Possibility of David Ayer’s Director’s Cut of Suicide Squad Still Remains

Quick Links

Examining “Suicide Squad” ‘s Troubled Production
The Uncertain Future of the Ayer Cut
Creature Commandos and Superman: Potential Keys to the Ayer Cut

Key Takeaways

Fan demand for David Ayer’s vision of Suicide Squad persists despite challenges from Warner Bros.
The success of upcoming DCEU projects may significantly impact the future of the Ayer Cut.
Creature Commandos and Superman could play pivotal roles in determining the potential release of Ayer’s version.

The call for David Ayer’s original cut of Suicide Squad continues to resonate with fans, even after the dissolution of Zack Snyder’s era of the DC Extended Universe. Following revelations that the 2016 theatrical version was vastly different from Ayer’s intended vision, Warner Bros. has faced mounting pressure to make the director’s cut available. The unveiling of Creature Commandos has revitalized interest in Ayer’s cut, particularly because of the animated series’ connections to the broader DC lore, but there remains a consensus that the prospect of the Ayer Cut is dwindling.

Initially, the success of Snyder’s Justice League sparked hope for Ayer fans, but the strong reception of James Gunn’s The Suicide Squad and the pivot towards a new DC Universe have dimmed optimism. Yet, historical precedents suggest that a slim chance remains for the realization of Ayer’s vision, contingent upon the success of upcoming projects such as Creature Commandos and Superman.

Examining Suicide Squad‘s Troubled Production

David Ayer and Margot Robbie on set of Suicide Squad

Title	Suicide Squad
Director	David Ayer
Release Date	August 5, 2016
Box Office	$746.2 million
Rotten Tomatoes Rating	26%

Initially positioned to resonate with audiences, Suicide Squad became a casualty of executive decisions shaped by feedback from earlier DCEU films like Man of Steel and Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Following disappointing audience responses, Warner Bros. shifted to a lighter tone to emulate the success of Marvel’s Cinematic Universe, which resulted in the excision of Ayer’s darker themes and character arcs. Noteworthy alterations included modifications to the villain Incubus and the portrayal of Jared Leto’s Joker, whose adaptation received significant backlash.

Despite grossing an impressive $746 million at the box office, critical reception was overwhelmingly negative, pinpointing flaws in the narrative and character development. Ayer, reflecting on the aftermath, has consistently expressed his dissatisfaction. As he candidly explained to Variety, “I made a great movie. I made an amazing film… To have something I put so much love into get taken away and reengineered… it’s been a painful journey.”

The Uncertain Future of the Ayer Cut

The release of Zack Snyder’s Justice League demonstrated that fan advocacy could influence studio decisions, creating a momentary surge in hope for the Ayer Cut. However, campaigns featuring hashtags like #ReleaseTheAyerCut have failed to achieve the desired outcome. The success of Gunn’s The Suicide Squad and the dissolution of the Snyderverse further complicated the prospects for Ayer’s vision. Although Gunn has made favorable comments about the original vision, optimism remains muted, with Ayer himself seemingly accepting that his film may not receive its deserved recognition.

Warner Bros. may hesitate to release the Ayer Cut due to potential repercussions. The critical acclaim of Snyder’s Justice League highlighted the stark contrast between the two versions of the film, serving as a reminder of the pitfalls of executive meddling. The prospect of releasing a director’s cut from an already poorly received film raises legitimate concerns about further scrutiny of past decisions and subsequent implications for forthcoming releases in the new DC Universe.

Creature Commandos and Superman: Potential Keys to the Ayer Cut

Posters for Creature Commandos and Superman

Amidst skepticism, there lies a glimmer of hope for the future of David Ayer’s Suicide Squad. The outcomes of Creature Commandos—the inaugural title under the newly revamped DC Universe—and future projects like Superman may be instrumental in this regard. As the new DCU embarks on uncharted territory post-pandemic, finding success through both film and television could reinforce faith in the revitalized vision spearheaded by Gunn.

The potential release of Ayer’s cut would represent a significant step for Warner Bros. to distance itself from the controversies of its past and demonstrate a commitment to artistic integrity. Unlike Snyder’s Justice League, which required extensive reinvestment to complete, Ayer’s revision might merely necessitate manageable visual effects updates, making it a less daunting project for the studio. While the Ayer cut may not reach the exalted status it aims for, witnessing the director’s hard work come to fruition would bring satisfaction to many fans.

Source & Images