Reasons to Believe in the Twilight Princess HD Remake Rumors

Recent speculation suggests that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess may be poised for a second remake, and it’s difficult to argue against it being the most deserving title in the franchise. While my journey with Zelda began with the groundbreaking A Link to the Past and Ocarina of Time—both of which have left an indelible mark on my gaming experience—Twilight Princess remains my personal favorite among the series. My fondness for this game is not merely subjective; it stems from its unique blend of elements that make it ripe for a modern reimagining.

While it might seem surprising that Twilight Princess, released more recently than remakes of older titles like Ocarina of Time or Majora’s Mask, holds such a position, its accessibility remains a challenge. A revival would not only enhance player access but could also positively influence the future trajectory of the Zelda franchise if it achieves significant commercial success. Personally, I yearn for the chance to enjoy my favorite Zelda adventure on the Nintendo Switch, rather than having to rely on my Wii U for a single nostalgic outing.

Twilight Princess: The Cornerstone of the Zelda Experience

Evolution of Zelda’s 3D Gameplay

The release of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild marked a significant shift in the 3D Zelda formula, exploring an expansive world with a new approach. However, I still hold a strong appreciation for the traditional style characterized by a mix of linear dungeons and open-world elements, famously pioneered in Ocarina of Time. This hybrid structure created a compelling experience, offering both the adventure of exploration and the engaging level design typically found in more linear games. Twilight Princess exemplifies this classic formula brilliantly.

In stark contrast to prior 3D Zelda titles, Twilight Princess boasts an expansive map that enriches the player’s journey, giving Hyrule the depth of a vast kingdom. It successfully integrates a diverse array of biomes—from the arid Gerudo Desert to the icy peaks of Snowpeak—each featuring meticulously crafted dungeons that feel organic to the landscape. Take the Goron Mines on Death Mountain, for instance; it presents itself convincingly as a mining establishment rather than a generic dungeon.

Furthermore, Twilight Princess is home to some of the most entertaining minigames in the franchise. As an enthusiast of outdoor activities like white-water rafting, I find Iza’s Rapid Ride thrilling, while snowboarding against Yeto brings back nostalgic memories of 1080° Snowboarding on the N64. Despite the appeal of minigames in Breath of the Wild, they lack the depth and world-specific design seen in Twilight Princess, leaving my experience feeling more complete and immersive.

The Potential Impact of a Twilight Princess Remake

The Influence of Sales on Franchise Direction

Link and Zelda beneath the Deku Tree in Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom.

Beyond my own desire for a revitalized version of Twilight Princess, I believe that the game’s successful remake could positively influence the Zelda series overall. Since its debut, I have expressed disappointment with the evolutionary path of 3D Zelda titles. Skyward Sword remains my most significant letdown, as its linear gameplay felt restrictive. The game’s overworld, Skyloft, resembled more of a level-select interface rather than a vibrant, living landscape akin to the expansive Hyrule field in Twilight Princess.

In contrast, the freedom presented in Breath of the Wild was refreshing following my Skyward Sword experience. Yet, the sheer scale often left me feeling less inclined to revisit it compared to other Zelda titles. Should a Twilight Princess remake garner substantial sales, it could serve as a reminder to Nintendo that fans continue to cherish elements from older Zelda designs.

While the chance of receiving a game that mirrors Twilight Princess in entirety may have passed, the possibility remains for Nintendo to reintroduce classic features from earlier titles. More intricate and thematic dungeons, for instance, are a key aspect I long for in future installments. Ideally, upcoming titles could favor smaller, more thoughtfully designed locations—similar to the Zora River—over vast, but somewhat indistinct, landscapes.

Twilight Princess: A Commercial Powerhouse

A Reimagined Version Could Benefit from Previous Commercial Success

Cover art for The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess.

It’s reasonable to anticipate that a Twilight Princess re-release could thrive commercially. According to the Nintendo Wiki, Twilight Princess ranks as the third best-selling game in the franchise. A successful remake could not only rekindle interest in past elements but might also pave the way for their reintroduction in future games.

Sales figures play a crucial role in determining the direction of the Zelda series. For instance, Skyward Sword had one of the poorest initial sales for a 3D title, leading to the groundbreaking reinvention seen in Breath of the Wild. Conversely, Breath of the Wild’s commercial success has heavily influenced the development of its successor, Tears of the Kingdom. Although the original Twilight Princess remake suffered poor sales, I suspect a new edition would fare markedly better.

Challenges Faced by the Previous Twilight Princess Remake

Wii U’s Limitations Hampered the Last Remake’s Reception

Link from Twilight Princess in front of a Wii U console.

The prior remake of Twilight Princess HD was exclusive to the Wii U, which has been historically recognized as Nintendo’s lowest-selling console, as noted by Nintendo‘s own statistics. In comparison, the Nintendo Switch boasts more than ten times the sales numbers for both hardware and software. Twilight Princess HD’s release coincided with the conclusion of the Wii U’s lifecycle, limiting its initial reach and appeal.

Moreover, scarce availability of Twilight Princess HD has inflated its market value, costing players around $200 for a second-hand copy. A Switch remake would enhance accessibility, allowing a broader audience to experience this classic. Regardless of whether one agrees with my assessment of Twilight Princess as a standout entry in the series, it remains crucial for fans of The Legend of Zelda to have the opportunity to engage with and form their opinions about the game.

Sources: Nintendo Wiki, Nintendo

Source & Images