Outlander Diminishes the Significance of a Major Character Death

Outlander Season 7 has notably diverged from its source material, leaving out a pivotal element from the books which lessens the emotional weight of a character’s demise. Episode 15, titled “Written in My Own Heart’s Blood,”draws its name from Diana Gabaldon’s novel and closely parallels the book’s climax. However, a critical aspect of Brianna’s narrative has been modified, specifically regarding a letter she discovers at Lallybroch. While her decision to return to the past remains intact, the poignant insights about Frank Randall are conspicuously absent.

A Key Omission: Frank’s Letter to Brianna

In Season 7, Episode 15, Brianna seems to move past a moment of introspection with one of Frank’s books rather quickly. Shortly thereafter, she uncovers a hidden compartment in Brian Fraser’s desk, retrieving a letter she believes to be from Roger, who had placed it there during his adventures in 1739. However, this deviates from the book’s narrative, where Brianna stumbles upon a letter from her adoptive father, Frank.

Tobia Menzies as Frank in a suit in Outlander

In the novel Written in My Own Heart’s Blood—with additional insights found in Go Tell the Bees That I Am Gone—Frank’s letter holds significant revelations. It becomes evident that Frank had a deeper understanding of his daughter’s fate than anyone else, including the ominous Fraser prophecy that threatened Brianna’s safety. He cautioned her about this danger, showcasing a foresight that raises many questions about how much he truly understood regarding their entwined destinies.

Theories Surrounding Frank’s Death: More Than a Tragic Accident?

This raises an intriguing question: did Frank Randall foresee his own mortality, or did he know he was in imminent danger?

Frank’s Potential Sacrifice for Brianna

There exists a compelling theory suggesting that Frank’s tragic death was not merely an accident but a sacrifice made in an effort to protect Brianna. The notion posits that Frank had uncovered information regarding the Fraser prophecy that placed him at risk, leading him to act in a desperate bid to ensure his daughter’s safety. Diana Gabaldon herself has echoed thoughts on this theory, pondering whether Frank’s death could indeed have been intentional. Unfortunately, such profound layers are largely overlooked in the TV adaptation.

Frank Randall putting his hands to his mouth in Outlander.

The Importance of Frank’s Understanding of Brianna’s Fate

Regardless of whether Frank’s demise was an accident or a selfless act, his correspondence to Brianna embodies the knowledge he held about her narrative arc, knowledge he never fully conveyed to Claire. In fact, Frank may possess a deeper comprehension of time travel than any of the other characters, thanks in part to his intellect and keen insight into Claire’s journey. His creation and awareness of historical patterns likely stemmed from his deep desire to safeguard Brianna’s future.

The Oversight of Frank’s Story Arc in Season 7

Frank Randall often receives a questionable reputation within the series, overshadowed by Jamie’s connection to Claire. Despite the perception of him as an obstacle, Frank’s role and his profound attachment to Brianna highlight the complexity of his character, transcending the labels attributed to him. Critics argue that the show has neglected to emphasize Frank’s vital contributions to both Claire’s and Brianna’s journeys, reducing him to merely another character in the background.

In summary, Frank’s character should embody more than just a shadow in Claire’s narrative. His letter is a testament to his significant role within the story, revealing layers of understanding and sacrifice that the Outlander television series has not fully explored.

Source&Images