Seeking Better High Fantasy Adaptations for the Big Screen

Warner Bros. Develops New Game of Thrones Film – Is This What Fans Want?

According to a recent report from The Hollywood Reporter, Warner Bros. is quietly working on a new Game of Thrones movie. Although not many have clamored for this revival, it seems that the allure of George R.R. Martin’s expansive world remains irresistible to studios in search of profitable franchises.

Middle-earth Films Also in Production

This upcoming movie is not an isolated project. Earlier this year, it came to light that Warner Bros. is developing two additional films set in the Middle-earth universe, the first being titled The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum. Producing this feature will be the original team of Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh, and Philippa Boyens, known for their successful adaptations of Tolkien’s works. This film will narrate Gollum’s journey between pivotal moments of Bilbo Baggins’ birthday and the Fellowship’s arrival in Moria, with Andy Serkis stepping into the director’s role after his iconic portrayal of Gollum.

A Morbid Curiosity for the Future

There’s a part of me that is certainly intrigued by the prospects of these new adaptations. The rich lore of Westeros offers countless opportunities for exploration, and Serkis’s legacy as Gollum is unparalleled. However, I must admit that there is a nagging concern regarding the proliferation of reboots and prequels that may overshadow innovative storytelling in high fantasy.

The Shift to Streaming Services

Recently, high fantasy has found its primary audience on streaming platforms. Services like Netflix and Prime Video have embraced the genre with adaptations like The Witcher and Shadow & Bone, alongside ambitious projects such as Greta Gerwig’s take on The Chronicles of Narnia. Moreover, Prime Video has opted for vast narratives with titles like The Rings of Power and adaptations of The Wheel of Time by Robert Jordan.

Why the Big Screen Deserves More

While these small-screen adaptations possess their merits, it is essential to recognize that high fantasy is inherently designed for cinematic experiences, complete with breathtaking visuals and grandiose storytelling. It’s disappointing to see so much talent focused on television rather than the theaters, where these stories can truly shine.

Overdone or Reinvigorated?

Despite the inherent potential for thrilling narratives within the realms of Westeros and Middle-earth, a concern lingers regarding the exhaustion of these stories. Without fresh perspectives or groundbreaking narratives, one must ask why a film should take precedence over a series. Curiously, why dedicate entire films to Gollum, spotlighting such a transient period in his life, when countless other rich tales from Tolkien’s works remain untold, like Beren and Luthien or The Children of Hurin?

Exploring New Fantasy Worlds

It seems Hollywood’s recent missteps, like the lackluster performance of Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves, could lead studios to believe that revisiting established franchises is the safest option. This mindset disregards a wealth of other remarkable stories waiting for adaptation, such as those by Robin Hobb, Brandon Sanderson, and V.E. Schwab. Even the successful Empyrean series by Rebecca Yarros is experiencing a shift toward television, a decision that leaves many questioning why cinematic trilogies are not being considered.

The Call for Innovation in High Fantasy

While high fantasy inherently carries substantial financial risks, the over-reliance on familiar stories muted in repetition does not capitalize on its potential. Hollywood should steer its focus toward discovering new narratives that resonate with audiences, rather than recycling the same beloved tales by returning to established epic landscapes. A fresh approach could yield not only success but possibly even exceed the triumphs of previous adaptations.

Source & Images