Sonic The Hedgehog Franchise Director Reflects on Design Backlash Five Years Later: “We Listened to Those Opinions and Took Action”

Jeff Fowler, the director of the Sonic the Hedgehog franchise, has recently shared his thoughts on the significant backlash regarding Sonic’s initial design, five years after the release of the first movie’s infamous trailer. When the trailer debuted, fans were quick to criticize Sonic’s appearance, particularly noting his small eyes, lack of gloves, and human-like teeth, leading many to refer to him as “Ugly Sonic.”In response to the overwhelming feedback, Paramount chose to redesign the character and postponed the film’s release from November 2019 to February 2020. This redesign appears to have positively impacted the franchise’s trajectory, with early anticipation for the upcoming Sonic the Hedgehog 3 indicating it could be the best installment yet.

In a recent interview with Deadline, Fowler emphasized that the original design and its subsequent revision highlight the production’s commitment to listening to fan feedback. He reflected on these events as an integral part of the franchise’s history, amidst various challenges such as filming Sonic 2 during a pandemic and navigating recent labor strikes in Hollywood during the creation of Sonic 3. Here’s what he had to say:

Every movie is going to face challenges and obviously we had some very public ones with the redesign, but all that stuff has just become part of our story. And it’s something that I sort of champion. We now have this amazing relationship with our fans. They obviously voiced some opinions, and those opinions were heard and addressed. It’s now just become part of this great relationship with them.

It’s amazing to me that we’re here on a third film, and we’ve made a TV series. I mean, Sonic 2 was made during a pandemic. Sonic 3, we had a writer strike, we had an actor strike. We have always found a way through.

Insights from Fowler’s Remarks about Sonic’s Redesign

The Impact of a Game-Accurate Design

Sonic the Hedgehog movie redesign poster

The remarkable success of the first Sonic the Hedgehog film can be attributed not only to its appeal across all age groups but also to Jim Carrey’s standout performance as Dr. Robotnik. However, the efforts to redesign Sonic certainly enhanced the film’s allure. Had the inaugural movie failed at the box office, there might not have been sequels or the anticipated Knuckles spinoff series on Paramount+. This would mean the current cast of Sonic the Hedgehog 3, featuring notable voices such as Idris Elba as Knuckles or Keanu Reeves as Shadow, may never have come together.

Interestingly, what was once considered “Ugly Sonic” has since transformed into a source of humor. Recently, Paramount even offered an ugly Christmas sweater featuring the original design as part of their 12 Hours of Sonic 3 Giveaway. Additionally, the character made a cameo in the 2022 film Chip ‘n Dale: Rescue Rangers, portrayed by Tim Robison as an FBI agent, demonstrating the character’s playful evolution. This lighthearted take illustrates how the franchise has evolved while the redesign successfully fostered goodwill among audiences.

Evaluating Sonic’s Design Evolution and Audience Feedback

The Value of Fan Feedback

Shadow and Sonic from Sonic the Hedgehog 3 — Image by Yailin Chacon.

It’s clear that paying attention to fan feedback regarding Sonic’s original design was vital for the success of Sonic the Hedgehog 3. The more game-accurate representation of the character is just one of several elements that showcase the series’s gradual embrace of features from the original games. With Fowler and his team committed to refining the franchise with each new edition, there’s a promising outlook that Sonic the Hedgehog will continue to resonate with audiences for many years to come.

As a captivating addition, Sonic the Hedgehog 3 is expected to include two post-credits scenes, setting up exciting prospects for the franchise’s future.

Source: Deadline

Source & Images