Pokémon Needs to Address a Major Anime Flaw to Recapture the Magic of the Original Series

The contemporary Pokémon anime has established a clear identity, making it easier for fans to understand what to expect from each episode. Although the series still manages to surprise viewers with unexpected plot twists, it lacks the adventurous spirit and unpredictability that characterized the original series. This essential shift may contribute to a sense of nostalgia among long-time fans.

Nonetheless, the latest installment, Pokémon Horizons, showcases a more focused and coherent narrative than its predecessors. While this tightness enhances clarity, it often sacrifices the magical elements and intrigue that initially captivated audiences. The earliest seasons of Pokémon succeeded in embodying the franchise’s adventurous spirit, even with their quirky elements. This unique blend of oddness played a significant role in making those original episodes memorable.

The Pokémon World Was Less Known Then

The Original Series Had Little in the Way of Restrictions

Ash's Butterfree meets a pink Butterfree in Pokémon.

In the early years of the Pokémon anime, writers operated with far fewer constraints regarding content and themes. For instance, Ash Ketchum’s early propensity for physical conflict reflected a more carefree storytelling approach. This aspect gradually softened over time, leading to a more subdued portrayal of his character. Furthermore, the interactions between Ash and companions like Misty contained a level of sarcasm and wit that diminished as the series progressed. This rawness contributed to Ash’s development of innovative battle strategies, notably during his duel with Brock.

Creators enjoyed a considerable amount of freedom in exploring various concepts that did not rely heavily on the Pokémon games. Unique phenomena, such as the inclusion of massive Pokémon like the Giant Dragonite in “Mystery at the Lighthouse”and early glimpses of iconic characters like Ho-Oh, showcased the anime’s innovative storytelling. The original series also incorporated real-world animals—a rarity that further blurred the lines of its fictional universe. Such a flexible narrative environment allowed the audience to feel a sense of discovery alongside Ash, immersing them in the Pokémon world as if it were freshly unfolding.

The Orange Islands Exemplify The Original’s Creative Freedom

The Anime-exclusive Region Allowed Great Freedom

The Orange Islands saga stands as a testament to the creative latitude possessed by the original series’ writers. Designed as a filler arc during the hiatus before Pokémon Gold and Silver, this narrative allowed for imaginative exploration that diverged from established norms. It introduced a vibrant new region featuring exclusive Pokémon like the iconic Valencia Island Butterfree and unique challenges that redefined traditional gym battles.

In the Orange Islands, gym challenges often featured creative elements beyond straightforward battles, integrating races or other engaging activities. This heralded a significantly dynamic approach that would later influence game design, as seen in Alola’s trials. While the series has since shifted to predominantly revisit familiar territories, thereby limiting the potential for new original content, the implications of the Orange Islands arc remain a crucial part of Pokémon’s storytelling legacy.

Pokémon Horizons Should Be Given Its Freedom, Too

Horizons Would Benefit from the Same Freedom as the Original Series

Roy and Liko look at each other before their battle.

While Pokémon Horizons has made commendable strides in narrative development, it could further benefit from the same creative liberties that the original series enjoyed. The introduction of whimsical elements, reminiscent of those early episodes like Giant Pokémon, has already enriched the storyline. However, the narrative could expand further by taking risks and stepping outside the established canon.

Challenging canon might seem radical, but the evolving lore of Pokémon has at times begun to hinder creative storytelling possibilities. For Horizons to recapture the adventurous spirit synonymous with the original series, it may need to break away from rigorous adherence to video game logic. Allowing characters like Roy and Liko to execute unconventional strategies could reinvigorate the anime’s dynamic nature and surprise long-time fans.

By embracing the creative freedom it deserves, Pokémon Horizons has the potential to deliver a thrilling viewing experience that encapsulates the essential charm and excitement that originally defined the franchise. This approach can rekindle that sense of wonder, making the series less predictable while still honoring its beloved roots.

Source & Images