Moana 2 Presents Major Challenges That Frozen 3 Must Address

Disclaimer: Contains SPOILERS for Moana 2!

Disney’s Moana 2 has made waves as a highly successful sequel, yet it underscores a significant challenge that Frozen 3 will need to tackle. The trend of Walt Disney Animation Studios releasing sequels to popular animated films is relatively recent. Historically, sequels, with some exceptions like The Rescuers Down Under, were produced by smaller studios until 2018. The successful outings of Ralph Breaks the Internet, Frozen 2, and now Moana 2 showcase a shift in strategy that is resonating with audiences. As more sequels to the Frozen franchise are in the pipeline, lessons from Moana’s second installment could provide valuable insights for Disney.

Finally delivering the much-anticipated follow-up in 2024, Moana 2 ventures deeper into an all-encompassing narrative featuring Moana and Maui. This sequel successfully integrates beloved characters from the original while introducing new faces, thus creating a refreshing dynamic without losing sight of what made the first film memorable. Although it hasn’t captured the same critical acclaim as its predecessor, Moana 2 has triumphed at the box office—something Disney hopes to replicate with Frozen 3.

Embracing an Epic Direction in Moana 2

A Thrilling Expansion Beyond the Original

Moana 2 marks a significant enhancement in its epic storytelling compared to its predecessor. The sequel’s plot hinges on a divine curse affecting the entire ocean, prompting Moana to rise as a leader in order to combat this crisis. As she assembles an expanded crew from her island, the film features a larger ensemble cast, amplifying its scope. It also showcases an array of colossal creatures, deities, and breathtaking new locations, reflecting its grander narrative ambitions.

Interestingly, the conclusion of Moana 2 is left open, hinting at future adventures within the Moana universe. By introducing new wayfinding cultures in a mid-credits scene featuring the antagonist Talo, the film sets the stage for further developments, potentially leading into a larger overarching saga, contrasting with the self-contained story of the first Moana.

Frozen 2’s Grand Attempt: A Missed Opportunity?

Reception Struggles Compared to Frozen

Interestingly, Moana 2 is not the first Disney sequel to aim for a more ambitious narrative. Frozen 2 attempted to elevate its story’s scale as well. It delves into a multigenerational narrative revealing Arendelle’s history, Elsa’s powers’ origins, and introducing the Northuldra, an entirely new tribe. The sequel’s plot leans heavily on the conflict between these two realms, almost rendering it a war epic.

Film	Rotten Tomatoes Score
Frozen	89%
Ocean	95%
Frozen 2	77%
Ocean 2	61%

Despite its ambitious approach, Frozen 2 faced criticism from fans who felt it did not achieve the same magic as the first film. Many viewers felt overwhelmed by the extensive lore and exposition, which detracted from the straightforward charm of the original. The deeper focus on Elsa’s backstory also left secondary characters, such as Anna and Kristoff, sidelined. Critics noted that an overdependence on flashbacks stole focus from the primary narrative. Overall, while Frozen 2 boasts strong qualities, it struggled to seamlessly integrate its complexity.

Envisioning a Larger Scope for Frozen 3 & 4

Potential for a Two-Part Epic

As both Frozen 3 and Frozen 4 are concurrently in development, there is much speculation regarding their narrative structure. The possibility of a two-part story could allow the sequels to explore a more expansive and intricate plot—a venture that Moana 2 might not fully encompass.

Source & Images