Se7en Features Just One On-Screen Murder, and It Wasn’t Executed By John Doe

Despite its lukewarm reception from critics upon release, Se7en has gained significant acclaim over the years, transforming into a sleeper hit and securing its place as one of the standout films of the 1990s. Directed by David Fincher, this psychological thriller is now celebrated not only for its gripping narrative and stunning performances but also for its dark tone and shocking plot twist.

The storyline immerses viewers in an unnamed, crime-laden city, where we accompany Detective Lieutenant William Somerset (played by Morgan Freeman), who is merely a week away from retirement. Joining him is the enthusiastic yet inexperienced Detective David Mills (Brad Pitt), who has just relocated to the city with his wife. Their investigation revolves around a series of grotesque murders inspired by the seven deadly sins, ultimately leading them to the enigmatic and sinister figure known as John Doe. Each murder in the film is meticulously orchestrated and deeply unsettling, though curiously, the on-screen violence is limited, with only one murder depicted during the film.

The Sole On-Screen Murder in Se7en

John Doe’s Death: Part of a Disturbing Strategy

Brad Pitt aiming a gun at Kevin Spacey in Se7en

Although the investigation deepens as Somerset and Mills close in on John Doe, he evades capture until the pride victim—a disfigured model who ultimately took her own life—leads him to surrender. Doe’s intention was to plead insanity if they escorted him to a location where the final two victims, representing envy and wrath, were hidden. As they travel, Doe reveals his twisted belief that he was chosen by God to illustrate humanity’s indifference to sin, resulting in his lack of remorse for his actions.

The film’s climactic twist reveals that Doe embodies envy, sparks a fatal chain of events, and shares a shocking revelation about Mills’ wife, Tracy. He insinuates that he has murdered her and placed her head in a box delivered to Mills. Doe manipulates Mills into embracing wrath, provoking him about his wife’s tragic fate until Mills ultimately succumbs to rage and murders Doe. This on-screen killing marks a significant shift in the movie and is strikingly the least brutal act depicted throughout.

John Doe’s Victims: A Portrait of Suffering

The Brutality of John Doe’s Third Victim

Theodore Allen as the sloth victim in Se7en

Every murder orchestrated by John Doe is marked by an unsettling creativity, forcing representations of various sins. The first victim, a grotesque depiction of gluttony, is an obese man forced to consume food until his death. Following him, a victim symbolizing greed is compelled to extract a pound of his own flesh under horrific duress.

However, Doe’s cruelest act may well be the prolonged torture inflicted on Theodore Allen, a drug dealer and pederast with a troubled past. Doe kidnapped Allen and imprisoned him for a year, confining him to a bed and leaving him in a deplorable state. Restraint was part of Doe’s gruesome narrative, as he positioned the police to find Allen exactly one year after his abduction.

When Mills and Somerset discover Allen, he is emaciated and surrounded by air fresheners to conceal the stench from neighbors. Although Allen was sustained by an IV during his captivity, doctors later declared him brain-dead, finding that he had bitten off his own tongue in a state of despair. This methodical torment ensured Allen was made to ‘live’ his sin in the most extreme way possible; while he was not innocent, his suffering at Doe’s hands contrasts painfully, establishing a legacy far more harrowing than death itself. Despite not being shown on-screen, Allen’s ordeal remains the film’s most haunting crime.

The Strategic Absence of On-Screen Violence in Se7en

Harnessing Imagination: The Specter of Violence Off-Screen

A bloodied John Doe raises his hands in Se7en

Se7en masterfully bypasses the need for graphic depictions of violence to convey its shocking essence. By relegating the violence to off-screen incidents, the film heightens suspense and engages the audience’s imagination, delivering a wound that’s often deeper than on-screen brutality could achieve. This artistic decision not only preserves the enigma of John Doe’s identity but also amplifies the audience’s discomfort about the unfolding events.

Ultimately, even though Doe’s demise is tied to another sin, it stands out as the least intense moment in the film—underscoring the sheer depravity of the other events. This strategic choice reinforces the film’s climactic twist, making John Doe’s death the only murder visibly witnessed, while paradoxically failing to serve adequate justice for his litany of sins.

Source & Images