Rumors surrounding the highly anticipated Sherlock Holmes 3 project have sparked discussions regarding potential storylines. Many fans believe that Robert Downey Jr.’s portrayal of the iconic detective could greatly improve upon the narrative elements that were perceived as flaws in the BBC’s Sherlock. The tales of Sherlock Holmes, along with its beloved characters, have seen countless adaptations over the past century. Among the most notable on the big screen are Guy Ritchie’s films featuring Downey Jr. as the legendary sleuth.
The first film, released in 2009, introduces us to Holmes and his partner, John Watson, played by Jude Law, as they pursue the cunning serial killer Lord Blackwood, performed by Mark Strong. The film was both a commercial and critical triumph, paving the way for a sequel directed by Ritchie, titled Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows. This sequel escalates the stakes as Holmes confronts his arch-nemesis, Professor Moriarty, depicted by Jared Harris, culminating in a pivotal moment where Holmes is thought to perish. With a third installment potentially on the horizon, there’s hope that it can deliver a more compelling depiction of Holmes’ highly significant return, unlike the approach taken in the BBC adaptation.
Sherlock Holmes 3 Can Handle Sherlock’s Return From The Dead Better Than The BBC Show Did
Sherlock Holmes 3 Can Do Justice To One Of Holmes’ Most Important Moments
In the climax of Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, Holmes faces Moriarty on a Swiss balcony, where their confrontation leads to a physical struggle. Despite Holmes sustaining an injury, he bravely confronts Moriarty, culminating in both characters plunging to the depths of the Reichenbach Falls as Watson watches helplessly. However, as the film concludes, it’s revealed that Holmes faked his demise, having hidden away in Watson’s office. This opens the door for Sherlock Holmes 3 to effectively narrate Holmes’ reintegration into both his professional and personal life, an opportunity that the BBC’s Sherlock adaptation couldn’t fully explore. In that series, Holmes, played by Benedict Cumberbatch, creates a dramatic scene by leaping off St. Bart’s Hospital under duress from Moriarty.
Although the return itself was executed well, it fell short in explaining how Holmes orchestrated his own survival. The first episode of season three left viewers without satisfactory closure; it mocked fan theories and neglected to resolve the mystery of his fake death. In contrast, Sherlock Holmes 3 could provide a coherent narrative that details his revival and the events since, fostering a more engaging experience without diminishing the intellect of its audience.
Sherlock’s Return Was The Beginning Of The BBC Show’s Downfall After Two Fantastic Seasons
Sherlock Wasn’t The Same After The Reichenbach Fall
The BBC’s Sherlock gained traction as a modern interpretation of the detective’s world, achieving widespread acclaim during its initial two seasons. Its innovative integration of classic Holmes elements within a contemporary context captured the interest of many. However, after the pivotal “Reichenbach Fall,” the series struggled to regain its footing. Not only did it overlook the critical question of how Holmes faked his death, but the overall tone became erratic, with plots that were increasingly difficult to follow.
By the time season four arrived, the introduction of a new character, Holmes’ sister Eurus—a dangerous criminal mastermind—further complicated the narrative with convoluted plotlines. Although the return of Holmes could have been an exciting development, Sherlock faltered in its execution. In contrast, Sherlock Holmes 3 stands to learn from these missteps, potentially crafting a more engaging and believable arc for the Great Detective.
Related Articles:
Wallace & Gromit’s New Film Sheds Light on Tough Truths About the Franchise After 36 Years
4:32
Tim Allen Reveals Exciting Toy Story 5 Storyline Tease: “It’s A Really Cool Thing”
4:17
Hard Truths: Where to Watch, Showtimes, and Streaming Availability
2:52
Leave a Reply