Ranking Lindsay Lohan’s Netflix Comeback Films from Worst to Best

Netflix has become a significant platform for Lindsay Lohan to revive her acting career. While her three films produced for the streaming service vary in quality, they illustrate Lohan’s evolving presence in the film industry. Many fans reminisce about her early movies from her childhood and young adult years, acknowledging that her popularity saw a decline in the mid-2000s. However, with the release of her Netflix original movie Falling for Christmas in 2022, Lohan began a notable comeback, subsequently featuring in two more original films that have become part of the holiday viewing scene on Netflix.

These three Netflix films—Falling for Christmas, Irish Wish, and Our Little Secret—display a range of cinematic experiences. While none of them could be labeled as groundbreaking, each film has its charm, whether through humor or heartwarming narratives perfect for the holiday season. Yet, the variance in critical reception and overall enjoyment suggests that not all of Lohan’s projects are created equal. Among them, one film stands out as the best.

3 Irish Wish

A Charming Yet Flawed Rom-Com: Irish Wish

Lindsay Lohan’s second project with Netflix, Irish Wish, certainly possesses redeeming qualities. The film’s picturesque Irish landscape enhances its appeal, offering stunning visuals throughout the narrative. As Maddie Kelly, Lohan showcases her natural charm and humor, which contributes positively to the viewing experience. The straightforward plot is simultaneously a strength, crafting a comfortable ambiance despite its predictability.

However, Irish Wish falls short compared to Lohan’s other works for several reasons. Notably, while the film attempts to establish a theme based on Ireland, it struggles with authenticity and too heavily relies on clichéd romantic comedy tropes. Besides, despite Lohan’s engaging performance, her character lacks depth and relatability, often echoing Katherine Heigl’s role in 27 Dresses without trespassing into original territory. The romantic dynamics in Irish Wish also leave much to be desired, demonstrating weak chemistry that diminishes the film’s impact.

In comparison to the festive cheer of Lohan’s Christmas-themed films, the St. Patrick’s Day approach of Irish Wish simply doesn’t evoke the same enthusiastic response. The film may tap into a niche for holiday-romances, yet it lacks the festive spirit that makes for enduring seasonal favorites. Thus, nestled amongst Lohan’s recent endeavors, Irish Wish feels less memorable.

2 Our Little Secret

Our Little Secret: A Christmas Film that Misses the Mark as a Rom-Com

Lindsay Lohan’s latest Netflix entry, Our Little Secret, showed improvement over Irish Wish, yet it did not meet the standards she previously established. The film features a notably talented cast, including Lohan and Kristin Chenoweth, both of whom breathe life into their roles, delivering moments of authentic humor throughout—particularly Avery’s comedic mishaps at church and unexpected family secrets revealed.

While it cleverly incorporates a holiday backdrop, Our Little Secret fails to balance its romantic comedy elements effectively. Rather than establishing strong romantic connections, it often glosses over character development, leading to a lack of chemistry between Lohan and her co-star Ian Harding, resulting in a romance that lacks depth and believability. With a low score of just 38% on Rotten Tomatoes, it’s evident that the film struggles to carve out a unique identity within a crowded genre.

1 Falling for Christmas

Falling for Christmas: Lohan’s Best Comeback Film

Lindsay Lohan’s inaugural Netflix venture, Falling for Christmas, stands out as her most successful film in recent years. Celebrated as her official return to cinema, it successfully delivers both a charming romantic comedy experience and evokes the warmth of the holiday season. The film embraces its Christmas theme with enthusiasm, making it a delightful option for festive viewing.

Despite its predictable narrative, Falling for Christmas provides audience comfort with its holiday spirit, cozy scenes, and a light-hearted approach that aligns with the best aspects of holiday films. Lohan’s performance is a highlight, showcasing her ability to captivate audiences with her charisma—as evident in her interactions with co-star Jake (Chord Overstreet). The movie checks all the boxes for a feel-good holiday movie, earning a respectable score of 62% on Rotten Tomatoes.

In conclusion, Lohan’s recent films demonstrate her undeniable talent and potential for future projects. As she transitions beyond Netflix’s offerings, exciting titles like Freakier Friday promise to showcase her comedic chops and expand her filmography. The future looks bright for Lindsay Lohan, and her Netflix ventures have undoubtedly played a pivotal role in her resurgence in the acting realm.

Source & Images