
The St. Katherine’s Church murder serves as an engaging side mission in Atomfall, offering players valuable rewards early in the game. To embark on this intriguing quest, players should make their way to Wyndham Village, the second area accessible after navigating through Slatten Dale, where the crime unfolded.
Unlike traditional gameplay, Atomfall presents a dynamic narrative with multiple endings and no rigid objectives. Players must employ their investigative skills, gather vital clues, and forge their path through the mystery.
This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide on successfully solving the St. Katherine’s Church murder while maximizing your rewards along the way.
How to Solve the St. Katherine’s Church Murder in Atomfall
Your journey begins in Wyndham Village, which can be accessed by interacting with Nac, a character located in Stallen Dale. Upon arriving in Stallen Dale, head left until you discover two dilapidated structures; Nac will be situated in the one on the right, playing his guitar. Speak with him, and he’ll point you towards Wyndham Village’s entrance. Alternatively, you can directly head to map coordinates 29.0 E, 79.4 N, located on the northern edge of the region.
Investigating St. Katherine’s Church

Upon entering the area, follow the road to find St. Katherine’s Church (map coordinates 33.0 E, 78.8 N). Inside, you will encounter Maisie Higgins, who has tragically been stabbed to death, while Vicar McHenry and Pamela Shaw are investigating the scene.
When you talk to Vicar McHenry, he will implore you not to report the murder to the Protocol, claiming that the locals will handle the situation. Engaging in conversation with either him or Pamela will yield minimal leads. However, examining Maisie’s body will uncover a note that points to a cottage near Mereview Hotel in Wyndham.
Chasing the Clues
Proceed northward and, after crossing a stream, locate a small cottage adorned with ominous warnings such as “Keep Out” and “Trespassers will be shot” (map coordinates 31.4 E, 82.2 N).The front door is locked from the inside, but you can enter through a side entry. Inside, you will discover a note labeled “Recent Movements”, indicating that Vicar McHenry had assigned Maisie the task of surveilling someone she had identified.

Continue along the stream until you encounter a white camping tent. Near this tent, scale the wall, and you’ll spot a deteriorating structure that has a basement entrance to its right. Beware, as the area is inhabited by infected rats; it’s advisable to circumvent them and make your way into the basement swiftly.
Identifying the Murderer
Inside the basement, often referred to as the Brewery Cellar, search the area for a Molotov Cocktail Recipe, which can be used for crafting. Instead of heading right, explore the left side to find a small crawl space that leads to a chamber containing a note titled “Kill the One They Call Maisie”. This crucial document reveals that the murderer is Morris Wick.

He will instruct you to confront Morris and inform you that he is the shopkeeper at the Village Shop, located at map coordinates 33.3 E, 79.9 N.
Confronting Morris Wick
At the shop, you’ll have several options to choose from:
- Kill Morris
- Report him to the Protocol
- Ask him to leave the village
- Bargain with him
If you opt for the first two choices, returning to Vicar McHenry will earn you a key, granting access to his chest which contains an Atomic Battery.
Should you choose to side with Morris, he will reward you with a crafting manual and a Training Stimulant.
Maximizing Your Rewards
To ensure you collect all potential rewards, follow this effective strategy:
- Bargain with Morris first to receive his rewards.
- Eliminate Vicar McHenry at the church and take his key.
- Open his chest upstairs to obtain the Atomic Battery.
- Report the murder to Captain Sims at the Village Hall.
By adhering to this method, you can secure all available rewards for this mission.
That summarizes everything you need to know to unravel the St. Katherine’s Church murder mystery in Atomfall.
Leave a Reply ▼