Modern Star Trek Acknowledges Deep Space Nine’s Status as the Franchise’s Outcast After 32 Years

Throughout its seven-season journey, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine has carved out a unique identity within the larger Star Trek franchise. In contrast to its siblings, which often interconnect through crossovers and shared story arcs, Deep Space Nine largely operates in its own narrative universe. This distinct separation is characterized by its deep exploration of mature themes, intricate political dynamics, and overarching story arcs that diverge from the episodic adventures typical of series like Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Voyager.

Recognized as something of an outsider, Deep Space Nine has nevertheless garnered a dedicated fanbase, celebrated for delivering some of the franchise’s most compelling episodes. The darker explorations and complex character developments that define the series have made it both a beloved installment and a deviation from the greater Star Trek narrative tapestry.

The Outlier Status of Deep Space Nine

A Different Beginning: Crossovers That Amplified Its Isolation

Upon its premiere, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine found itself in the considerable shadow of prior Star Trek series. The early episodes echoed the style of Star Trek: The Next Generation, reminiscent of Star Trek: The Original Series. However, as the series progressed into its second season, it began to emphasize key themes such as religion and politics, culminating in the franchise’s first cliffhanger finale by season three.

As Deep Space Nine evolved, it increasingly delved into the complex conflict with the Dominion and the political machinations surrounding it, distancing itself from the optimistic ideals often depicted in other Star Trek narratives. This shift challenged Gene Roddenberry’s original vision, leading to conflicts among crew members that were uncharacteristic of the franchise as a whole. Notably, Commander Benjamin Sisko (played by Avery Brooks) found himself at odds with Captain Jean-Luc Picard (portrayed by Patrick Stewart), symbolizing a newly established rivalry between Deep Space Nine and The Next Generation.

The infrequent crossovers that did occur only underscored Deep Space Nine’s position as an outsider. For instance, when Jonathan Frakes made a guest appearance, he portrayed Thomas Riker, a character with no ties to his well-known role as Commander Will Riker. Moreover, when Lieutenant Commander Worf (Michael Dorn) joined the cast, he largely left his The Next Generation backstory behind, minimizing the connections to prior narratives. Even Chief Miles O’Brien (Colm Meaney) seldom referenced his time on the USS Enterprise-D. Ultimately, these moments served more to highlight DS9’s distinct status rather than integrate it into the broader franchise.

A Modern Perspective on Deep Space Nine’s Legacy

The Limited Future of Crossovers

Even three decades since its debut, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine continues to occupy a unique space within the Star Trek franchise. While other series from the 1990s frequently get referenced and revisited, DS9 has mostly been relegated to occasional Easter eggs. Newer shows like Star Trek: Strange New Worlds and Star Trek: Discovery are interconnected and frequently draw on characters and storylines from each other, while Star Trek: Picard continues the narrative established in TNG, and Star Trek: Prodigy recognizes elements from Voyager.

Currently, the main series offering notable crossovers with Deep Space Nine is Star Trek: Lower Decks, which features several episodes showcasing familiar DS9 characters and even canonizes previously alluded-to relationships. For instance, Ensign Mariner (Tawny Newsome) begins her journey on Deep Space Nine, and connections among characters like Lieutenant Shaxs (Fred Tatasciore) and Colonel Kira Nerys (Nana Visitor) are explored. However, with the finale of Star Trek: Lower Decks, expectations for further crossovers between these two series are greatly diminished.

Challenges in Reviving Deep Space Nine

The Impact of Avery Brooks’ Retirement

The last portrayal of Captain Sisko by Avery Brooks came in the 2006 video game Star Trek: Legacy. At the conclusion of Deep Space Nine, Sisko’s ascension to join the Prophets in the Celestial Temple established him as an immortal, nonlinear being, complicating the potential for future crossover narratives within the Starfleet context. Furthermore, Avery Brooks has stepped back from acting since 2001, focusing primarily on documentary projects, raising skepticism about his return to the role. Therefore, while side characters from Deep Space Nine may still appear in new stories, it is unlikely that we will witness the direct continuation of the beloved series.

Source & Images