Robbie Kay’s Character in Pirates of the Caribbean: What Happened to Him?

While many fans debate the ranking of the Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides within the series, it is noteworthy that the film introduces several characters who vanish after this single adventure. The original Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy established a clear narrative. Following the conclusion of its central storyline and the exit of popular characters Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley), Disney faced the challenge of crafting a new storyline that would maintain the franchise’s appeal, particularly with the return of Johnny Depp’s Captain Jack Sparrow and Geoffrey Rush’s Hector Barbossa.

Penélope Cruz’s portrayal of Angelica was underutilized; she had the potential to spearhead a new era for the franchise alongside Jack Sparrow. However, the lukewarm response to On Stranger Tides led to a soft reboot, resulting in the abandonment of most characters introduced in the fourth film. This decision extended to the replacement romantic duo of Sam Claflin’s missionary Philip Swift and Àstrid Bergès-Frisbey’s mermaid Syrena. Interestingly, Stephen Graham’s character, Scrum, is one of the few to return, highlighting how past attempts to rejuvenate the series with new characters largely fell flat.

Robbie Kay: The Unsung “Cabin Boy”of Blackbeard’s Ship

The Ambiguous Importance of Kay’s Character

Robbie Kay is on a ship in Pirates of the Caribbean.

The initial three films in the franchise featured a consistent ensemble of supporting characters that contributed to the dynamics of Jack and Barbossa’s crews. However, many actors from those films did not return for On Stranger Tides, prompting a push to establish a new roster of crew members for upcoming installments. One of these additions is Robbie Kay, who plays a character simply referred to as “Cabin Boy.”The designation nods to historical maritime traditions where young boys were often recruited for various onboard duties.

Oddly, On Stranger Tides appears to ascribe significant importance to Kay’s role. Displayed prominently throughout the film, particularly due to his youth, it seems peculiar that his character lacks a proper name; past supporting roles typically have some unique identifiers. His last appearance shows him alongside Barbossa, further hinting at a deeper narrative connection that ultimately led nowhere.

The Mysterious Disappearance of Kay’s Character

Diverging Paths for Kay and the Franchise Post-On Stranger Tides

During the production of On Stranger Tides, Robbie Kay was still a teenager with little recognition in the entertainment industry. He later gained prominence through roles in Once Upon a Time and Heroes Reborn. His absence from Dead Men Tell No Tales remains unexplained, but one can speculate that Kay simply pursued other opportunities while the franchise moved away from his character. Given that his character joined Barbossa’s crew, it is plausible he met an untimely fate at sea or departed from the crew at some point.

Barbossa’s growth in subsequent films suggests that Kay’s character could have taken on a new role within a different ship, possibly as an officer. Ironically, Kay’s presence could have enhanced the dynamic in the fifth film, especially in interactions with younger characters such as Brenton Thwaites and Kaya Scodelario. This would have helped break away from the traditional narrative of having only two young characters fulfilling the role of star-crossed lovers. Ultimately, Robbie Kay’s potential remains a missed opportunity within the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, as his character was left underdeveloped and contradictory.

Source&Images