Over The Hedge 2: Reasons Behind the Abandoned DreamWorks Sequel Despite $300 Million Success of the First Film

Over the Hedge, a 2006 animated family film, enjoyed considerable success upon its release. However, in an era where even the most unconventional children’s films often receive sequels, the absence of an Over the Hedge 2 raises some eyebrows. This movie, inspired by the comic strip created by Michael Fry and T. Lewis, follows the story of RJ, a clever raccoon voiced by Bruce Willis. RJ finds himself deeply in debt to a bear who resembles a mafia boss, compelling him to enlist the help of a group of woodland animals in order to steal food and avoid becoming the bear’s next meal.

The film features an impressive ensemble cast, including Gary Shandling, Steve Carell, Allison Janney, Thomas Haden Church, Wanda Sykes, William Shatner, Nick Nolte, and Eugene Levy. With its zany humor and engaging storyline, Over the Hedge stands out among its animated peers, reflecting a level of craftsmanship that elevates it above the typical fare aimed at younger audiences. Garnering a 75% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and produced by the renowned DreamWorks Studio, it is perplexing why a sequel never materialized.

Why No Sequel? Financial Considerations

Competition from Other DreamWorks Productions

Despite its impressive critical reception, Over the Hedge amassed nearly $340 million at the global box office, which might seem substantial at first glance (source: BoxOfficeMojo). However, after accounting for production costs of approximately $100 million and an additional $70 million for marketing, the earnings don’t paint as rosy a picture. With studios only retaining about half of the theater revenue, the film barely broke even at around $170 million. After applying a 15% distributor fee to Paramount, DreamWorks found itself facing a loss of $25 million.

Even with $75 million in DVD sales, which nudged it back into the black, the film’s profitability was modest. Given DreamWorks Animation’s strategy of producing just a few films annually, the lucrative performance of other franchises, like Shrek 2 – which earned close to a billion dollars – made it clear which projects the studio would prioritize for sequels.

Challenges to Box Office Performance

Other Major Kids Movies Released

Verne hiding in his shell in Over the Hedge

With its talented voice cast, high-quality animation, lovable characters, and a storyline appealing to both children and adults, it’s surprising that Over the Hedge didn’t perform even better at the box office. A crucial factor contributing to its performance was the intense competition from other family-oriented films released around the same time, compelling audiences to make difficult choices.

The animated film faced considerable rivalry from kid-friendly blockbusters, such as Cars, which debuted just a month later, along with several others like Hoot, Garfield: A Tail of Two Kitties, Nacho Libre, Leroy & Stitch, Monster House, The Ant Bully, and Barnyard. Each of these films managed to perform well at the box office, further diminishing the potential earnings for Over the Hedge.

Is There Still Hope for Over The Hedge 2?

Cultural Legacy Issues

A bear, a man, and a woman in a pile staring at something in Over the Hedge

While some audiences might yearn for a sequel to Over the Hedge, it seems that these fans represent a smaller demographic. The film undeniably provides an entertaining experience with its unique heist narrative and imaginative sequences featuring animals navigating human environments. Nevertheless, its cultural footprint remains somewhat limited. Should a sequel be released on a streaming platform, it’s likely that many viewers would require the number “2” in the title to recognize it as a continuation of the original.

Source & Images