Moana 2: Reasons Lin-Manuel Miranda Did Not Return as Songwriter for Disney’s Sequel

Lin-Manuel Miranda, renowned for his work on the original Moana, has clarified why he did not contribute songs for the highly anticipated sequel, Moana 2. While the first Moana, released in 2016, was a notable success at the box office, it gained a larger following after its streaming debut on Disney+, consistently ranking as one of the platform’s most-watched films.

In a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Miranda explained that his absence was not due to a choice between projects like Mufasa: The Lion King. Instead, the transformation of the sequel from a planned TV series to a theatrical release meant that a team of songwriters was already appointed, and they began their work earlier in the creative process. Here’s what he had to say:

Implications of Miranda’s Absence for Moana 2

Reception of the Disney Sequel

Miranda, celebrated for his musical achievements in Hamilton, is often considered one of today’s leading songwriters. His original song, “How Far I’ll Go,”not only captivated audiences but also garnered an Academy Award nomination. The memorable soundtrack from the first film significantly contributed to its sustained popularity on Disney+. Unfortunately, the absence of Miranda in Moana 2 has sparked criticism regarding the quality of its musical compositions.

As illustrated in the table below, critical responses for Moana 2 have fallen short compared to its predecessor. While multiple factors contribute to this disparity, many agree that the sequel’s songs do not reach the heights of the original. However, it appears that audience reactions have been more forgiving, as the film has already amassed over $601 million globally and continues to attract viewers. The audience score reflects a generally positive reception, indicating that many are still finding enjoyment in the film.

Moana Franchise Rotten Tomatoes Scores
Title	Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score	Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Ocean	95%	89%
Ocean 2	61%	87%

Our Perspective on Miranda’s Non-Participation in Moana 2

Potential for Miranda’s Future Involvement

The challenges faced by Moana 2 can be traced back to its initial concept as a television series. This transition has left remnants of TV structure within the film, which may partially explain the criticism regarding its music. Had the sequel been envisioned strictly as a cinematic release from the outset, it’s conceivable that Miranda could have been involved, possibly alleviating some of the critiques regarding the musical score.

Looking ahead, Moana 2 is poised to become a blockbuster of 2024, with the potential for a third installment to be greenlit, along with an upcoming live-action adaptation of Moana. Should a third animated film materialize, it could pave the way for Miranda’s return to the franchise. Nevertheless, those eager to hear more of his music can catch Mufasa: The Lion King, set for release later this month.

Source: THR

Source & Images