National Treasure 3: A Much-Needed Sequel Following Disney’s Streaming Strategy Missteps

National Treasure 3 is becoming increasingly essential following the cancellation of National Treasure: Edge of History. The franchise’s latest cinematic offering, which debuted in 2007, left fans yearning for more by hinting at the enigmatic contents of page 47 in the U.S. presidents’ book of secrets. Unfortunately, despite setting the stage for a sequel, the franchise has remained inactive for over 15 years. The spinoff series, National Treasure: Edge of History, surfaced on Disney+ in 2022, but failed to recapture the magic of its predecessors.

This series did attempt to draw connections to the original films, welcoming back some beloved cast members like Justin Bartha as Riley Poole and Harvey Keitel as Agent Peter Sadusky. However, its lackluster reception led to its cancellation after just one season. As fans reflect on the cliffhanger surrounding page 47—a mysterious plot point that has yet to be resolved—many are left wondering if we will ever see Nicolas Cage reprise his role as Benjamin Franklin Gates.

Disney Should Prioritize National Treasure 3 Over Streaming Shows

A Third Movie Would Have Benefited the Franchise More

Nicolas Cage as Ben Gates looking concerned in National Treasure 2

Considering Cage’s continued popularity alongside the nostalgia linked to the original films, it’s clear that National Treasure 3 should have been prioritized by Disney. The prospect of reuniting Cage, Bartha, and Diane Kruger—as Dr. Abigail Chase—for an exciting new adventure would undoubtedly generate significant buzz. Historically, the franchise’s theatrical releases performed well at the box office, and a third installment would likely follow suit, satisfying audiences eager to solve the enigma of page 47.

Movie	Budget	Global Box Office Earnings
National Treasure (2004)	$100 million	$347.5 million
National Treasure: Book of Secrets (2007)	$130 million	$459.2 million

Given the franchises’ successes with theatrical releases, transitioning to a streaming series was a misstep for Disney. The trend to convert numerous intellectual properties into Disney+ series—accelerated by the uncertainty brought about by the Covid-19 pandemic—did not resonate with fans of National Treasure, which inherently works better as a movie franchise.

Exploring Why National Treasure: Edge of History Fell Short

Absence of Key Elements from the Original Films

National Treasure: Edge of History lacked the fun, adventurous spirit that characterized the original films. Critics lamented the absence of genuine treasure hunting and complex puzzles, which made the original movies so engaging. This shortcoming became increasingly evident over the series’ ten episodes, as the pacing failed to match the swift, exciting rhythm of its predecessors.

The series received a disappointing 38% critical score and a 49% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating widespread dissatisfaction. Edge of History also grappled with integrating familiar and new elements, leaning too heavily on the original films while simultaneously failing to develop its own narrative. This imbalance made Cage’s absence painfully apparent, detracting from the intended storytelling.

One Positive Outcome from Edge of History for National Treasure 3

Potential for Edge of History Characters in the New Film

Characters discussing in National Treasure: Edge of History

Despite its flaws, the characters introduced in Edge of History could enhance the narrative of National Treasure 3. Screenwriter Ted Elliot has indicated that he considers the series to be part of the canon, which includes substantial references, such as confirming Agent Sadusky’s death. Characters from the spinoff have connections to Riley, who attended Sadusky’s wake and played a role in cracking critical clues.

The core cast for National Treasure 3 should include Ben, Riley, and Abigail, but incorporating characters from Edge of History could provide valuable supporting roles and explore unresolved storylines. This integration would help bridge the gap between the films and the series and create a more coherent franchise experience, blending the strengths of both formats.

Current Developments Regarding National Treasure 3

Ongoing Conversations About the Trilogy

The enduring popularity of the National Treasure series—despite the underwhelming reception of Edge of History—keeps the idea of a sequel alive. Discussions regarding National Treasure 3 initially surfaced in 2008, when producer Jerry Bruckheimer announced plans for a sequel with an ongoing script. Unfortunately, this project became mired in developmental limbo, but new initiatives are currently in motion.

In 2020, it was reported that development on National Treasure 3 has resumed, with Bruckheimer still on board and Chris Bremner tasked with screenwriting. However, delays occurred when attention shifted toward the National Treasure TV series, ultimately culminating in Edge of History. While Bruckheimer confirmed that a script was finalized in 2022, further details have remained scarce.

As of March 2024, Nicolas Cage’s recent comments have left fans unsure about his potential return. At this point, while National Treasure 3 remains in development, there is no official word from Disney regarding its cancellation. Although progress is slow, there remains hope that a new installment could still be realized, reminiscent of the lengthy gap between the original Top Gun and its highly successful sequel.

Source & Images