Netflix’s Latest WWII Film Struggles with Tyler Perry’s Disappointing Rotten Tomatoes Record

Tyler Perry, a name synonymous with the popular Madea franchise, has often found himself at odds with critics. Starting his journey as a modest playwright, Perry’s transition into Hollywood occurred after the film adaptation of his play, Diary of a Mad Black Woman, propelled him into the limelight. Since then, he has worn multiple hats—acting, directing, writing, and producing—for a slew of films and television shows. Despite varying critical receptions, Perry’s films often resonate with audiences, illustrating a notable disconnect between critics and viewers.

Audience Ratings vs. Critical Reviews

While many of Perry’s films have struggled to achieve favorable ratings on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes, audience feedback has frequently told a different story. The table below highlights several of his films, showcasing the disparities between critical ratings and audience enjoyment:

Title	Tomatometer Score	Popcornmeter Score
Diary of a Mad Black Woman (2005)	16%	86%
Madea’s Witness Protection (2012)	19%	66%
Alex Cross (2012)	11%	47%
The Single Moms Club (2014)	19%	58%
Boo! A Madea Halloween (2016)	19%	52%
Brain on Fire (2016)	13%	67%
Boo 2! A Madea Halloween (2017)	5%	41%
Acrimony (2018)	19%	65%
A Madea Family Funeral (2019)	11%	31%
A Fall From Grace (2020)	15%	50%
Divorce in the Black (2024)	0%	73%
My Fault (2024)	18%	37%

Even amidst criticism, Perry’s work continues to connect with audiences. For instance, A Madea Family Funeral had a staggering 20% difference in ratings, while the widely panned Divorce in the Black still managed to secure a 73% audience approval rating. This resilience demonstrates that Perry has cultivated a loyal fanbase willing to support him through his creative endeavors.

The Challenges of “The Six Triple Eight”

Audience Satisfaction vs. Critical Discontent

Four women in period clothing in an office in The Six Triple Eight

After the lukewarm reception of Mea Culpa and Divorce in the Black, Perry’s latest release, The Six Triple Eight, was anticipated as a beacon of hope in 2024. The film narrates the inspiring story of an all-Black, all-female battalion in World War II that tackled a pressing postal crisis in Europe. Unfortunately, this film, too, has met with mixed reviews on Rotten Tomatoes.

Currently, The Six Triple Eight boasts a 50% Tomatometer score, marking it as a “Rotten”result. In contrast, it has achieved a more favorable 78% on the Popcornmeter, indicating audience appreciation. These figures are notably better than Perry’s previous releases in 2024, which reflect the ongoing trend of audiences responding more positively to his work than critics.

Analyzing the Divisiveness of “The Six Triple Eight”

Perry’s Proven Track Record

The current 50% rating indicates that even those critics who found fault with The Six Triple Eight acknowledged its compelling narrative. Audience members have praised its performances and storytelling, leading to the question: how significant are these reviews really? As a Netflix release, viewers have the luxury of watching without the pressures of box office performance. The reliability of Rotten Tomatoes scores may hold less weight for Perry’s dedicated fanbase.

Tyler Perry is a director who has firmly established himself in Hollywood and continues to inspire a devoted following. Given that he wrote and directed The Six Triple Eight, a polarized response was perhaps inevitable. Rather than solely relying on critics’ opinions, audiences are encouraged to view the film firsthand to gauge its effectiveness. Engaging with the film without preconceptions can lead to a richer viewing experience.

Source: Rotten Tomatoes

Source & Images