own life, illustrating the narrative’s stark message about accountability and the haunting weight of one’s actions.

DC Comics Conveys a Powerful Message Through Hitler’s Narrative

The Concept of Redemption Remains Ever-Present

In the closing sequences of the storyline, the Outsiders, after a climactic confrontation, find the lifeless body of Hitler’s clone. Amidst their triumph, Black Lightning encapsulates the overarching theme with a powerful reflection:

It looks like both Baron Bedlam and one of the most evil men in history each got a second chance. Bedlam made the worst of his, but the other… well, if even he could fight his evil nature – even at the cost of his own life – I’d say there’s hope for the rest of us as well.

This approach of employing Hitler as a character within a redemptive framework is contentious yet thought-provoking. It offers a layered message that transcends the historical context, focusing instead on the notion that redemption is attainable for everyone, regardless of their past misdeeds. A profound takeaway from the DC Comics narrative suggests that transformation and the potential for change reside within every individual, even someone as notorious as Adolf Hitler, without necessitating the symbolic intervention of a patriotic punch from Captain America.

Adventures of the Outsiders #33 is currently available from DC Comics.

Source & Images